Skip navigation
Prison Legal News
× You've used up your 3 free articles for this month. Subscribe today.

Seventh Circuit Rejects Prisoner’s 1983 Claim but Criticizes Controlling Precedent

Loaded on Dec. 30, 2015 by Derek Gilna published in Prison Legal News January, 2016, page 26
Filed under: Wexford Health Services, Civil Procedure, Appeals. Location: Illinois.

Seventh Circuit Rejects Prisoner’s 1983 Claim but Criticizes Controlling Precedent

by Derek Gilna

It’s not often that a federal appellate court criticizes the precedent that it feels obligated to follow, but that is what happened in a civil rights lawsuit filed by Illinois state prisoner Earnest Shields.

Shields sued prison ...

 

Full article and associated cases available to subscribers.

As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.

Subscribe today

Already a subscriber? Login

More from this issue:

  1. Two Suicides at Privately-operated Pennsylvania Facility
  2. Denver Wins Sexual Harassment Suit Filed by Former Jail Captain; Tenth Circuit Affirms, by Matthew Clarke
  3. Numerous Deaths at Nevada Prison Raise Questions, Concerns, by Christopher Zoukis
  4. Ohio Prisoner’s Estate Awarded $350,000, by Derek Gilna
  5. $183,000 in Settlements for Sexually Abused Pennsylvania Prisoners, by David Reutter
  6. Oklahoma Prisoners Develop Software which Could Save the State Millions, by Christopher Zoukis
  7. Conn. Guard Gets 90 Days, Probation for Sex with Prisoner
  8. Colorado Court Finds Book Limitation Policy Violates Prisoner’s Religious Rights, but Case Reversed on Appeal, by David Reutter
  9. Family of Prisoner Who Died from Allergic Reaction Settles Lawsuit for $2.4 Million, by Christopher Zoukis
  10. Federal Court Certifies Class-action for Thousands of Detroit Prisoners, Enters Default Judgment, by Derek Gilna
  11. Are We There Yet? The Promise, Perils and Politics of Penal Reform, by Marie Gottschalk
  12. Opposition to the Death Penalty Grows with High-Profile Support, by Christopher Zoukis
  13. Pope Francis Calls for Worldwide Prison Reform, Support and Hope for Prisoners, by Christopher Zoukis
  14. PLN Intervenes, Unseals Settlement in CCA Fair Labor Standards Act Case, by David Reutter
  15. Report: Nearly One in Four Exonerations Involves Crimes that Never Occurred, by Christopher Zoukis
  16. Getting the Money Out of Prison Reform, by Dan Berger
  17. A Clean Slate: Prisoners Taking Advantage of Tattoo Removal Programs, by Christopher Zoukis
  18. Criticism of Congressional Mandate to Keep Immigration Detention Centers Full, by Derek Gilna
  19. Report Calls for End of Welfare and Food Stamp Restrictions for Felony Drug Offenders, by Derek Gilna
  20. California Prisoner Exonerated but Now Faces Deportation
  21. President Obama “Bans the Box” at Federal Government Agencies, by Derek Gilna
  22. Washington State: Class-action Alleges DOC Policy of Denying Medical Care, by Derek Gilna
  23. Tulsa, Oklahoma Settles Four Wrongful Conviction Lawsuits for $810,000, by Matthew Clarke
  24. $130,000 Settlement in Minnesota Prisoner’s Medical Negligence Suit, by Matthew Clarke
  25. West Virginia Supreme Court Undermines Prisoners’ Right to Sue for Rape
  26. Texas Grand Jury Indicts Two Jailers in Prisoner’s Death; Others Face Discipline
  27. Tragic Death at Washington Jail Results in Changes, $1.3 Million Settlement, by Lonnie Burton
  28. Connecticut Prisoner Obtains Settlement in Civil Rights Case, by Derek Gilna
  29. Why are Alameda County Jails Forcing Women to Take Pregnancy Tests?, by Susie Cagle
  30. Texas Hospital Settles Suit over Improper Border Patrol Search for $1.1 Million, by Matthew Clarke
  31. Georgia: $453,000 Jury Verdict against Private Jail Medical Contractor, by David Reutter
  32. California Court Upholds Prisoners’ Convictions for Fatal Jail Beating, by Derek Gilna
  33. Seventh Circuit Rules Wisconsin Prisoner’s Religious Rights Must be Honored, by Derek Gilna
  34. Prison Legal News Settles New Mexico Jail Suit for $235,000, by Derek Gilna
  35. Study Finds Private Prisons Keep Prisoners Longer, Without Reducing Future Crime, by Peter Kerwin
  36. Seventh Circuit Rejects Prisoner’s 1983 Claim but Criticizes Controlling Precedent, by Derek Gilna
  37. Utah Judge Orders Jail to Stop Seizing Prisoners’ Money for Pay-to-Stay Fees, by Matthew Clarke
  38. One of the Largest Solar Power Companies in the U.S. has Ties to Prison Slave Labor, by Panagioti Tsolkas
  39. Michigan: Private Prison More Costly than State-Run Prison, Attracts Out-of-State Contracts, by David Reutter
  40. California Officials Reverse Position after Receiving Prison Phone Company Contributions, by Derek Gilna
  41. From the Editor, by Paul Wright
  42. News in Brief

More from Derek Gilna:

More from these topics: