×
You've used up your 3 free articles for this month. Subscribe today.
Circumstantial Evidence Sufficient to Defeat Summary Judgment
Loaded on May 15, 2000
published in Prison Legal News
May, 2000, page 33
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals held circumstantial evidence in a retaliation claim is sufficient to defeat summary judgment in prison officials' favor. While confined at New York's Bare Hill Correctional Facility, prisoner Gregory Gayle filed a grievance stating he heard prison staff praising the guard who had used a ...
Filed under:
Retaliation for Filing Grievances,
Disciplinary Hearings,
Retaliatory Discipline,
Appointment of Counsel.
Location:
New York.
Full article and associated cases available to subscribers.
As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login
More from this issue:
- Testing Testing: Sweat Patch Under Scrutiny, by Lara A. Bazelon
- The History of Prison Legal News, by Paul Wright
- PLN in Court, by Paul Wright
- $880,000 In GA Medical Neglect Suit
- From the Editor, by Paul Wright
- Texas Prison Dentist Settles Dentures Suit for $3,150, by Jon Michael Withrow
- $600,000 In GA Medical Neglect Suit
- Colorado Denies Hepatitis C Treatment as Too Expensive, by Bob Williams
- DOJ Investigates CMS Health Care at Missouri Prison, by Michael Rigby
- Washington Civil Commitment Held in Contempt, by Tamara Menteer
- From the Editor, by Paul Wright
- Louisiana Prosecutors Have "Ties" to Murder, by Gary Hunter
- New Mexico Private and State Prison Phone Rates Challenged
- CCA Prison Under Gang Control: Death and Injury Suits Filed, by Gary Hunter
- Five Lawyers in Peru Freed, by Heriberto Ocasio
- Black Prison and Jail Employees Win Discrimination Lawsuits
- $150,000 Judgment Against Prison Officials Upheld
- 2003 Washington Legislative Round-up, by Lonnie Burton
- Post Conviction Update, by Reaves, Jr, Walter M
- Washington DOC Personnel In-Fighting Results in $230,000 Settlement
- Retaliation, Publication Ban and Lack of Dental Care States Claim
- Bad Water Causes Florida Prison Evacuation
- Investigators Probe Ohio Paroles-For-Sale Scam
- Book Review: Inmate Litigation, by John E Dannenberg
- FDOC Hazardous to Prisoners' Health, by Mark Sherwood
- Good and Bad News in Haverty Aftermath: No Good Time for Ad-Seg Placement, by Phillip Kassel
- Prison Labor's Race to the Global Bottom, by Zack Roth
- Palestinians Still Imprisoned Despite Peace Process, by Inaki Markiegi
- Transfer Moots Wiccan's Claim
- Texas Death Row Hunger Strike
- Comatose Prisoners Expose the Limits of Mercy, by Gary Hunter
- California to Outfit All Prison Guards With Stab-Resistant Body Armor
- International Perspectives on the Death Penalty, by Julia Lutsky
- Nevada Religious Group Gets Federal Money to Help Prisoners, Delivers Nothing
- Claim For Prospective Relief Moot Upon Release, by Ronald Young
- Grievance Procedure Not Required by PLRA in All Lawsuits
- Wrongfully Convicted in California and New York Awarded Damages, by Michael Rigby
- City Liable for Jail Sex Shows and Nude Dancing
- Heck Does Not Bar Evidence in Shooting Case, by Ronald Young
- New Mexico Supreme Court Rules in Disciplinary Hearing Remedies
- $115,000 Settlement in Seattle Jail Strip-Search Suit, by John E Dannenberg
- Absent Plain Error, Objection Necessary to Preserve Issues
- Magistrate Judge Recuses Self in BOP Medical Treatment Case
- Denial of Medication Precludes Summary Judgment
- Dismissal Reversed for Determination Whether Prisoner Was Misled About Remedies
- Grievances Exhausted When Prison Officials Fail to Respond
- News in Brief
- Summary Judgment Reversed on Fact Issues of Guards' Failure to Protect Prisoner, by Bob Williams
- 522 Days in BOP Ad Seg States Due Process Claim
- Jury Awards $700,000 to Chicago Jail Worker for Sexual Harassment
- California Parole Rescission Panel's Disagreement With Granting Panel Fails The "Some Evidence" Standard, by John E Dannenberg
- Transsexual Prisoners Have Privacy Right
- Exceeding Doctor's Work Limit Order Actionable Under Eighth Amendment, by John E Dannenberg
- BOP Electric Musical Instrument Ban Upheld by DC Circuit, by John E Dannenberg
- New York Prisoner's Assault Claim Headed for Trial
- Guard Proclaiming Open Season On Prisoner Actionable, by Ronald Young
- Wyoming Prisoners Win Summary Judgment for Increased Security, by John E Dannenberg
- Illinois Governor Announces Death Penalty Moratorium
- Dismissal Without Notice for Untimely Service of § 1983 Complaint Is Abuse of Discretion
- Federal Tort Claims Act Suit Limitation Construed in Medical Suit
- Circumstantial Evidence Sufficient to Defeat Summary Judgment
- Ninth Circuit Holds Exhaustion of Remedies Mandatory Before Filing Suit
- Chief Medical Officer Liable On Medical Policy Decisions, by John E Dannenberg
- Kentucky Jury Awards $2,641 to Estate of Murdered Prisoner
- Retaliation Claim Satisfied by Existence of Major Misconduct Citation, by John E Dannenberg
- Exposure to Second-Hand Smoke States Eighth Amendment Claim
- No Jurisdiction for Interlocutory Appeal Where Evidence Is Disputed in Failure to Protect Suit, by John E Dannenberg
- Inquiry Required Before Dismissal for Failure to Pay Partial Filing Fee
- Warrantless Police Search of Prisoners Cell Upheld; Damages Awarded For Retaliation
- No Appeal Bond Required for Indigent Colorado Litigants
- PLRA Applies to Prospective Relief; Fees Are Not Prospective Relief
- Loss of Good Time for Kansas SATP Refusal Upheld, by Bob Williams
- South Dakota Attorney Fee Award of $106,877 Upheld Under PLRA
- Court Modifies Education Plan for Rikers Island Youth, by David Reutter
- Oregon Contraband Conviction Reversed
- BOP Prisoners Eligible for Drug Treatment Without Documented History of Abuse
- News in Brief
- New Jersey Sex Offender Treatment Statute Creates Liberty Interest
- Qualified Immunity Denied in BOP Transsexual Strip Search, by Bob Williams
More from these topics:
- New York Prison Officials Found Routinely Violating HALT Act With Overuse of Solitary Confinement, Feb. 15, 2025. Disciplinary Hearings, Control Units/SHU/Solitary Confinement, Cruel and Unusual Punishment.
- Fourth Circuit Decision on Claim of Retaliation for Exercising First And Sixth Amendment Rights Highlights Police Corruption, Feb. 15, 2025. Police Misconduct, Retaliation for Filing Grievances.
- Colorado Supreme Court Announces When Deciding Defendant’s Pro Se Motion Requesting Counsel on Postconviction Review, Trial Court Must Either Deny Entire Motion or Permit All Claims If Any Have Arguable Merit, Dec. 15, 2024. Appointment of Counsel, After Request for Counsel, Pro Se Issues.
- $25 Million Contempt Fine Prompts Release of Pretrial Detainees from Philadelphia Lockups, Dec. 15, 2024. Appointment of Counsel, Contempt (Civil Procedure), Bail/Pretrial Release, Fines.
- Indigent Defense: Appointed Counsel Does Not Mean Free Counsel, Dec. 1, 2024. Appointment of Counsel, Indigent Defense, Indigent Defendants - Fees and Expenses.
- In Oregon Case, Ninth Circuit Limits Pretrial Detention Without Counsel to Seven Days, Nov. 15, 2024. Appointment of Counsel, Pretrial Detention and Detainees, Speedy Trial Clock - Tolling of.
- Maine State Prison Warden Replaced As Misconduct Allegations Investigated, Oct. 15, 2024. Guard Misconduct, Disciplinary Hearings.
- Florida Jail Chief’s Firing Upheld, Retaliation Lawsuit Headed to Trial, Aug. 15, 2024. Retaliation for Filing Grievances, Consequences of Firing Appointed Counsel.
- Sixth Circuit Revives Ohio Prisoner’s Retaliation Claim That Guards Got Him Kicked Out of Religious Group, July 1, 2024. Religious Discrimination, Retaliation for Filing Grievances, RLUIPA.
- Seventh Circuit Affirms Dismissal of Retaliation Claim By Federal Prisoner Against Guard in Illinois Lockup Who Saw Grievance Against Him, July 1, 2024. Retaliation for Filing Grievances, Failure to Protect (General), Civil Rights Actions or Offenses/Bivens Actions.