Skip navigation
Prison Legal News
× You have 1 more free article available this month. Subscribe today.

Denial of FOIA Request for Complaints Against Immigration Judges Reversed

Loaded on July 28, 2017 by Christopher Zoukis published in Prison Legal News August, 2017, page 62
Filed under: Disclosure of Records, Immigration. Location: District of Columbia.

by Christopher Zoukis

The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals has reversed a district court’s order allowing across-the-board redactions by the government in response to a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request.

The American Immigration Lawyers Association submitted a FOIA request to the Executive Office for Immigration Review, a division of the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), seeking disclosure of records concerning complaints against immigration judges and the resolutions of such complaints. Federal officials produced the records but redacted the names of the immigration judges and other information. The district court upheld the redactions.

On appeal, the D.C. Circuit held the across-the-board redactions of the names of immigration judges did not satisfy the government’s duty to respond, and remanded that issue for the district court to reconsider the application of certain FOIA exemptions. Further, the Court of Appeals found the DOJ’s redaction of the records on the basis that they were non-responsive to the FOIA request, when there was no statutory exemption authorizing such redactions, was improper.

However, the appellate court upheld the DOJ’s redaction of the complaint resolutions involving immigration judges because they were not final opinions or orders, and thus outside the government’s responsibility to disclose under FOIA. The case was reversed in part and affirmed in part. See: American Immigration Lawyers Association v. Executive Office for Immigration Review, 830 F.3d 667 (D.C. Cir. 2016).

Following remand, the DOJ produced records that it had previously refused to disclose because they were non-responsive to the FOIA request. The case remains pending. 

 

Additional source: www.citizen.org

As a digital subscriber to Prison Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.

Subscribe today

Already a subscriber? Login

Related legal case

American Immigration Lawyers Association v. Executive Office for Immigration Review

Year2016
Cite830 F.3d 667 (D.C. Cir. 2016)
LevelCourt of Appeals
Appeals Court EditionF.3d

More from this issue:

  1. Banks Profit from Loans to Private Prison Industry, by Derek Gilna
  2. Florida: Trio of Con Artists Sentenced in Rule 35 Sentence Reduction Scam
  3. Study Finds Extreme Lack of Gender, Racial/Ethnic Diversity in State Courts, by Derek Gilna
  4. Seventh Circuit Reinstates Indiana Prisoner’s Lawsuit, Holds Prison Officials Prevented Him from Pursuing Grievances, by Lonnie Burton
  5. Denial of FOIA Request for Complaints Against Immigration Judges Reversed, by Christopher Zoukis
  6. Fourth Circuit Rules Lawsuit over Inadequate Prison Food Not Barred by Res Judicata, by Lonnie Burton
  7. Ethics Rule Requiring Post-conviction Disclosure of Exculpatory Evidence Adopted in North Carolina
  8. Use of Electronic Monitoring Skyrockets, by Christopher Zoukis
  9. Nebraska Supreme Court Holds Reporter Can’t See Executed Prisoner’s Drawings, by Christopher Zoukis
  10. Seventh Circuit: Two-month Delay in Ordering Biopsy Not Deliberate Indifference, by Christopher Zoukis
  11. Tennessee Sheriff Settles Lawsuit over Religious Proselytization
  12. Unlikely Criminal Justice Reform: How New York City Reduced Arrests and Slashed Prisoner Populations, by Lonnie Burton
  13. United Kingdom: 80% of Prisoners Aspire to be Entrepreneurs, Opportunity Fund Helps
  14. Man Smuggles Poison into Jail, Commits Suicide Following Arrest for Failure to Pay Ambulance Bill
  15. Fourth Circuit Clarifies Rights of Pretrial Detainees; $35,000 Settlement on Remand, by Christopher Zoukis
  16. Consensual Use of Another Prisoner’s Telephone PIN is Not Oregon ID Theft
  17. Seventh Circuit: Medical Deliberate Indifference Case Remanded, Loses at Trial, by Christopher Zoukis
  18. Dismissal of Personal Injury Claim for Damages from Malfunctioning Jail Gate Upheld
  19. Private Prison Firms Spend Billions of Taxpayer Dollars Acquiring Other Companies, by Christopher Zoukis
  20. Ohio Prisoners Build Computers from Spare Parts, Conceal them in Ceiling
  21. Illinois: Prison Guards Sued for Fatally Beating, Suffocating Prisoner, by Lonnie Burton
  22. Fourth Circuit Reverses Judgment in Favor of BOP in Deliberate Indifference Case, by Christopher Zoukis
  23. Tennessee Sheriff Pleads Guilty to Sexual Misconduct, Excessive Force Charges
  24. Alaska Prisoner Deaths Criticized in Report, Author Becomes New DOC Commissioner
  25. Report: “Culture of Racism,” Frequent Use of Force at Northern California Prison, by Lonnie Burton
  26. New York: Police Department Ordered to Produce Police Manual in Parolee Shooting Case, by Christopher Zoukis
  27. California Court Vacates Prison Infraction Charging Prisoner for Refusing Meals, by Lonnie Burton
  28. Disability Rights Group Slams Mental Health Program at New York State Prison, by Derek Gilna
  29. Nevada DOC Moves to End Discrimination against HIV-positive and Disabled Prisoners, by Matthew Clarke
  30. California Lifers with Possibility of Parole Entitled to SOL Tolling
  31. Policing for Profit: Law Enforcement Agencies Abuse Civil Asset Forfeiture, by Matthew Clarke
  32. South Carolina Appellate Court Upholds Prisoner’s Wage Suit, by Derek Gilna
  33. Widespread Abuses at Santa Clara County Jail; Three Guards Convicted of Murder, by Lonnie Burton
  34. Illinois Prisoner Fatally Shot after Standoff; Hostages File Lawsuit
  35. $6,500 Settlement after Ninth Circuit Reverses Summary Judgment in Retaliatory Ad-seg Case, by Lonnie Burton
  36. Incarceration Numbers Falling, Especially for Blacks, by Christopher Zoukis
  37. Ninth Circuit Reverses Revocation of Supervised Release Over Blog Post, by Christopher Zoukis
  38. Ninth Circuit: Warden Who Failed to Protect Female Prisoners from Sexual Assault Not Immune from Suit, by Christopher Zoukis
  39. Seventh Circuit Reverses Infraction for Failure to Allow Prisoner to Present Evidence, by Lonnie Burton
  40. California Appellate Court Reinstates Prisoner’s Mandamus Action Against CDCR, by Derek Gilna
  41. First Circuit Allows City to Include Prisoners in Census Counts, by Derek Gilna
  42. Eighth Circuit Rejects Qualified Immunity on Inadequate Nutrition Claim
  43. PLN Obtains $50,000 Settlement in Tennessee Jail Censorship Suit
  44. Texas Prisoner was Emaciated and Sick when Killed by Cellmate
  45. Supreme Court Lets Prosecutors Off the Hook for Withholding Evidence, by Derek Gilna
  46. Arkansas Prisoner’s Illegal Sentence Remanded Despite Filing Wrong Challenge
  47. Suicide at Texas Jail Results in Firings, Lawsuit, Investigation and Legislation, by Matthew Clarke
  48. Tenth Circuit Remands Two-year Sentence for Federal Probation Violation, by Christopher Zoukis
  49. Washington State Mental Health Agency Held in Contempt; $14 Million in Fines Levied, by Derek Gilna
  50. One of Tennessee’s Most Pristine Rivers Contaminated with Prison Sewage, by Panagioti Tsolkas
  51. Forced to Endure Extreme Heat, Prisoners are Casualties of Texas’ Climate Denial, Documents Show, by Candice Bernd
  52. Ohio Closes Prison Farms, Auctions Equipment, Plans to Sell Farmland, by Matthew Clarke
  53. From the Editor, by Paul Wright
  54. Breaking News: U.S. Attorney General Reinstates Federal Asset Forfeiture Sharing, with Conditions, by Derek Gilna
  55. News in Brief

More from Christopher Zoukis:

More from these topics: