ACLU v DOD DOJ Questionnaire Regarding Detainees 00000433
Download original document:
Document text
Document text
This text is machine-read, and may contain errors. Check the original document to verify accuracy.
Depar~ment'of J.~s.ti~~ Inspector Gener-al Q~~sJ:ionnaire R~gcu.din·g ~etctin~e~ O:OJ.-.oIG INVES'UG'ATIVE QUESTIONNAIRE . FOR REVIEW AND US.E O'NLY BYINDiVIDUAl FBI ~£SRONDENTS . • DO NOT·F6.~WARD·OR.DI$EMI~ATE . ,. QU,ESTIONNAIRE 10: test-OO.00043'3 .A,:s·aHh.e last time th~s;q~~tronni;tir~was !!a\(~~, ~ome r~quire_df;el~S;,t1av~. n9~ l;>e13n c9mpleted. Pleasla~re~Jew·yo.ur ri:$p:ol1ses. '. . A. " .. ... .'.~~' . . P~r$onal.Inf()r01atipn 'P~ease proviae·the following information: .~. f.lr.~ name' -2. M.ldAle In!V~r: 3: last name: 4. Eliter:ed. bn auty. DClte (EOD): '5:· ti:lp:eoi Ql';tisfo.nJFi~ld Office: :6~ ~4rrelJt jpb. title: J .. Dii'ect'dial b'ffide:t.elephone nuhiber; 8, FBI cell p1tooe: huml:5et: .Q. f$,:i: p~:rger nutnber~ . lQ•. ·Be$'t cQntact number ror you~ '6~7¢PERAC?REEMF~ir 6 de '7C,PER AGREEMENT 6&·1CPERAGREEMENT 6 &·7C ~ ~:rp SUJ1ERVlSOR'f SP.ECIALAJ)ENT 6 & 7C.PER,:AGREEIfI1ENT § ~.7C PER,AG.REEIVlE.Nr '6 '& 7d'p~R AGRE;,EIVfENT' 6 i& lCPERAc'fiREENiENt a :11. At,any. time aft.e'r-:5epterril:>er 11,'2001, C1id ye.u set'Ve':as meriib~r of ttie u.s.. Military, or as an. 'employee;or contractor or the FBI'or any other g,overnment agency;.- at Guantanamo Bay,;. CUb~j Iraq; Afgl1a~,i.st?!fT;'or'lr areqS 'COntroll~ py the ~ ...S. MilitClry qr a V.. S, int~lJige,n~~ s.er"{tc.e tn:qmnedion with \he . .9(9b~1 ~~r Qn setror.? @·yes 0 No 1.2.·. Enter the numb.er of tirne.syou. wer.e depi9y,e.d or·'asl>ig ned tSi· each of the fo,howing lo:catloris: .(Guantanamo Bay, 'cUba,;' 1racr,: Afghanistah;.or in any areas ~ontr'Dlled by fhe.U.s. r¥1ilitary or a U.S. intellig-en€~ ~erijce); 1· . ,For .each deployment .orasslfJ.i1ment .complete 'the' fol!owiJ'!9. secti.on. Location I'select oni!) D'ipJoYm~ntIkl:i5~igiJmeri~:~eg!lfi9i1.9r' bepl.~en~ 0·... ~5sign'rilllnte,n.ileil. on h ... iii:~q~ . . ~~ ~. ," .. or.·a~o!it abO.llt ~ 03/2.004 , .', 0.6/2.0.04 f;2a., What was.~ne~gen:e~al na~lir~ ~np p:ljrp'qs.~QfYQUrassignmS!rit.a'l1~ activities? INVESTIGATIVE lib. Please.provide.the'names of the"spedfic,camps~bases; or facilities where you' worked, Bt\~H1?AP IN.:r.ERNATIO.,NALA1;RPORJ, "~~l)' GI;IURf.Yn P~$PN, ~AMP.A:S'1~F,.q.MFi.BA~YLOJil i2~ N9t~; I,f lnfprm~tion' aQout '2i specific camli, Qase" or ~cj(jW i$ 'cIa:ssjfi~d ·ab'9V~ SECRET, p l~a~· th:eck her.~ 0, in.c1ud'e ih your ;answer that 'Y0~J' have "'attdj~.i9 nal illfo~ma~io.n t1a~.sified ·a.Qoye 'SECREf,'~' and, if you knOw, identify,'the:dassificatlon.lev'el, ticket, ,compartment, program,.,or.other· desigratbn tha~'?lPplles19 t~e !nformatlqn"l?o n9t lncluqe the addlt1ona.1 c!<;Isslfied InT(,Xmatfol1 In your OIGQ-004828 qu~stionnpire responses. bIG pers~lnnel with ,the, necessary clearance will contact you to reteive Name I:,12~,. Qkl It. Position YQJJ jp)ntly' irJ¢~lew";ri~i¢~r6~~t~~'j,yd~tai';e;~~-~~~~f:{~$~~~~~liC?~_NI------ ---"- ----:: { Q~ 0~ : ~i2f. Dld-¥o~j~ihtLVpian=ati;; iJ~t~in~ int~rVle~or-ih~rro~atib~ ~st~tegy; ;bj~iY.ei"6;: ta-cti,~-,with- ~on- -';' ) IFar personnel? ' 0No o Yes I. 1 I , :~i2g~~W~re:Yq~ ~ver~Qthi~~~inYb!v~ in"" i~~fn~,e int;r;(~~~:9F- int;r:r6g~ii9nS -Wii"h- ~po:FBi -~t~on_nil?-;. ~ -0 Yf;.~ -e No . ,: ------ -.- -.--- ---,- --:,- -------'--- - ---..-- ---.----- - - --- --- -- --- - - - - --,""- -'---, -- -- .. .-,~. ': .. ' . '".' • • . ; c . ' A. Training Prior to Overseas Deployment or Assig'ilme'nt i3. ~i(b{pu rec~iyi.~, ~iflY trainfn'g", .Insttucti\1l1, qqjui,c!alJ¢e spec;lficallY in pr.eppratjplJ for an'to.,f 'Y.9pr ove,i:'s,eas'd'ePloyrhent.s or-as.signments? 'eVes .' :ONo-Q:rJo' Not Retai'l 13a. Who provided thiS. training, instrucj:i6n" or guidcfnce"an'd Where did you rec.eive it? , F~I, F~LACA.DtMY:" :QUAN'TISZQ; VA. .. , 13'b: Desqri~e the SUbject pn which'you r,eceiv~ tl:ll~..trairTiJJg, Ins~ructIqn Q( g,uid?nc:;:e:. ARAB: OJLTURE AND .INTERVIEWING, VARIOUS LOGISTICS' BRIEFINGS ,OY~ ONo lS. In, preparation for any 'of your oOv.e'rsea's. dep.lhyinents or assignments,_ did you'recefv'e,any:traiJiing" instructIon, or guidance ,concerning the, standards' of conduct applicable to the treatment, intervl\=Wi qr' 'interr9gatJ98 QfQetai8~e"s ~y non-'FBI p~rs'pnl'\el? QY.es 16.m, preparation for any of your ov.erseas depI6ymer'its,,of. assigninentsr'did you re€eive-any lrainiFl9, instru<1iO,n,'or gl.!.\dC;lnC!=-concemjrm IJo{ba~ yOU' w~r:e'suPP!Jse~ 'tq'qo'ih9() 'obser;v.ed 'or ~eG!rd !ab~,l!t' the tr~atm:ent, interview,: 9r rnte,rrgg'ation of Mta.inees, py Fa.t: pe~(mn,~, which ygu beli'eVed t9 b:e inap'ptoprfate! !Jnpr:Qf~ssjQnai, c~er:c1Ye( 'aQ,u:.slv!,!" Qr"l..mla\NfuJ?, ONo 00.0 Not Ret~H 17vI'rJ (:lrepaI9t!on 'fqr ?lny'ot ·voIJr overseas' d~p!Qyments Qr C\sslg~m~l]t~, ~ld ypu r.~t:~N:~:anytrqfnrng,: i.[l$trJ..Ic.tion, or g,uidc\Ti'ce cql')~eming wliat Y.9l! w.~re;~_uppp,~~1. te;:i (1.0 if yOl! obsery'ep orhe,atd ;ab.p'l,lt the tr~~tmeht, iht~rvlewr 6"( InteJrQgatior1 of p~~jnees- ~ n'c;)il-FBI p¢r.sonnef, Which you believed 1:0 he inapprepriate, unp'ro{essional, mer<::iye, abusive( er _unlawful?' - OIGQ-004829 b6 b7C o Yes ONo (!)Oo Not Recall I !B.Traintn'g During Overseas Deployments or Assignments 18. During any of youroyerseas deployments or asslgnmentsr. dId you receive any training; Instructlon/ qr·g1J.i(tanG~conq~rnJng the:sta.nd 9rd.s 9fc~ndu.g: !:lPl?IiGable t9 th.e treqtment,irit~rview; or int!=r(O;gati(;m of detaln~es·by FBI- persqnnf?l? 19. D4nng ~ny.ofyour qver~.e?s,t1eploymentsor assfgnrnell~sidid you ,rec~lve ~ny·tr~Jt1lng, Instructlgl1, qr ~ujqanc~'c(;>nc~rningt.he··~tat;1dRr9.$9f c:onglJ.s::t ~pplicqble to tlr~tr.eatrn.~nf; jn~ervj~w,'Qr . interrcygat,o,n of (IetalM~s, nO,h-FBI p:erso'hn~I7' »V ·':29t Quring any; .of YQyr E?xrerseas .deploYlTlen!s br ~ss,gnmen~s, dld you. r~celve 'any trai'nlng ( (hStructlon-,.. Q.r:gu.rdqnce;ccmt~rning what you were··s.l:lpPQ.$~ to do if you obs~rved Qr heard auou,tt he: . Tr~atment, inteMeV:fi '(if' ir)t~tr.pgatioll of ~$t~inees t5.y FBI pet~liriel', whIch you b~lie:v~d to be inappropriate, unprofessional, coemiv..er abusive, or uhlaWful? ONe, :0"Do Not Recall , 21. Durihg any 'ofY9ur m/erseaS t1¢,ployrtlerits .or a$sjgtiri1eJits~ did you reteive any tre'lning, instltrctidn, '01' gUid'aliCe concerning what you: w,ere supposed to do if you bb'served or heard about the· . treatmeflt,. interview" or interrog,ation 'ofdetainees by non-FBI personnel, which you believed to Re !napprQpria~ej unprofE?ssiona.I, ~o~rciv.ej'<C!~u~iY,e, 'gr unlClwfull Ie. Ade'q~aeydf 'ONo TrainIng . ,22., In :your 'opinion,.dict" you r.eceive 'a,d~q'uate t~it)ing;l i nstruqioh, or 9tlida n~e relating to .stand atd 5: .of cohduCt by FBlahCl nett-fBI persbfmel re;latin,g to, treatment, interView, or interr.6g·atioh,6f .detaineesprlor to' y.our·deployment ,or asslg.nment7 (!) Yes 0 No di~ yqu r~e~ve pdegua.te, training; in?truCtjohj or'guiqAPce relatil1g to stapdC!rds ~t cQndlict b)'l FBL~nd non-FBt ·llersonn~l.relqtir)g to tr~tmeh~, 'Intervlew, qr Interr.ogatJQn of :,i.E3..in y'<?ur''t)pinioo, 'detainees.during your deployment or .assiQ limeilt? receive aClequate' traininy,. instruCtion, ofIfuitJifn'ce -<:oJi(erfling what :y'oLi were su pposed to ,do if ,y.ou observed 'or heard about the treatmentr. interview, or interrogation of -qetainees T by FB1,or OOri':FBI p'er~nnel;; that- yc;>u bei,ievetl was ]nClPpropriqte, u.npr~'fess.ionaIT . 24-..Iri 'y.ou(o.i:jibibn, :f:liil you OIGQ-004830 :coercive, abusIve, dr uhla'WfUl? o Y$ ~ No ,---------------~---------------------------_._------------------------_. Z4a. PI~as~ ~ escribe th~ W~ys:tl} w.hich yeu, b~ '~Y,e the t.r~ining, instruction 0r.9 uiq an~e was ' inad,equat~: CONSID.ERIN~, THAT FQllQWIN~ THE CHAUIl OF..COM,MAN.O I~ UND!=~T<:r(;m TO' ~E THE _.!".~~f3<?~R.~I~ ·~~~~~C.q.ll ~'t:1_~~~ ~l}.~E~ ~~P'I!!~~~,h:~~~I~~NG_·~S)'!~c:.E?~~'3_'( [9'3- ~t\I~ ~~~~~s:: _ 2~. <op~icin'al) In what ways. q30.the.FBJ .ilTiprov,e. ttaining' on tbis .~i.Jbjea farfu.tute ~epioYrnents'or 'assig nrhents? (:ommen~~ -- ; - - - - - - - - - - - - . , . - - - . . , . - - -I 26.. P..Ieqse pr()vi~e:! any. apqifiona.! iJifoTt)1?ltio.n, ~9n,cer.'1ing·traj.ning Tqf·oyeJ;,Sea.s :9~pIQym~nts dr' 10. p.ss.iMtn~nts of f~I. p¢rs.qn.tiel YQ.u .b"'ejIi~Ye is televant, . ...... ··I.m?...J'Q'l..... ~~itp~~-~~ .~~.•~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~;.. :!. '.: ~~~~~ .IntroA~c~lc:>n ~9 ~al1:,~I~:. I.n tlJl~ se~tion;. W~ ,a~e .!?~ekin9 lrtforyn~tion regardjng.,~ Wig~. r~.SJg·e of , 'inletVfew Dr' ·interrog·~~lp·ri tectiniqlJes. and t:>ther j.y peS'; Qf d¢taine,e treat(JJ'eflt :!:illieg.ed fo naVe ptcu rre:d.. 'Yp'~ ~hoWld h(jt:a~·sunie,1lts.t b~ause..w,e, are'.asklri~f~bo'ut a 'particular tethhiqu¢ or ptacti.te( th'$t,w~ nav~ ,co'hdudecl" that "It: rn fact ·occurred. We 'receg nlze that some of these techniques:or practlces mel)! at tTmes be,.n~~~psary for'saf~ty 911d SC;C.!.lxity'Jn a de.te,ntion setting.. ~[r.?ldd~10n;)/"{~ recognjze th~t:~orneoqh~s~ ~~ch~l~rlJ~§·Of. 'PrqC~(G'~ rt)~ay' ~~lV.e b~'~h aUJt)p!lt~q for O;~.~ P'Y mlllt::lry Pf'gtpe'r g'o~e)"nment .p.~r:s~r"net With fesp~ tQ 'each .jdentlfied teC;hltiqu.6[ P~ctiC~t~o.r type of co iidu c.t d escrjbed oeloWr we are se~ki~g' information 'about its occurrence ·during..or in :connedion with the inter-viewor interrogation of a ~~~!,,~ei' or ~Hrlrm. t"'~:d~t¢.nti~ll'~f.~' de~!!1e~.!?~v~nd:Wha~ls, ne~~~ for ~~f~W ~np':~CHrity, Itr .ttj~t ;t9.ntexvw~ W.III a}* y9.lJ to te.1i '"'~ wh~.ther(jtJ~ gr tnpre .aftne, fQIIQWlll'g ~!;ltetrre.rit~ ari;.,tr!Je: 1. I personally,pbserl1e(j thiS tondJ'~t. 2. I obser.vecrdetainee(s) in a cond itiol'l that le(!' me to believe .that this' conduct had .oceurred; ~e.t.aln:~~{ s) 'told me: t.~at th I!>·~ond.t,Jc.t.n'?~ 'pc;purJ:e.'d.; 4.. Othe'rs'Wh'g ppse~ed this ~Ol1du.~t <;l~~~[I~ep i~ to rrt¢l. 5.'. r hay~ releVi30t jr)fotmcitiOii c1ci'ssified. a:bOV¢}'S.Ec;RET" . 'fi. I nev.ei',6bserv.ed -this conduct nor'hea'td about it frbmsomeone who.did. a. a. 0 I pl.'lTsOnaHy obseriJeCl this tonaud. In:a ;cond ItioFt "that led me to, b~lieve Co 0 Detainee(s),.told me that this <;;c:>ha uct, nad .o.ctui-'rErl. b. 0 td. 0 e. 0 lI.observed detalnee(s) thanh's coh,dUct had .Qccu'rr:ep. Others· whe ooseiiled this cOridtJtt described it to m·e. ~ have ·r.eleYanf Information 'classified above "SECRET". OIGQ-004831 l1J 0' II ~e\ler '2&'. observed this conduct nor heard about' it fro~ someone who did. Qepriving ~ detainee Of clpthing a. 0 I per:st:maUy observed this conduct. b. 0 1 bbse'tVedcietaih~e{s). in a cbndition:th~t led me' to b~li~ve tni'lUhis c9hqu~t ha~oc¢urred. ,c. 0 m~tainee,(s)'told me that this conduct had ;octur(e'.d. d. 0 Others' who .observed this conduct described it to me. e. 0 I have rele)/2uit information classified abo:v.e, "SECRET!l. t: 0 1. never observed this'conduct nor heard about it from someone who did. 19,., DepriVing -0 'detajJiee:'or:sl~ep; er inter.ruptifl9 sleep' by frequent cell relocation? 'Or other-methods D r pe-rso tlall't;-dbse"rv.ed Jhls,:cQIJ~uc.t. ,b:. 0 1obse'rv.ed Cl¢ta,in.-ee(~) in :'a)::ohditibri that led me to_ believe :tli'at thrs conduct bad :occUrre((.. 1'1', ¢. o IDet~i~~~(s}-t~jd me'that this,£or1duct had,occurre9. 0 tItherS' Who observed thIs cond uct des'ctibed It tb me. e'. 0 r have relevant iof(:o'rmation dassifiea £iboye "SEeRS",. d, f. ~ 1 never o.Bserved, t his :conduct nor"heard :about it from-someone'who, did. ..... 30. Beating a det~lnee a. 0 I b', C. d. e: l~; 111 e:tr ~his condUct. pE;~sPnaIlVQ~iS;erv -~------------_._--------- 1. obse',rv~d dE:ftcHnee.(~) In 'a:conditlon th,at lec:t, me tb b~lIev!= thatthls conduct had occurred, o lDetainee(s),tdid nie that thiS: conduct had :O.ccun:ed. o latherS: Whoob,Seht o II lia\Je :releyant ltinorniatlon tl~~'si.fied ab.o~~ ".SECRET". o-'.. J1 never . --.. observed .... .. ............. t his:condtiet nor heara aboUt it from som'eone,who dld. "...~ - , ~ -', 9,. Please proVide the ap'p roxlmate time frame.:durlng, which thIs conduct 'occurr:ed. Frorn,Q.4/10M tg, d4/2bM -, Doc> NQ~ . Rec;:all OIGQ-004832 h. THe .detaioee(s) .treated in tliis way were.lodltea at the lime in: 1 0 Guailtanamo 20' Iraq 3 '0 Afghanistan 4 .Qt{l¢r Lo~t.ion d ~ 0 Qt>, NQt, &~II i" ~Iease .rd~ntjry the deta,in~(s)' by name an~ number: DQ NOT RECALL j. Please identifY, the J5erS:bh(.s) who :treated the d~tairiee(s} in this manner, ir'i¢lud iog their name(s) and government.agency,(les): ' 'D.EJ:".AJN.~E, (A P,o.,UtE :OFF~C~P-YWA~ ARRE~T-ED By L~~AL IR.Aq~ p:.oU~E: tFJ~,P'M ANOTHER -VILlA.GE) AND Tl)RN~D 'QVE~T0 THE POLISH SOLQIERS AT !=AMP BABYLON BEFOr?,E BEiN'G TRANS,FERREQ,TO US, CUSTODY AT ABU,GHYRAIB. OEfAINEE CLAIMED. HE WAS BEATEN BY-THE SOlD1ERS AT THE CAMP AFTER HE WAS ARRESTED. THE 'DETAINEE'S CON DITION WAs' 'VERBAllY REP.ORTEEfTO' OFFICIALS ATTHE PRISON ANO IT WAS REQUESTEO,THAT HE WAS ~IVEN",MEDI¢ALTRi:ATM'E~J, DETAli'J'EE"S fACE WAS: &RUIS'E'O:ANb,sW0LLEN. " . ~ P.lea~, ii:fe!l~lf.y,~.r1,'co~!ler F~~ persqnl1el :qr n0!1"Fi?1 per~!,>nn~l W~CJ'9,b~rved qetai,n~e~~J tr~eed, h:lt~ls mCinner,Jnclydjng their narnel:» 'irnL~,gen~y(ies)~ SPECIAL AGEN I.- lnis,condUa: .occurred, i'n c6miectio(1 wfth: I :f: @ One detaihee 2 ~b ,Sev,eral detainees (.t-4.) ;3,Q M~l)Y de,tai.I'J,~,es (n:!~r~ thCln 4) II J 4: '0 DQ N<jt R,e9'!11 b6 b7C ' m. '(OptI911~1) Pl~se d~ribe'the'r~le\lafit ~irc.umst~.n,€es in mpr:e'CIetail:, .31 .•Using" water'to prevenr ~teathins by ,a aeta i neje ,or to, J:r..eate the sen.sation of"drow.ning a~ [j I personally observed this..conduct. b, D ['observed' detainee(sJ In a,cond itlon' that led 'me.to bel ie)Je that- this cand uct had ,oec;u rred., «;:.. ' o 'Detalnee(s) told me that 4: D. ttl Is cand uct h,ad '9.c~u~ra;l. Q~her:s who o~served '~hls ceod uct des~ri.be9 e. 0 J h!3ve rer~ya[i~ J: I~r it ~Q [Jl~•. i,nT<?rma~!on' c!as~ifieQ p~9ve' "$,EC~ET\ i never ol;?s,e,rved t,hJ$ ,cQl)q!Jet.nor heard ,aoqut'lt from,sQmeqne'wl1o did. '32. U~irtg hands, rope, Qr·anythIn.g el$,e. l:,q ~hbK~ Qf strangje'a 'de,tainee, OIGQ-004833 .. .. 0 I personally observed thls,.conduct. b. 0 I observed detainee(s) in a'condition that led me to believe thatthis conduct had.occurred. c. 0 D~tainee(s) told me th,at thi?- condl:let had ·Qccuf.red~ d. 0 qth~t? Who olJ!?erv~d thl$ condu~t.l;I~sqlbed It; to me: , ________._. _____ e. 0 I have refevant information c1asl?i'fjep ~~_ove"'SEC~~J':., ___ f: [tf r n.~v~r qb,~erved this ,t9npu~t nor h~rd 'a b,04~ it from.;5qm~.oneiWhod i9, - 'a~ , ";33-. ThreatenIng a., q othJ~r a,etlon to ,cause phy~lcal pain"lnjury'r dlsflgur,emelitror'deattr L personally observed this conduct. b. 0' r observeddetalnee(s) In aCQnd'ltlon'that led me to belleye that- this Gonduet had 'Occurred. <::,' 0 Det~i[lee(sj tqld me th~t this,~onduct hpd :occurred.. <L 0 OllIer:? whp ·op$ef.v~d -t.~i~ <;<:Hr<!u5ft-de~erfQe9 It to fJ)e.; e., D I h9Y~ rel~v.a:rit Il)f~rm.a:t19n, fl~:rs.sJfle<;i Cl~(;>ve. "~SECRET'! ~ f. ItT I Il~v.~r qb~.er\(t;:c1 this ;c;ondU,l:;t ,nor h~rd abo,at, it 'from 5qm~9t1~WhQ di9. :~, Oiher tr~a.tmel1~ qr ::icti011.,.cau~iilg;Sigllif~ht phys.I~! pa1t'i qr' Ihj\JiJ', pr t~using .i:lis~gli(~m~nt9i' :death per~naUY opserved thl~ ,t;onq4Ct. '\1: 0 I b', o hoJ:>se.rved detainee.~s.) in ,a''c9nd n;ion that led me to- believe' tha,t-tIJis co.np~ret ha9 OCGurrep.. c., 0 D~tain~($Hqld m.~thC!t t{li$ cpndu'!=t l'!i;l'd 'o'q:yrre&l, d. D qthers-lA.!no bb~erv.~~·~hIS c-qnd!-!ct d~s~rlbed lito m~ . " e;, t, 0 r haVe releva-tit [-n'forrrta~ion classified c!lb9V¢: J'S'E,CRET". 0 t O,!=v¢r 9.b.s~hle(r this~C9hdu~t np{h~r~ .abp]J~: it from ',sometlne.. who, Ifid, 35. Placing a' detainee:on a hot 'surfare or burning' a:detainee· a'. 0 I· per~.na.lly obseryed thi~:c;qndu~t. . .b: D I~01;l,serv.ed detC}'ln~e(s) In ·aTQnd.itlpnr~* leq me .~o' b~lIeve lhat·thls con:duct h:ad nq:::up:$d., I • . <;:. 0 IDetaine~(s.) tqld rn~ tngf thrs cpnq.uct hgld Q~c.urrecj, d.. D 9~hers who o~~rved this cO!l~uct d,e?f=ribe.q i~ to IJJ¢;' .... ... .. .. ....... .. . .... .. .. .. .. . .. .. .. ...... _.... .. .. .. ~ ..- .. V<._ ., -. OIGQ-004834 . L have relevant Information classified above '!SECRET" . '" e. f: 0 0 , ., I never observed thisxonduet nor·heard·about it from' someone who did. .36.. Using 'shackl~s or()th~r r.estraints il') a pr9h;mged m9nn~r a. 0 I p¢.rsOJiany·ob~fYed this·c6f1C1uct. U)Dserved det:afne~(s). in a cbnd itiorn.bat led me to believe thatlhis tonduGt d. 0 0 0: e. q I have relevant inlbrmation classified a bo~e: :·:SEGRET·o". f. 0 I ne.ver:observed thls.:cond uet nor heard 'a bout It from 'someone, who did. .15 • d. haa 'o,a.currea, Detainee(s} told 'me that this. to",d'utl had .occurred. others' who observed this (,;(jnduct described it to me. 37;. R¢q.uJring :a deta~in~~·,tQ m~intaiI11.,or restr:aining a oetc;ljne~: inT a stressfl,ll or painful pO,s,iti9h ,a. D I p~I'sonally ob'$erved this conduct. b. 0 I observed detainee(s) In ,a co'nd ition that led me to believe thatthis condu.ct had -oecur-red., c; o !IJetainee.(s') tQld me that this condu.ct had ,occurred. ,d_ O 0 e. Others who obsetved thiS conduct o~cribed if to me. I have relevant: information dassified a'boVe "S·ECRET'!·. f. I~f I never observed this-~condud nor heard about'it from someone who did. 3'8. FOfl:~rng a.d~tajnee to P17rfon;n demClnding physical exerdse a. b. t: d. e; f. o II personaliy db served ,this. .cO.tldUct. o II ohserv.ed "detaihee(s) ih .a 'Cond ition that led me: to belieye .that this: conduct had .occurr~d. o IDetaine~,(s) told m,e that this GondLict mId :o«::currect. , o IOthers' who QbserVed thIS con'duct.described It to me. o II' have relevant information, classified aboVe. "SECRET". o if never observed this 'conduct .nof·hear'd -abo,ufif frorn·Someone who did.. OIGQ-004835 i '39. Using .electrica"1 st'loJ:k.6n a detainee. II 0'. b, ,. 0 I personally observed this..conduct. 0 Lobserved" detalnee(s) in a,coOOltloO' that led me to believe that tills conduct: had ·ocCurred. o 'Detaj!1ee(s) tl?ld me that this cerxh!c~ had ·oECUr.r~. 1, 0 OtlJe~ w!w o~seryeq t,~ls cqndl,lct descri.~ed l~ t9 m~ e. 0 t. hav~.rekwant fn"formatjo"n ~lassjfie;d ,al;l"ove '~SEG.REr\ I: 0 r never o~St;:.rved thjsTonduCt.nqr i)eard abo!.)t It frQm someon~:who did. 40. Threatening to use eletlriajl :"5hock'on' ~detair:i!2-e ... • •• . 0 I persOnally observed this.conduct. b, 0 I observed detafnee(s) in a cordition that led me to. believe that fhls conduct had :occurred. c. 0 Detalnee(s)-told me that this conduct had .occurr.ed: 11:. 0 ~tl:lers who observed th,is C0l1duGt descri~~ it. ~o. meD.> hav.e.r~!evC!nt lr,1.f9rm~tjon cJqs~fHed. ab.ove '~SECRET~', 1 o 'I nev~r ob~e~~~"t~ls:a;lr.idU(;:t nor tr~r4 :about It .from sorpeolle"wh.o.dl,d. .~ . -~ , , .' 41. IilteritionGillY defciyh,'g ordeil~ing ;deta'jne~ m'edic.al alr~. 0 I personally observed thls.coJiduet. b: 0 I,obseived detafnee{s) in a coroiti0n that led me' to believe that lhis- Condud had .ocCurred. c. 0' p-etainee(s) told me that this conduct had occurr.ed. d. o IOt,her.s who ~served t~lS'co.n:ctu~td~Cf.lbedIt! ~9 me,. e. o It. ~a.\le ~rev:a!1l' il1torrT\a~ion c1assifi~ above "S'EGRI;f'\ f. o it o.ev~r,o:Q*rve4 tnf~'"CpnQ4~~ J19r .hearg.:aQ91;lt- it. ,tram S9m~PJ!~ \yh,9 4J<!, 0, . , 42-. HoOding or blindfoldIng a 'detajnee other. than during tr.anspo(1atkll; a. 0 , 1. perso'naHy' otiseived, tfHs ,e:onduct. b. 0 c, d d. d . 'observed detalnee(s) in a.cohdi1Joh that led me to believe.thatthis ronduct hat! DcdJrr:ed. iDetainee(s) told me that this conduct had occurred. !othera who observed this cond uct described It to me. OIGQ-004836 S 1 " · , - t: l~flI never observed this conduct nor heard about it from someone who'did. :~3. supje9:ing a detQinee t<:! extremely cold or hot room tempet<;ltures for extended periods 0 b. 0 c. 0 d. 0 j:l. I ps::,rsOnarJy 6b~rVeQ this,coMUGt. I.bl5se(iled detaifleefsJ in 'a.{;ond itiori that led me to, believe .thanliis coriBuct haa ,Q.ccurr.eo'l -Detainee(s)-told me that this, coildtlct had ,occurred. Others~ who obse'rved this conduct d,escribed it to me. e, 0 1, have releyarit information classified above '!SEGRET". f. 0 I ne.ver'observed thls,;conduat nor heard about it fromsomeonawho did. 44., Supj~ing a 'det.aine~ tq loud musk ',a'. ~!f personally observed this conduc.t. in'a ,cond ition that led me to. believe that this conduct had ol!curred .. -c'. oo II-obs.erved:detainee(s) ;D'etainae.(s). told me that this cond:u,ct had ,6,ccOrr.eid. b. .d. 0 0 Others who ,observed this m:i,ridLJct,described it to me:., I have releVant information ClIassified a'bo\i.e '~SECRET". f. 0' I nev.er observed this"conduct nor heard about it from 'someone who did. ,e. 4-5. St!.bje:::ting ,a deta.in'ee t.o brig hP flashing ~ Ilg hts or ,d 9 rkness o Ir pgrSbnally b'b'se'ryed this c:o'hdu¢t. D. D !I ohseN.ed ',detaihee{s) ih.a condition that ied me: to beLieY,e .that this cb,iid uct bad ,o,ccurretl. c. o !Detainge,(s)-told';:nethat th,is conduct had o,ccur~ed. f'd, o IOthers' whO ,o.bsel'Ved this conduct ~I'escribed It to me. .e. o II haVe relevant information classified abo\ie "SECRET" . f. 011 neverobseiVed this'conduct hor:hea.rd:abolitit from someone.\vho did. OIGQ-004837 46. IsOlating a d¢tctihee for an extenaed p.eriod a~ b. c. 0 I personally observed this"conduct. o ILobserved detainee(s) in 'a,condifiorr that led me to lJelieve thaNhls conduct- had occurred. o JO~ta!nee(s) told me that t~is conduj:t had 'occ;:urre;I. 0 0 t 0 d·f e. Ot!:ters whQ o~sery~q tqis condllct'd'escribeq !~ t<;> m~; I. have relevant inrQrmatjo'n cla'?sified allove "SECREr'!. I neVer ob~e.rve~1. thjs'GQr)du~t l1Qr'heard abou.t it from someon~who did. r personally observed·this.conduct. 0 r 'observed detafnee(s} ina .co.nd ition that led a. D b, me to believe that this conduct had occurred. c. [j >Detalnee(s) told me that this condud had :occurr:ed:' q.. D ~ ft o Qt!:rers who oQserved tl"\is c,0.rrd ud des,cribed i~ to. m~ .. r hqye r¢levqnt i.of9.rmqtiQn classified..q'~9ve .01r "$ ECRET'!• nev~r"op~~rve9 t.t1ls:CQliquct (lOr hl?ard .~bqUt;.lt frorrrscrpeQn~lJ:Ihp,dld. ·48,. U$.Ing rapid res.'p.on'sELteatns:a nei/Qr forced .ceIi eXtr:actii:ins, a. b'. c. q II perSonally o:bserved thls,eoilduct. o II.obse'rved detalhee(s). in a.cona itioh-that led me to. believe thaUhis co~dud:: had .occu'rred. o !Detainee(s) tOld me thatthis conduct had occurred. d. 0 Others' who obseryetj this' conduqt' qe.!?crlbeq It~.9 me,. .. 0 r ~av,e relevant· in"form.9ti'on das.~ifle.~ C3.lwve "SE¢R~l/·. f: IL'1~v~f'Q.b.?eryeq ~hf~'q;>neJ4crI)9r .h~r~ ,a b~ut,!t frqm~m¢o.n~ "Ybo dJg. '~ o - a'. 0- II persOnal!y' observed this Conduct. b. o ir-observed detainee{s:) in axo:ndifioh that led 'me to believ.e that:this conduct had .occarred. o lDetainee(s) told me that this cond.uct had occurred. o IQthers who observed this conduct described it to me. c\ d, OIGQ-004838 ·"t e. f: 0 0 " , ,. , • I ' I have relevant rnformatlbn' classified Clbove ·\SECREf". I never observed' this:conduct nor heard about it from someone. who did. .50. Threatening tQ use' mmiqry worl\irtg~,-s'-,>Q,,-,n-..;·o,-"r..;.n.:..:;e-,,"a.;...r ... a_d'-"e.... t9.;.;,.·ln;.;..e.;...e'-Q. [J Jr _ p~rsolially 9b~tve<J this:coMlict. 0 0 I DlJserved de'taineefs) in 'a condition that led me'to- Delieve thaUliis conduct h~d ,o:c:cliitetl. e. 0' [j othefS' who obse'ryed this £(;;indlrct d.es{;ribed it to me. L have relevant Information classified Clbove; !!SEGRETII . f. 0 I never'observed thls:conduot nor'heard about It 'from someone who did. b.. d. ,d. Detainee(s) told Toe that this condhtt had ,nccurred. :a. D It petson'~I\Y observed this :tonduct. c; o !I oDse~ved 'detainee(s) hi "Lcpndjtion that led me to, beiieve that this condu,ct had ·oacurred.. o !OetZtlnee.(s) told me th~t thiS condu,ct. had ,occilrred. d~ D. io,tners- who ,observed this GOnd uct'deScribed it to me: b. .e. . f. o :I have relevant information Classified a'bo~ie, I~SECREr'~ r~r Knev.er observed this>conduet nor heard about it from 'someone who did . st. Threatening to '.use..sp.,iders, scqrpionstsn:akes; or other:animals 0T):a detainee .a. o II p~r.sonaJ\y observed thlsconduc;:t. lb. D II oh.serv.eci detaine~(s) in.a tOh({ition that led J m~ to believe ,that this ~bnduct l:iad .occurr.ed. o !Detainee(s) told 'me that this Gonduct nad 'occufred. Id. o latherS' who obselited this tond ud described It to me. ·,e. o II have relevant information classified aboVe "SECRET". j .' jC f. , I 0'lr never observed this condliCt nor heaJd 'abount from ,someone "liho did. OIGQ-004839 S3. Djsr~sRes:tfuI.statetiients, fiandlihg, or:acti<Yns ihvolvin9. the Koran 0 b', 0 C;:. 0 -g.r 0 e. 0 'f. 0 a~ - I personally ,observ.ed this..conduct. I:observed detainee(s) In 'a'"condition that led me to believe that this conduet had 'oceurred. De,tainee(s) told me that this conduct hac;l.:qc:curred. Others' w.hQ o!?serye.q t,his c~nd LJctd-escriqed l~ t9 rn~ 1. have relevant informatjon cla:ssiffep al?"ove "5 ECgET", r never:o.\:>serveJ;! thJs'coJi~uct,nQr'heard aboutit fro,m .sqmeone'whodid, 0 I perSonally observed this conduct b.. 0 I observed' detainee(s) in a eOl'ld itiOIT that led 'j'f c. ,d, d me t o believe that this conduct had .occurred. Detalne-e(s) told me that this conduct had :occurr.ed 0 ·Qthers who obS<';rv~ ~his cEl.n:du9tpescrjQ~ It ~o., --. e. 0 I !1qve refevpnt iqfi:>rm?ltiQn c1as~?1f(ed ,~b.ove "SEeR '1': 0 r f1everoJl~~rve<l this 'COI"!P uct. nor h~rd a,b.qut It fr,om SQlT1eQne, w.ho. did. 1- , .5:5. pictiing a woman's, eiotHing on .a.:,detainee. a. D I perSonally observed this :coilduct. h'. d.lI ooseh(ed delainee(s) in·a condition that led me t 0' believe·thaHhis conduCt had ,(lccurred. c, o IDetainee(s)-fold me that this conduct had occurred d. 0 -0 '~. QtJJers who obselYed thIs cond U9t: described i~ t9 me. t bayE;': relevant inf,CxffiC)tiQn das~ifie~ Cl.b9ye, "SECRET'" ' .' f: lEI 1. nSlver-oq~erv~.q this· ~<?l')quct'n9r·he,;l~p _ab9ut it f q6. "I)juJ:;hlng a d~~ainee or act!rl'g .Wv.iard .;3 tletafn'ee 'in ,a a. 0 I personal!y 6'bserved this conduct. b·lo 1 observed .detainee(s;) in a . cond'ifion that led me t o believethatlhis conduct had Dccur-red. c·lo Detainee(s) told me that this'conduct had occurred ld, 0 others who observed this conduct described it to' me. OIGQ-004840 , " e. f. , 0 I have relevant Information' classified above '~SECRET". 0 r never observed this :conduct nor heard about it from'someone who did. ,pl., H9.1d.lng:~~tain~(?) who w~re not offiqally ~clqlowl~getl,orregi~ter~d a,s '$,uch by the-,agency detaining the p~rsbn. a. q 0 0 d. 0 'e., 0 f: 0 I personally observed this coilduct. that led b. Lobserved cletainee(s) in 'a 'condition :c. D'etainee(s)told me that this conduct had 'occurred. a. b, 0 0 me to believe that this cOl')duct had occurred. Qt,hers who oi?se~~d this cond,.uqt descr!~ed it to me., ~.I1~v~ ,r~levarit inrormati<;>n c1as~ifieq ~~9\1~: "S.EGRET)I.~ ~ never:ob~erv~d this condu,ct'r)or heqrd ,aQ0ut it rrom~~meonewh.o9i!:L I persbnalfy.observed this conduCt. Iob'served detainee(s) In a<.cond liroh that led me to believe' that this conduct. had .occu'rred. jc: O,\Detainee(s) told me that thIS conduct-had occurr.ed. d, 0 Others, who observed this cc:md uct:described it to me.. e. IT. fa. I[) j-I. 0 f ~,~ve releva,nt InformatiQn classjfi~ ~~()ve '!,S:ECRET 0' 1~,never Qbserv.e.d this,·conDu~t·nQr.h'eprd about it from,Someone'who dJd. J1 " o ir perstiilall,y 6b'S.erVed this :conduct. 0 Lbbsei:ved detaiilee'(s)' in ';3 cond ition fhat led ine to believe thaHliis conduCt 1iC'ld .occlirred. Ie· o IOetaihee(s) told me that this conduct: had ,occur'i:ed.. ld. o ~O.thers who observed this conduct describea it to me. J'e., 0 If· 0' I ~ave re1ev,arit, !nform?ltion ~Iassifieq a);>ove "·~.EC~!;P'. I nev~r 0.,bservec! this 'Cond4ctn~r heArd :a09ut.lt frO!T1;SOmeonc= who qId. OIGQ-004841 , - 6,0. Threatening to take' a.cti6h agailist a d etainee's family a~ 0 I b't 0 0 d.!, 0 e. D. t. !if . c: personally observed this.,conduct. Lobserved detainee,s) In a ;cond it ion that led me to believe that thIs conduct had oc<::urred. De,~ainee(s) ~oJd me that t~is cond uct had 'occu~re;l. O~hers wJlQ ol?serye.t! t,his co.ne! I;lct desE:ri~~ j~ t9 me.. I. have relevant inrormatio"n- c1as~iif ie.d .al;>'ove "S.EC,~", I nev~r ob~erved this 'conquct nor heard abbut it from sqme(?f)e·wh.o did. ~re. emQtlonql or p,sych,qlqgical trpum'a .to a qeta)riee 0 0 r personally observed this.conduc1. b. c. d Detainee,s} told me that this cand uct had occurred~ ·ct, I observed'detaihee(s) ina eondit iOIl that led me to believe that this conduct had .occurred. d;, 0 Others who observed this eon,duct descriQed i~ te;>. m~~. - -- 0 I h!=)ye ,re!e.Vetn); i(lf9rma~iQn classi fied. al;>.ove' ~$:ECRETrr;. 1 10 i: never ob5,~rve.c1 tnls coM uct .!l0r. h~ r~ a bput· It frb.rrl' SQmeo,ne' »,h.q- ~ l.d. ~. QQ. 'oJher religio:us.or:sexuai ,hatassment Qr humiiiation.p(a ,detalnee' a. 0 I per~tially' observed this .cotlduet. b'o d c. D. ioetainee(s)told me that this cond uct had occurred. I ;observed delalhee(s) in a ·con'd itiEin that lett me to·lielieiie thiinhis conduct had .occurred. 0 IOthers' W!19 obsel'veq this co.nd u.ct d'escrl~ed [t ~o me. :e;· 0 r have r~I~~ant intormation. c1assi fie~ ~b(;>ve "S:ECREj'''', f. 10 1. n.eyeF'o.q?~rve(r ~his'c.;oneJlJ.~e !l9r ·~~~9 .C:'li?9 ut it from S9me~,\n~''Wbo eJ.i9, d. .6J. QJbe(tn~a~l]1~nt , " [)f'a~ d~~ine~ that in 'yo!JropIhion Was_uliprpfes51'iciniill, .u:riJf.ql~har,sh or:afjgr¢$,Slve, ~coercive, 'abusl\(e~ 'or'unlciwful ; a~ b. I 0 r. personally observed this, conduet. 0 I 0bse'rved d.~tpi>t)~~(s) in a:conc.litiQI) that lee! me t9 bel,ieve.thgt'this ~onduct had 'occurred. tt;:~ D \Deta! nee(s) t~ld me t~at this canduct had 'o~curreCI, - .- " OIGQ-004842 .. .- 0 Others. who observed thls conduct described It to me. .e. 0 r have re1e'lant Information classified above "5 Et:RET u,• f. 0' rn~ver ol?s~rv~d this'conduct n9r i:learq about it from.S9me0n~wh9 did. d. ~1;§i!tfir_-""""":" I.. ;" , ij .64. Di9: YOJ)'9,~~rye'gliY inwersonqtfpOQf F~r p..~r$Qrlnel ~Y"9!1YQ.n~ 9!JJ!ng an !nt~rvi~W Qr !nt~rr9gqtig[J qf: ~a d~talh~? '6,5:, Oid i3 ny; q¢~ine~ Q.r Qi~¢r 'Pe(~n t~II'Y04 '~hat he qr she ha.d Witnessed t.hi:! jrn.persotl:~~.iqn ,Qf FBI p.ersohn~1 fn'cQ'rmection with:a' tfet~in~ jn~erview or interr.og?l'tioi1?· . 0 y¢~, <!1 No'; 65,. Are you awa re. of any ':sham" or ~ staged n .deiai nee interviews' or interf0g ations, conducted for Mem oers, :or th~ I). S..~O'llg re.s~;o,r. their s t a f f ? , , Y~1i' 0 Np~ o ,6.7',. To' Y9~ r kl')~wledg e; ',d id any militaIY or jJ1~e,l1fgellg~ personnel eve:r deny or,de!ay 'FBI ·gccess ~o,' q; , ·d,~~i~·tb!2l.F61 .wai'lte4. t9 ~Qes~ioJi bet:-a~se;th'e'detciLn~e' tJcid sl,J,s(ailJl?l;! ir,'lju,ries. aft:er he WC!S Gapfure~? Oy~?- ~~o' 0 1 .';. -," ',68: bid 'yoti ever-eM your paiticipation in or bbsel'Vatlon..Qra aetajnee j'iiteritiew, or iriterro.gatfori ~e~ause .of the in~ervierJ or inte!ro:g~tion met!lbd~'be!~g',used?' , 'e C'Yes Np. '~9-, Wer.¢ you ~ver tl?lg ,that i3'h9th~r FB,I :~mployee- ~n!;le~ hif9f ~.er p:artJciIJatipn 'in 9:t ob'~rvCl.trO.h of, ~ 'd¢taln~ in~e.rvI~W. 9f Int~rtogaj:lol'l b:~'Ca:use of th~ lnt,ervl~w Qr llit~... togatloil methods' ~Iog used?' . 0 Yes' :~' No 70. Dur..ing .i3~Y :-cif-Y94f pver~,as i1epI9.yrT1e~~~ or a§.!?i[nl;J'lenl!ir. pip 'YQU. r~PQf"!: ~nycqncerl1s, r,egardfng a'hy ~detaine¢' in.ter'view.elr iilterrtigatioli J1ICn:j:ice!;!".or Qtnertyp!::s 'j:>f tfetainee tr~.tmel1.t, to: an 'FaI ~.YR¢rvr~of? ' . . 0 Yes- .0 No 71. Durl'1g anS!'- 9f·yoyr ?,v.erse~s deployments oI.,asslgnrnent~~ dl9 yo~ report allY .cone,erns regardlpg any ,Q~t?\in.ee:Jnt¢rv.iew. cil'''interrQ.g'Rtip!:l pra:ctlc~s pr Qth~r"~YI?~ 9f det,C\i!1.ee; treatn:rent you 91)~~tvM 6r b~n:l ~.~94t, ~9,a npnMFB,I s:qp.~Nis~r ~r p~her rionMFB.:I·p~rSprlri~1? o Yes" ~ !'lb. . 12·.. . Hav,e:y.~u -ev.er: beeli orClered Of directed not'to repo'rt,.or:disco'urciged .iri. anx w~y, frem r,epdrting f o~~rvati~ns or gll~gation5'r.el,a~ed tq detainee treat!l1ent or interview or Interrogation 'qctions 'or OIGQ-004843 pr.actfce-s? o Yes 0 \'{d 7~. ttave yOll ~pe:rjel"lGed .a-ny. .aqual or th~atene:d j"et~lia.tfoli f9t r¢P6.rtrng 'ptfsertationS'Qr' '~ilfegatiPhS .6fdetainee, treiitmeht QJ' fotelView"OJ' h'lteirogationcaetio'nS or, practices?~ O:Va '0 No 74. (Q'Rt1o.hi:(I) PJ¢<l.s.e. prQji'i9¢ :any-~p.difloh~1 q>.(hrilent$·r'c;g~n:iitl~ .tli~ rep9n:ing.Qf 9>ric'~rDs, t~ri;l1eP .to, interVftWlor interrOQatfon techniques,. deti;mt!dn prat:t'ct!s~ 6i\other d~talriee treatriren.t ~~tr:(~_·.. o D'! 0 "o::"'W', 75. We're you debrIefed, 6th~thati the standard debrief1n· FD-7.72f~contferniJi? y:ouroverseas @.S~ignrn.en~(~) '9f $I~pIoYment(sJ a.ft~'YQu ~.mpr~~~g ~h.e d~ploy~~~{!?) G'> yes 7.~a. or ~,s~fgnmefl~(j;H' 0 N9' Who: lt~briefet:j '¥Qu? lJiE .EM,PLOYE.o.A:;SISTANCE PERSONNEL 7·5b., Wbe'n ahd:where.dld thedebf"lefJiig(s) od:un JUNE OR JULY. 20.04 - MIAMI fIELP OFFICE (MANPAJORY' fOR.·AUL WHP,WER.E OEPI,OYED.) , 75e- VJe~ YOU' ~sJ(ed ~lx;il!t'~etaJn'ee:det.e:ntlon 6r'-.in'.tef¥iew: or lnt~bgatiOr" praq:f.~s dljr!119 tne' . d"o,"'ffng(s)7' '. . . aYes ,@lIlo 7M. What other sul)jects.were GOIlered during ,your·debriefing.cs}1 MATTERS RE\:)\TEO.TO ruE EMPLOYEEASSrSTANCE PRO.GRAM 1s.e: Was.:.any, ~,QCUnieht l?:r.epar~·d to m~mQtlallze the·He.br'(efing:? . d' Yes :b. No ~0DQ Not Know Thartkyau for ya.ur cO,opetation' 'in' c;ompletln.9. this;,qUe.stion-r'la:ir~ OIGQ-004844