Department-of J,~stic.e In~pectpr Gen.er·al 'Que,stipnnaire' R~gar.dln·g D~tain,ee'S
~

..

.0

DOJ.-OI:G INVESTIGATIVE QUESTIONNAIRE
FORREV1EW .A~D USE ONLY BYINDIVIDUAL FBI ItESPbND'ENTS
, '"
,
~p. NOT FO~WAiiD OR Di:S:SEMI~ATE .
QUESTIONNAIRE 10:

test-O.0001~022

,Asa( ~h,e last time this qu~,tj'Qnnarre.w~~ saV~dl ~ome require,d (iel~s~ hc}V~ n9~ ~een"c9mpleted.
Pleas'eTeView'your responses.
.

:~ ~ .

",.:

.. "

.

,~

':.

..

"" .. , "...- '!, ; ,:... " ,~,'; (':

"~,' .~.;

Please provide'the fo1l6wih~' information:
'1. .FI~st Hame.
i., Mi~'~le Inltf?l:
'3; Last name:,
4. E·nter.ed, btl DlIty Date (EOD) :
.5:. Cun:ent D1VIslqn!Field bffice:
6. ~urrel)t job title:
Y. Direet dial office telephone number;
8, FBI (;~Il phone ,number:
,9, f\3J p~ger nutrlb.er~
10., !3es~ cQotact number for you.:

... '

"

. ".

/

".'

.

'9 &.7C PERA,?REEMEf,n:

'6 &. '1C PERAGREEfilIENT
6&,7,CPERAGREEMENT
6, &',7C

(; 8. ,7e
~pe<ii'pi Agent
,6 & 7CPER,AGREEME.NT

Ii &: 7¢ PER.J.H:~REEN1ENT
Ii fJ.;7CPERAGREEMENT
6 & rc PER AGREEMENT.

11., At any time cifter:Sep.tember 1l,'20,01, did 'yo,u, serve, as ,a 'member onne

u.s. Military, 'or: as aYl
employee or contractor of the FBI,or any otheqjovernment agency,. at Guantanamo Bay:; Cuba; Iraqi
Afgh<;lt:l!?tCl!l; 'or "I) art;:qs'~ntroll~ py'l:l1e ~:S~ M'ilit9ry Qra V.,S. illtellig~,n!:e fien/i~e ill 'CQl'm.e.<;:tion:witp the
'910l;>al Wi'll on !error?
(!), Yes 0 No
12. EliteI' the 'nlimber ,of times you were deployed 'oF/assigned to'each of the-follo,wing IDeations
(Gl1?n1:qnalT)Q' B9.YI9:UP<;1~ J:raqrAfg~a,nlst,Eln; 'qr 'D:'any: ~reas c;ont~~lIed py the l)~'S. M.ii~ti'lry 01':9 U~S,
int~lIigel1<:~ service)';2
For'ea-ch depl9ymelJ~ or assignm~~t cO'lt'!plet~1:hefollowi!'J'g sectio~./
LOGation Cselg~ op~)'

:~u~nfuj~~nl~]~
12a~ What ..,:m's the fleneral

Deployment:'Of'asslgnment:. began on~or

Deploymen1; or, assIgnment: ended on

a.boJlt

or-a'liout:

03(2004

:05/Z004

hature and purpose: 6ryo'ur~assignment
Upgrading ELSUlt capabilities andint.erviewing 'detainees;

and :actiyities-,?-

~2:b. Please PfOvipe',the,llql1lles ofthEf!:ipec,ific C9mpSj baS'E;!s; or'~ci!iti~? wh~re .Yc;lu ~Qrk~d.

'C~mp D~lta~
,
. , . . . . .'
1;2c: Note: If informatTOIi about a specific tamp" base,. 6rfacility' is.c1assifiedabove SECRET,

'please l=he:ck: here, D, iricilJd~ in 'yQuransyitei' tfiat ,ypu, haVe "additi6na.l'information '¢Iassiffe~ ',-a trove
'SEt:RET/" arJd.;

iJ you

koow, jdef1tifythe,classifica#~n levef, ticket, 'compartment" program, 'or''Ot,her

$:Iesjgn~tion ~h~~.appll~'~o the,lnformation, Do not W:ll,lde'tbe'ad,dition,al clC!sslfied inform~tipn in your

qu~,stionnalre,re,spoilSeS. QIG persol'fliel .with the. necesSa'ry clearan<:e will cOD,tact ,yo,u ro r~d~ive' it,

OIGQ-005041

·.-.

~1~~.)=~a~Id~D~ij :~y ~i~'~'~~~ QQsltlo]r=aJJ~~ ~0~J=t}l~.f~i ~~~n=Ii~I~ =~~~Q~ y~u=~i[~ly i~pit~~:

.~~rlQ9= ~9~i~~~12Y~~rlt
2r~i~1~n~e:n!i;,
.
.
.
... "
,:

"'

Nain~

I

b6
b7C

Positi(jn

L

q~~~~n~~~o~_~a~~~~------------

_

·:1~e. D!C! Y9u j9intJy il1t~ryiew 9f int~rrogat~ al)Y d~t~ii)ee with nO.l):-f~I p~rsonnel?

0 Yes

:

:0

'I
No
I
.J,... - - - - - ' - - - . - - - . - - - . - - - - - - - - . - . - - - - - - --'.-'-'- - - - - - - - - - - - -,- -,- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - . - - -'- -.,

;i2f; Did you Jolntly plan'any det.altl~

rnt~M~W Qr"

interrogatiQli ,s:trategy,. objectjv~

.FBI p~rsonne.l7 .

ortac;:tlt~ Wit~

n.bn- :

,

':

'

0 Yes

.@

No'·

'.
~

~0

",

':i2i;~W&eyo5~vi(6tb,;M_i5e·lhv.6i\iediridcl~iiie~:intJrvie;~,6r,rnfirto~~ti;h-;-.;ith-hoj,~FBI
p~;s;iin~7-:

, d Yes@

·n-'-----------------------------------~---------------.---------------1-"

Peplo:yment~r

assignment 'began on.9r

loca.ti9ri' (select olte)

about'

D,eploymen1:(Jr assignment,ended o.n
or:about
'

;ji-ag:

OS/2003

0:7/2003·

12a. What 'was the gen'ei'al

I

natlire'alid

,

pU'r'pos'e of'YOU'r"a'ssignrrIEmt;.and activities?

I

.

~
Of t,h~,specifi.c;.'C~(ljP~i. P.a:s~sr or t;rcilitie& w~eJe YOl,J

b6

12q. P!ease'I1r.Q'V'ide th~:npmes
wotk~d.
,Baglitl.ad In,ternati9r.ral Al'rpqrt
12c: Not'e,: If information 'abbt.i't a 'spettfi6.camp, baser' 6 r latH it~( is''.tlassifjed ~bd.ve SECRET,
piea5e..ch¢ckhe,re, 0, .inClude ill your answ~r ttiat you have "additiohai info.rmation,c,lassified 'above
'~EGR.EJ:'r.''' ~D.dj if YQ4: kl)9w, i{h~iitity th~·dg~~jfic~tio.n'I~vel, tjck~t, '(:<nl1PCl,rtmen,t, p,rograw, or ot/.1~,r
~eslgnatlon .that'apP.lle~ to-th~flnf9rmatI91J" Do not In<<;:lu'9e: tIre ;2~dl~.I9n<;)I,c1qs.s'lfjed Inf.Qrmatl9n In v,Qur
qu'estip'nnaire re.sp6hses" OIG. 'perSonnel witH the nete.ssary clearance will'confact you to receive it.,

.....-..

.

....

:~-:."'.-

_ _ ._

--.-:-

-_

-

__

-

.

.

- - --

- - -

-

.....

_"';"'"_'_'_~;'_ -0

"";" _ _

-7':- -

~.;;; -

-

- - -,.- -- - . - -' ,- - ' - - _ -'-;- -

::~gC!, YJ~a~~,ld~D!!fJ~ ~t !1~~~ ~!1<! .~8:s1tl0.!J",a.! .!~~l!f.!:I.~i-_·t.D~..f~f.~~2qn_n~l

:;d,u6D"g-yo-ufo deplQyrii~nt -ora~s1gnJnent . ~
*------~--------------~----

I

Name"

:12e.'Pi~

::

'

L

'

,_ ~

...... - ' - -

-

- - -~

I

tE...:~I!.o!'!. yql.!.. C!i[es!~'t !~p.Et~9.·

Position

~~uY~~ls.9[>:' ~~E;.Gl~18Q~"L

you-jointJY i~t~i:vi~W or!nte.rrogate<ClflY,d~tai.nef;:'with [lon.:.FBI p~fSOnl1el?'
0 Yes
:0 No

~i2f Dlce io"UJ(ifntlY piah:~ny' ~'etaln~ lm:ervrew~Qr:lnter.r~y,a:tfon''7st~teg

:FBI personhel? '

'b 7 C

~.,

.. "

'~,b7C
-;,

y,- ~biectlv~ -;,r: iicilCSWith ndn--~: '

"
.. "
;
I
0 Yes
0 No
'
•
:t2'g. Were:'y,0u ever otherwise involved in detainee:interviews"or interrogations with mm.:FBI personnel?' :
"
0' Yes
'0 Ncr
-~

,1

' _ _ .... -

"

.

______________ b 6

,.

"

:

'

'

" _ ' _ _, , : , _ ..:

,..;. _ _

~

_ . _ ~ _ .

_ _ , _••

r:;-- -'-"- - ' - - - ' - . - - - - - - - - - - - -,..... - - - - , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - . - - - - - . - - - - - _ .._ - ---'- - - - ..

:u"

. .

. ~.
...
't~':'',; .:."'.-.,...~ : ..

A. Tralnin,g Prior 'to:Overseas' Deployment o't Assignment
13', t>id~you ree.eive any'training r instrudioll,or'guidance spedfk:ally In prep,aratkmfor any"qfyour

OIGQ-005042

,

,eyes

ONQ

QDo Not Recall
i.3j' Whp prov.ld,ed tbij ~Rlinirag, instr'u,ctlQn, Qr g,uid?ltrceJ and where die! YQu rec~ive, it?

b6
b7C

14b. D.estribe the sub 'ect on· which 'ou received this trail1irr

instruction or "'tiidance.

14. In· preparation fat' any'ory.our .overseas deployments,.er assignments;.d id you recei.v.e.any training;
!n"5~ruGtl~n, or,gy id9n~ :c;Qn~e,lT,Iln.g lh~ :s.tan~.ard s of~on~~~t ~ ppllc~bl~ to tlJe tr,e?ltm~nt,
int~ryiew" pro irjt¢r.r.ogaU~1i of:detairiees by FBI pers.Q'nnel?

'00.0 Not Hecali

0No

is. In pte paratilm for any' of you r overseas deployments :or assignmentsj" dId you ~eceive any traini ng,
. fds.tn)<;tiq~/;Or~guigari!=e cpn!:er:nin.~ .~l1eA~tan.~Q.rd.~ Q(cPJi~uct ap·p.licab"le to ~h¢ tteatm¢rit"
jntervlew, Qr jnten:d~atIQn'QLd¢taln'e~s

by non-FBI

.

per,s~mnell

·~.N,o

Hi; Irr p(eparation.ror ~nY'ofYQur'overseas peplqymen~:Qr assfgnmeots, dtct yo~ r~q~I'l~:~QY ~191n!ng'F '
i~structIQn":O.r:guTd.an'ce <iol'i~ernlng what yO!J were's.up~o$ed .to, <;1.0 if you 'ob!?~rve~ or h'ea:rd·:a~.Q,ut
the treatlTleht, ji1te""i~lA,i,. or iriterrqgation of detainees. bY FBI p¢rsot:loel, :wnich yoo b~lie.ved leI"
b.e lnappr.opriate~ llll,prof,essional, coercive, abusive, or unlaWful?

:bYes.

-.

.0 Do 'N"ot"Recall

i'1., In pr¢l:iarptipn fo,r. j::lI1y;of y.oljr 9v~rs~dp !:lepl6yments or 'p~sig/.ln'l.~nts/:j:lld you ·r~Celv.e a.ny· ~rainin9.1 '
ibs'trudj6ri,.o'r,guida,nce .cbnc¢hiing wfjcit you were,sLippbS~d to, do -if'you. ;obseNed .or heatd 'abGlu:t
. ~he·treatmenf, 'i,ntervJewr <?~ inter~6.9~tlon 'of detainees by non-FS~ personnel/ wllieh' you believed

to Q~ 1I"!approprlat~r-I,l,npl'of~~,~19J:1al;

'co~rc[ve, .:aPJ1,slv~f.

tjr !J,nlaWfu.\?'

,

.QYes '

l

lB. Training, Duril1g Overseas Deploym'ents or Assign'ments

1?" Qurlog any. 'of your 0v:erseas ~epIQym.e'1t~ or aS~lgn~ents, did yol,! re~elye ~!1~(~r.aJnlrgt 'In!?tructl~n,
,~t~guJ(Janse ~one~r.n[llg th~;stand,?lrd~:of cQrl,dll.c;t Cll:1plic'abf~ tD the'tr~tm~nt, inteNiew, OJ
.
I.nte'rrag'a"tlon ·of"Oetal.n'r;.e~ ,b'f FBI ~.r~t>nn~1?

$¥.es.
ONO·
la-a, WtiQ 'Pt6Vjd'gd this- tra5og" iffs~r'uq:iPht 6r 9uid.ance?
b6
19b: .BrleflY ,d.esGrlbe th~ s~ ~!:it~n.~eof the :train.ll\g, Irrstruetlon, or g~ld.qnf:e provl9'ed to' YOl!o
The gUidance,gerierally Gonsisted of a reminder that all interv'ieWs'condutted bY: FBr.
per~~>nr(e\ ,shoul~ pe:in ~~.elling·witht~~ p're~,~xJsti.lJg. FBl ~t.amjarq5'f9r i.!1.~eryre~s

b7C

OIGQ-005043

cpndLjcted on subjects in c;us,to.dy.

lac. Was,C!!1¥ ()f the training·, ~in~truc~ion, or ,gLiJdance proyiQe9 In'writtng?
:OVes

~O Do Not RecaIJ

0Nb

LI

Hr. Ouring any:of your overseas"deployments or assignments, did you

receive any'trainihg~ i'nStruction!~
qr:guldance'conterning the ~tand,an:ls qfcqnduct '?lPplic.a~(e~o tile treat!Tl~nti:il}t~rv.!~, qr
interrogation of detaiJiee$ by: nO,ti-'F61 personnel?

,2p'., During anY:0f your 0:v:~rseas'deploYQl~ntsof (lssig nmen~s, dtd you receiv~ any tKljningJ'il1struction,
org uiQ,anq~:c9nt:el'n!ng yvt)<;lt you, Wer~ ~J?p:qse<! t9 9.P if ,yol,l ob~ervs=fI qr heard ,at19yt the
trea~m¢nt, interv(~w, qr int~rr9.QatiQii 6n:letairi~e~~ by FBI pe'rsb,nn~IJ which you b~He,~~ tp be
Iriapproprlate.,urjprbf5slorial,toerciv'€r
abUsive" Qr-unlawful?
,
'

.

'

Qbo NotR:ecall

:@Yes,
O'No
',ZOa, WhO: provided 'this training,. instructi.on, or gUidance?

''''
I
L
.',
'
:2qb, Bril;~fly"d~trib~ ine' 5iu,bs~nce;9f:ttfetr'qinint:l, in.~mrqign, or gUipC!nte::pro'\(t~~~O'yqu.
.
,

rlJ~'gl!j,dal)ce pr9v~eQ, ~<;lS ~q,!ml'"[ledi~t~!Y; report, tp- SS~

p~rtai.n!!1g 1o"~e.t~]n~,a,Qusl?; Wheth~r o!?,?erved 9r: l,m<.>t>.~e,r.v.eU"

b6
b7C

!gflY il)foJTIlC!~ion

:2:0'0. Was-,any:of the training! instruction, or :guidance pf0vided in writihg,1

aVes ,eNq ;0 Do, Not Re~1I

.21. During,any;af your,overseas 'deplbyriJ~nts 'o'r assigi'lmeiitS, did you 'red~iYe ally training, iilstruction,

or gujclance cOJ)cernil)g what you we(6'supp()qe~ ',to' 90 if YOl,l,gpq~,lVed or hear:9 9P0ufth~~
,
1re~tm~nt(' 1,nt;erVleWi: ~r )nterrgg~tipn, ot",det~!n~~s by non:-FB'I,p~tSol:ln,el,whlcl1 Y0!J qef!~ved J9
b,e irla:p'prpprja,te, unprQ'fes5idnal, coerdve! 'abU,siveJ or unt?iwt'uI?

Ie. Adequacy of Training
'21'. :i:ri,you~,.oplriibn) :did' you

recelv.e adequate trainIng.,. Instructionror:gurdance relating' to sta'ridard's. "

:9.f l:':9J1Quct by. F~J al1q non-}~I p~rwnne! re!aUIlU :to, tre~tJTIent, 'jhtervi~V{f' <;>r interr.Qg?\tion''Df
d~t<;liJJ¢~S prit?r

tOYQur ~eployment

:23. In YQlJn:ipjl1idn, did

Qr;asslghmeh17

yo,u ret~iye :adequa;te, training, instructiOh, 'or-guidan'ce relating to '~andard's"

~6f Cqritlu~t IJy ,FBIaiiCl nQh-'f,BI p:ersori,nel'relating to treatrii~ntlintel'vfew" 'or, fnterr.0.9atio~n:6f
detainees,during Y0ur deploymenr.or:assignment?

~ ¥es

0

No

OIGQ-005044

, i2.4•.In Y9\.lr OPi~iOl'Jr'"did 'you receive"adequ~te training, instruction; orgJ./ida,nce conCerning wh,ai'You.·
Were SlJPposeP to.dQ:1fy'o~ Qqs¢Ned:qr heard ~bout the ~re?tmentJ [nt~rvlew, dr interrog~tidn ,of
',detain.ees, D)f FBI 'or. noh-FBI personhel! that YOU 'believed was im,\,Pptopri,iter unprofessidhalr.coercive/. abusiV.e" Qr unlaWful?

eyes

0

No

25'. (6ptional) In what ways- Gan the F'BI improve training on this subject (or future deployments:or
'l:!$$ig nm~nt-$? .
'

10, Commen~s
2'6. P"'ease provide,any additional information'.conc::erning."training fOf'overseas deplo:y-ments or
assig IJrn~nts ~f F~I R~rsQnn~1 you 9Ellieye i~ re,l~v~,t:it.

D~l'il.nr;~: .. ~-~@1,~:~~,,~.,.
'QIlJi~~~~'@F~jj§.'~:,

,

•

"

-

•

•

t·

"

' . . "

'.

'.

'.

>

•

•

- ":,':,"
• •: '

".

",'

•

"

~nlroducl:i~n to Part.Xn: In this s~ction[ we~are seeking inro/1Jla.ti<:m reg,arfJi'ng a wide- ran,ge., oT
il'!ter.vie~ Of 'irtt,errqg?!J(l:lI) t~c~niqy~ 8t')9 9ther -types- qf'~etainee-tr~atiT)~n.! p'U~g~d tq, hav~ ·9c;;cu,rred.
-'(olJ '!?hpl1ld n1:>.p3$$Ume, jy~t. ,Q~§u"se we:-ar.~"asking, ~b,bl!t a pat.tic~li:lI· Je:c;hniq~~'~or plC.lctic;:e, thpt\ye, ttcw.e
cohdud.ei:I tbat Jt 11'1 fatt occur-ted. We r'eoo~:fniz'e'1fiatsbme 01' these technlcfues or 'p'rattices- may-.,at tl.meS

'be necessal)" for safety, and- security' in a'd~tel')tiQn setting., In addition;, we recognize,that.some oHhese
tecl)nif/ue?:or: pri?atlc~ may h,ave been author!zed f9r'u,se by mlllt~ry Qr"oth~t g'overnme.nt p~r.sonnel.

With (esp:-e¢t to "~~c;:h ipe.n'tined t~<;:hrijqu,~, pr~:ctir;:e, o.r tYpe .bf.coJig~tt,d~~ribeq b131ov.l" w~ 'are ~,~~kil)g'

'ih'fomiation ·abaut.its occurrence during or-inconnecfion with 'the interView o'r interrogation of a
det~jn~,~i;pr duri.l;1,g the, ~et:ention 'of a 'de'tai,'1ee p~YQn~ .w-~~t Js~eede~ Jor safety cU:id'security;
In ~h9~ :<;c;>rite~t, we wiil ask yo!:' tp tell J.l.§ JNh,eth'~r 'on~ Qr m9r~ bf th~ (onaWing :5t~tf?rne]1ts ,are tr.l,l~"
1. r pet.son~ilr.'qbse'r.vep 'tbl.s con~_uGt_
2. I.opserv¢d ,d¢tain¢e(s) ifLa '¢Qnd ition t~t1eO m,e to b.elieye Wj:ltlhiS' cond u!Zt had ¢ccurr..ed.
3', Detainee(s) told me that this,conduethad occurred.
4" Qther;5°who o.bserved,tbiscondlfctdescribed 'it to me.·
.$, ~ hilY~ tele\(ant 'i.lifprm-atI9r1 cJ~~$if[~d- ~i5q~~' ":SE¢ReTu:.
~6-.. I.b~ve.r qb'~e'rVed thi~ con~:iJJe:t nor h~ard abol,l.t ,it" 'from :sqrrleone Wi)o qld.
.

.

-.

..

.

I

27" Deprlving-a detainee: of f,0c;>:d or water

a. 0 r p.ersdnally Qb~e~ed' this;,cqnduc.t.

r :a .Cphditioi:'l :that !~ ,ni¢ to beifey~,th:qt ~hi~, cqriquct ha'd occutrecl.

j,',

0

r".qbSe(Ved, ~~tali-\~~ts In

c:

tJ

rJetaih~,e(s) tpid m'~ tnat tHis: ¢:Oi"jd Lic,t had .o.tclJrrM.

d. 0
e. 0
--' ...

--~

jOt hers: who observed thl~ t;bnduct r;tescribed ittp,me..
I have relevant il)formation. clas,sifiea above
".-- --- ... .. ..

... - .

-

_. --.

-

..

--_.,

'~SECRET".

... _. ----

".

_._-

--

.~.

,

..

._-- . --

.. ...

OIGQ-005045

'[!j itrlr never'observed this conduct nor heard aboutlt from someone who did.

a',

0 r. personally:.obser\i.ed. this ,conduct,

b.

o

c.
d.
'e,
~.

[.observed·detainee(s) in .a . conditio'n that led me t6 believe that this eonduct had occurred.

0 Detainee(s) told me that this: cond uct· had :occu rred.
0 Others, whoobse rued this cond uct described It to. me.
0 I hav.e relevant in formatic;m classified above I\SE'oRI;TJI...
0 r, neveropseryeCi

"29. Deprivin'g ,a detalne~
a.
1;).

of sle,~p~ or Inte'rrupting

~Ie~p, by fr~.gu~H:ell reI69ati6ns.:oJ;otl1~r rtlefhdds

0 r personally obseIVed this'.conduct
0 r 'observed detainee(s) in a <::and ition that led

me to belie.ve that this Gonduct had .occurred.

<:ii. D.lbetainee(sj,totd.,me ~hpt this. cQnc! uct had o~curr~.,

d. 0
~~,

f.

Others whQ .abse:rv.ec{ this G0'nduct descrihed ~t to f(le.

o !r h~v~ Televant It;!form,atlon plassJfi.eq ~bovl;. ·!:S!=CR$'''.
0" !I never o.bserved this,c9nda.ct Iior heard aOp.I.!t it ftpm s.omeone·who 'did.•

'3,0. BeatiAif a .detainee

a;
~.

c.

9,;
~r

0 I. p'er~nally>'o:bse ry~d this cqndu,ct.

o ~I ogseIvecj d~tain.~e.(s} In '9:cQnd ificm t~~t !e,d m,e tp' t?~l!eve that: t~i~ c.or:rPw::t hap ,<;mqmed,.
o 'pe.\:9inee(s) '~ol.~ me ~h9t thi~'cond(Jct ha,d occurred,
0 'Others: who ob'servecl·thi~ c'pn~tuGt.desciibed it h:J me.
-------------:------1
0 r have re:l~Y~n.t i,n'r,orm<J}ioIJ <;:i~S5,ifled aboV~ ·\SI:CRET".

f: 0

I tl~~.t:!r Qb;;~rv~~f

3:1. Using water fo
a.

prevent breathing" by a ,detaihee~or to create tHe sensation of .drowning

o II per$Onally'obse

b, D I Qb~.tved ~I.~tain eet~), lil·a t~md-fflp.hthatred m~ to Q'eli~,,~ .thatthis ¢ond !Jct, ha.d :occ.urreil.

c.

o Idet~ln¢e'(s) told me that this conduct hqd o¢cLJrr¢tf..

OIGQ-005046

....
tOthers who observed this conduct described It to me.
"

,

'

,

,

d.

D

e.

o II have relevant information classified Clbove "SECRET".

f.

.32.
a~

"

0' if never observ~(i,t!lis/c(;>nqyctnor heard about it fr9m some0n~'wh<? diq.

!J~ing hands, rop~, onmything els~ to.choke or' $trangle.a detainee,

d

b. D'

I personally observed this.,conduct.
L'observed detalnee(s) In a'concfltlon that led me to believe that, this. conduct had occurred.

0 Detainee(s) told me that this cOllduct h,ad 9ccu~red.
d., D O~her:s.' who obser:v~t! this cql)cj yg' described it t9 f11~;
~. D 1.. have refevpnt lorormatl0'1' cla'ssiflep at>'~>ve U$,'!=C.RET't.
f: 0' I Dever'observed this 'con~uGt nor' heard ab-ou.t it from ,sorneoi1~'who did.

'c.

'33. Tliteateriing':other actio!'!' tP'dllj5e~12bYsiCaI. RCiiri,.

q.

D

D. D
'Ci D
-d.

0

e. D
f.

injurY,

disfig~u~r.e:.:.'r:n~' e;; ,;"n..:.;t:t;.f,. :;b.;:. ;r:.: .de;; ,;i3; ,;t; .;h

_

I persoOCl)Jyopserved, th{s wnd4ct!

r: obse,ryed ~etal,ne~(~) ina. '-cond itron that led me to believ~ th!3t fhis €ond lJ.Gt 'had 'OGe.t!rred.

·betainee( 5) tpld Jil~ ~~af :thj~ ~ond u:~t hpd :o~qJ rre9.
Others who 'Q.bsefY~~ this cond!Jct des'¢ribed

,it t<1 me.

'have rereyant. rnform~tio.n. J:;1i;!~sifi~Cl al?-<.>Y'e '~$,~CREt\

0 I ri'!=v¢r' Qbserved this ,cQ'ndu<::t il'Qr hj3arp '~bd!l~, it frQin Sdm~pne,w'hQ ,d fq.

,34.· O:ther treatment or action'causing signiffcant physieal pain or irijurYt or causing disfig,urement OT
de~th
~';

~.,

O. I personally Qb$~tVed thi~ GPntfu..~,t.
D r' '~b:~er\[ed de,talne:e.(s). iD ~d,ctjn'dlti6tnha!:. i¢CI"rTi~ ~o' Q'eli~ve .th~t tHis i:oitd.uct hap ,otcurr~d~

t. D petainee'(s) told ri'j~ th'atlhis.coni:.lu,tt he,d :cicturr~.
,d.

o

e.

D II have releva'nt itiformatiOli t1a'ssified ~boVe, "SECRET"'.

f.

0

lOthers. who ,ob,serVed this conduct des~ribed it to,

me.

I never',obserued this cO'nduGt nor' heard ,(3 b8Ut Itfroin. someone who did.

OIGQ-005047

a~ D II personallyob'served thls"conduct.

(I,

0 II observed detainee's) in a'condition that led me to believe that thi s conduct had occurred.
D Detainee(s) told IT'e that this condyct ~ad 'occur-re<;!,
D bth~~ whoobser:ve.d thIs l;:pndlfCt ~'esqlbed It to me:

e.

r:;J

f

0: n,~~r oQseryed, this tqn,d~~t nor heard 'abput it from:'sani~one'who , did.

b,
c.

~ have r~revant information d?~sifi~p p:1?:.~ye, I~SJ:CRET~:,_,_.

',,36. ,Using shackles or 'otherreSt'ra,lnts'ln' a prolong!..:ed;.:;-..:.m;.;.·a~n..:.;n.:.:e;.;.r

_

-

----

_

0 i: p,ersonally ·obs!,,!rv~d tljis '(:9pduct.
b~ 0 I o~~rved ,d~t;9In-ee(~) In :a 'Gond Ition ~hat le.d me; ~o, beUeye thr;lt thl !? qmducj: hadoGcurrefl.,
~;, 0 Detainee(s) tqld tn~ t,hqt thiscon.du.d h;:rd 'Qccurr~,
\1. O· Others: wbo observed th,i$, C,Or'ldJJ,~t--d.e$'¢ribed it to; me.
e-.., 0 ~ hpyereIev~nt Inf.orma~!o,n tla~sJfl~d cil;l'Ove II,SEC,RET'''.

a.,

: diq.

_...... --'--'

.........

-,

.....---- .... _.......

,
:

,
,

37. Requiring ·a·detainee to maintain" or restraining a :detainee i'ni a stressful or painful p0sition

,a.

0 I per$Pnal{y, observea thi~ 'conduct.

,

~I

0 ,I 9~~erv~~t (fe.fi3ilie~Is)' in:a '(;011(1 idOl) th'at led m~ f9' b~(jeve
t. D, be.tai n~e(s) toia rri!= .thpt ~hls,J:(m,d utt tlpq6'Cl:.U rred.
d, 0 (OtlJet5; Who ob·serY.~d this' ¢:qnd utt, described it ~Q me.

~,hat '~hi ,5 ¢ohcjU,t~ I1 qd 'oc(furr~,d.,

,
,

fhave relevant informatiQh''das,sified above n,S,ECRET"',
f. 0 II n$ver OlJs:erv~d thls'.c.onctuct lior neard ~..t":--It-f-rb-,m-so-m-'-'-~-on-e-:-w-ho did.

~. 0

,
:

'3$. fo.rdmJ a' d,etaihl=e to;,perfonn 'demanding physk:,af ,exercise'

b., D. II: observ.¢d d~talrie~s» in ~ 'GPnd,itloh that i~ n'i~ to b>~iie\!,~ ~hat ~h1 $ conduct, had o:Cd(rre~l..
~ 0 jDet~inee(5) told me tti~t ~his> conduct ha,d co¢(urr~.
d. 0 Oth~rs' Whp .observe'd .thiS, cond Llct described It to'me•
.e.
f.

D
0

1. have relevant itif6hnatio'n classified above. '~SECRET"·.
[never observed this:condud nM·heard about it fiu'm sorrieohe'wh0,did .
..

OIGQ-005048

3Q• .!.Ising electrical

~ho:Gk on a Qe~qjn~e

0 I personally observed this .conduct.
b~ 0 ~!obse.ryed detatnee(s) in a ~<?(1djt\on th?it I~ rl)e to' be!ieye that ~his cO'n.du~ ~ad 'occ.u,rred.,
c, 0 Detainee(s) told me that t!liscondlJct had '9c~urred.
<l. D /Others who 'ob~rv~ 'tl)is con~l,JctdesqJbe9 i,t to l)1~.
e. 0- r hav.e reJevant information' dassjfi~d ab'ove ",SECRET'\
f. 10 1: n~ver Qbs~rve9. ttil~ C:QlJdUQt nor heard ·~OQut.lt from,someon~whp'~Id.
a:

'40.. Threatening 'to use.electrical shodeon a .detainee,

0 ~ p~r:~nalJy·o.bS?rv.~cj this :co'nQu~t .
tr., D t obs~(veg 'Q~laln~e(s) in;a :qmp itlon thqt-Ied .m~ t9' believe 'tl1c;1tJ,his cond.uct, bad ·Qec!Jrr~d.
c. 0 D~~aine!=l{s) tql~. ,me tl;lat -t~ls ~Qnquct, n<;t:d oGGurre/:1.

~.~

.d.

o

klth'~ts' rJ:h9 pb'sery~d :this Gqnq4~t d.esWib~ it t9

m.e;

e: 0 t: have relevant ,'nrorhiation classified .abOVe i'SECRET'''.
f.

0 i

i!~v~r QQserv.ed' this 'cqJidu~t nQf:hi:E.r~·~bPL!t it frqrn.·som'ept1¢'. \'Jhq. ,diQ.

41. rntentionally,delaying or.denying detainee:medical care

a.

o II. per?QnallY opsexv~Q ~lil~ ,<;Q·n~uet.
o II' ops~rved detaine\=(s} In.a cond itlQ" that ledrne to belie'l(~ that.this ~Qnd,uct had occurred.

b.
c: o
d. o
e: d

iQetai nee(s), tqld mfi that

this' cpr!d u~t hi:i:d ,oc:C!.J.rr~.

lo.tli,erS who ,obsetve~d 't.hi~tO'ndJ.ictd.e?crlbedit to, rn.!=l..

II' have re:l~vant Informatlpn' cla$slfi~d -abov.e '~SE.cREf"·.

f: l~qI never ooseriied this ,conduct h6rhear:d.abbut it ,ftom:sorfre'one wlio. did.

9-2 . Hooding or blindfol~if!g'a detainee ether ~han durfng (r(3nSp,-0~rt,-.a_f.:...lo.:...n
.a.

"~.
c,
d.

e.

_

o II' p.er:S9r1i=llly 6b~e'i'V,ed·thls.,conduc.t .
o J:robserv:edqetaine~(sj jn ~.¢bnd1tion that led m~ to pel)eve thGit;tnis tonduct had .occurred.
i:J tDetqine¢{s.) t9id :me tnat this: t;:;ondtiq- hi3dQ,¢cQrrci:!.
0'pthers'
.
who ·obserVed this eonduct des'criIJed it to me.

o II have 'relevant ir:if6rrtlatioiJ clas.sified
.above: ".SECRET".
-

..

_.

OIGQ-005049

~llif

43.
a.

II never observed this conduct nor heard aboutlt from someone who did.

So.bjecting

0

a detainee to ,eXtremely, cold or' hot room temperatur~sfo.rextended

periods

1. persdnally·obser'v,ed. this,conl:lutt.

,c.

o ~.observeddetaihee(s) in a",condition that led me to believe that this conduCt had occurred.
o IDetainee(s) told me that this conduct had occurred.

d.

0:

e.

0 I have relevant information c1assiffed above' "SEGREP".
0' II n~\ler ().bse"'ted thi9 conpllct n~rhfi3rc) aboyt it from $01T].~?l]e'wtlo qid.

b.

f.

.4,4.

Others. wtJo ·obsel1/.ed this c(:mduct described It to. me.

SU,bj~ing a ·.de~cHnee,

to

lC!lfd music

0 I personally observed this:conduct.
I
b. 0 I:'observed detainee(s) In a condition·that led me to belie.ve that .this conduct had :accurred.
¢; D De~ainee(sJ t()l(:I me that thi~ conduct hpq oq:urred.
<L 0 Q~~ers w.hp ~bsery.ed t~rs conduct descrilJ.ed (t to me;
'~. 0 I have relevant !nfprn;Jptlon !=Iass,lfied ;3bov~ "?E<:;RET" .. '
a.

f;

0' I tJ~er 9.bs·~rv.ed this condo,et nor heard 'abaqt it from someone' who'd id;

·45:' :S'ubjecting a d.etainee to bf-ig'ht
a.

0 II per~naIlY'o;b?erv~d

f1ashili·g.J!9~h~ts:..:p;;;;;'.r::..;,d;;.;;a:.:.r.:;:k;.;.ne:;.;'s;,;:'s~

this con~uct.

Q. o.II observeg d~t<;lin~e.(s) in 9~cQnd ~!(;m-t~~t
.c.
d.
€li·

f:

o
0

led me to

'.12 e.I(eve ~hi;lt;tt;Ji~,c.on~1:Jct .Qa,d99Q!Jneg.,

!D~~ainee(s) ·tql,d me that tqi~'c,ond.uc~ Qa:q 'Q'<:i::urred .

,
-....
..
iOtbers whc.:> obser.ved thiS; co.n(j!1Gt desctib~d It'~o me.

\.

o if have relevari,t ilJforl1)aJion ¢Ia~sjfled above "·SE¢RET".
o tr n1=w~r <?b~~rv.~d ~lJis:cqn~ot..t n~or h~(d 'ab"Qi;rt It from: sdrrj~~newhb' O.l~,

'46'.lsolatihg

a detainee for a'fr extended period

a.

o II per-?Qnally'Qb?er.vec;! thi~·9?nj:li.JGt.

b'~

G ,f Qbse:rVed',t\etalnee{$)' in :a-c~>nd.iti.Qn thcit I~d me tCi QeJjeY~
o petainee(s) tolo me that this con~l.u'ct had o"Cc;ur~ed.

d.

_

tbat:tbis' con~Lid

-

.1

hi:1.d Dccurrea; r
-

-

,I

OIGQ-005050

..

'r

...

,

.

0 Others who observed this conduct described It to me.
.e. 0 r have relevant information classified above' "SECREf" .
f. 0' ~'!1ever-O'bs~rv~dthis'con~uct nor h~rd about it from some0n.~who ~iq..
d.

47..Usin·g 'd.udt tap¢. to

restraln,.ga~r, Q"r

punish

a d~t~inee.

a: [j I p'ersonally' observed this...conduct.

0 Vobserveddetalnee(s) In a'condltlon-that led. me to belfeye that this conduct
G. 0 betainee(s) told me thCjt this conduct had 'occur,red.
d. 0 Othem who 0~$erv~q t.hi's qmc! [Jct-described It to m~.
e.· 0 1. have.reiev~mt II)'form~tIQn cla:ssifl~ p~9ve ·~SECR.Ef'·!.
l: 0' I never:observe.d this 'conq u¢t .nor heqrd ·a hout. it fr.om someqne who d i~.
b.

had.occurred.

..

4.8. Using r;:fpid tespQhs~ tearri's and/or forced cell exttacti.ons

,q.

0

b~.

r personaf'/y ·o.bserved t,h(s 'condqct.

o if-observed c:letalne~(s) In .a;<::ondition th~t I.e~ me to: belie.y'~ tD?t this (;on,dw;;t had o-q;urred,
o IDetainee(s~ tQld rn~ t~qt 'thl$. q,onc! uct hpd im:q,lrf:e<;\.

c;;,
.:d.• 0' (Others Yirh'o QbseflL~d tuis p.onduct d~s.trib~ it ,tQ' Ole.

e.. 0

t ha\!e rele\,ant. fl}f.or'm~ti.o.n:~la~sifi~d 'C1~:ove "$ECRET"',

D. .r: rt~v¢rqQ$erved

f:

thls'-c6ndut.t nor:h~rd abQut: It fr9.lil.som~oneWhq:dl~.

~.. Pieas-:e' prQvide the a:pproximate time ftani.e darin¢. Which :thisq:mduCt.ocqurred•
From ·Q4/2.00,4 t6 04/20:04
.[]Do Not B-e~al!
h. The'de~alne~(s) treated In this Way- Were located ·at the time Hi:
10 Guanr~ft1am6'
. ,

.2 o Iraq

:3 0
')1.

Afghanistan

0 Other Location

5 0 09 Not Re~1I
I. Plea?e fdentify the:de~~ln~(s) by name an.~t n.umber:
(!'-Ion't know,

in

.j. Please· ide-ritify,the perron(s) Who treated the detainee(s) this mannet, including their
'name(·s) ,and g0ve~nment:agency'(iesl:
.
M.~mbers,()f th.e MP's v.J~ose tf.l,Ities .It, wps to 'extra<::t .re~Jci.trqrit petcHflees frorp thejr·ce)ls.

OIGQ-005051

k, Please identify' any other FBI persbnnel of noh-FBI personnel who,observ.ed detainee(s) treated
in this manner~ inclumng their name(s) and agency(ies):
I ~pn't know.

I~ This cQnduq: .o¢c.urfed in conJi~ctiQn Wit!.i:
1 .p dne de!~iilt=e

20 'Several detainees

(2-4)
3"0 ManY,detaine:es(rd6re'than 4}

'4,0 00' Not Recall

m.

(Optional) Pl.l=ase·desctib.e the,te leva nt circurristam::es

in more·getciil:

0 r p.ersbhally obserVed this:co'ndlltt.
b', 0 Looserved.detaihee(s} in a·c;:oridition 'that led me to Delieve t.nat this conduct hcid·ot>€ur'red.
e; 0 Detalnee(s) tQld me that this eo'hduct had occurred,
d. 0 Others who observed this cond uct:described It too me.
'e. 0 I have relev.ant information classified abov.e !!SECRET"·.

'a.

f.

0

I neverobser-vetl
thIs 'COnduct
heard
someone
who
' . " . ',
- . . ," .nor
...
"
... . ·about.lt :from
'
. . "'. .
. 'did.
.'

a',

D
D

I persanal ry observed this .conduct.

,b.
c.

q

,

/

~

"

Iobser.ved detainee(s) in ac~nd'ition that led me to. believe thaHhis conduct had .occurred.
Detainee(s) -told me that this conduct had ;occurred.

d. D Others who observed this condudtdesC'rlbed It to me:
f

"

>.,

>,,'

.,..-.

/:,,'.

~

••

-

"

~" D [have relevant Information classified above "SECRET"',
f: 0 ~, ".ever 0P.?8'rv~:~f thfs ·~9ndl!ct..n9r ,hear:4 ,a~l;)U~' it',froPl s9.m.eo!1~ Wh.o did.,
_.

D
b. D
c, D

a.

"

A

"I'

"

•

'"."."

",.'

I personally observed. this..(:onduet.
I0bseived ,detail'lee(~} in <a.contrition that led

'me. to believ.e thanhfs Gonduct had occurred.

Detainee(s) told me that thfs conduc::"t had '{)(;;CUfred.

OIGQ-005052

e

..

,

,

,

'

e.

0

1 have relevant Information' classified above HSECREf".

f.

0'

I never observed this'conduct nor heard about it from someone who did.

,

,

,

52. Thr.~tenlng to u~ spiqersf'$corplons/;snake~;or other'aJlimal~ on a'detaine~
a.

o 'I p~rSdnalJy obs~rVeQ this ,conduct.

b. 0 I,ODseryed,detaineefs)' in ~,cohditiofi that led me .to believe thaufiis contfutt. nad 6.cdliteCi.
Detainee(s) told me that this condHtt hado.ccurred.

:d.

D
D

e.

q

L have releyarit information classified above' ·!SECREfi '.

f.

0

[never'observed thls:mnduot nor'heard'aboutit from someone.who did.

c

Others who observed this conduct described it to- me.

,53.. p,isresp'ectfuI ,statements; handling., ,dl,"'Clctions illvq1ving, the Koran

,a. 0 I

b.
c.

o
o

personally observed this conooct.

I'observed det.ainee(s) In'ac::onditi6n that led me to belJeve that this conduct had'o'(!curred.,

\Detainee~S} told

me that thl's- e'ondlJct had ,Q,ccurred.

d. 0 OtherS who ,obser\led this c:ci'iid uCt'described it to me.:
,e.

oir have reley~hlt iriformatio'tl lZlassified ,ilho've '~S'ECREf'~.

f.

0'

I never observed this:conduct nor heard about it from 'someone, who did.

54. Shav,ingct detainee's facial or other hairto em qa(raS$ -Of humiliate: a qet§..:.;.in.:.:;e:.:;:e....
"

~b.
c:

_

o Tr p~r.soilaily 6bserved thJs.,tondu<:t. ,
o IIobser:v.ed detaihee(S) ill.a 'cbnd'itibri that led me: to believe that th.iS: conduct had oC,currect.
"

0

Detainee,(s) told 'me that this' cerid uct had {)ccu'ffed.

d. D Others' who obsehied thls rohouet described It to me.
,e.

f.

0

I have relevant inforniation classified above "SECRET" .

o ,r never observed tliiscondUGt n~r'~eard ;aoout it from ,someone who did.

OIGQ-005053

55.
a~

b~

<;:.

4:
e.

'f.

Placin~

a woman's c10thihg

on

a detainee

.-

0

I personally observed this..conduct.

0
0
0

Detai nee(s) told rl)e that this cend uct had 'occu rred.

o I[observed detainee(s) in a ,condition that led me to believe that tills conduct had occurred.
0thers Vo(hQ ogseryetj t~is c~nd uct'describ~

!t to m~

[haye-relevant inTormati9n classiffep al1ov~

"SECRET";

o '1 nev~r'Ppserve9

r

thls'conquet ncwheard abou't it from sqmeon~ who did.

'a. 0 I personally obsehted thls.conduct.

b. 0 I,observed detafnee(s} in ·a cond ition that led me to belie\le that this eonduct had ;occurred.
c.

d

d. 0

'Deialnee(s) told me thatthls conduct had ·occurred·.
Others who observed ~his p::m:dyctdescrib,ed it_t.o. me..

-

I h?,ve.relevqnt inT9rmatjQn'c1assffied. ,a9,ov~ '~$ECRET'l;
'f. 0 ~ nev~r o,b§!3rv~d t.hrs.;eond!1~t nor h!:'13r~ aboui It fror:rr SOryiebne wh.o did.

e;

D

5.7. Holdili.g.{ietain.ee:($):~how~re. nQtoffld~lIya~kh.o\vl~ged

:tletairiirjg
a.
b.
;c.

<f.:

the p e r s o n . '

I

.or registered a.s.~w;:h byihe.agen~y
.

o.te per~naI!Y'observe,c;f tnis :co.ndu~t,
.
o :1 observeq det,%\h('le(s} in '<:1 'condltiornh~t led ru~ to beneve tpat this co.n'duct hi'ld occurred. I
o rp~tai,net=.(!?) t.9J~ JJl~ th~t this cOl)duct qad occurret;l.
o

!~thers; w.h.o observeq t~i? c.cmduGt d:esqibeg i~ tQ

mI;.

e. 0 r have rel~vant il)forroatlPn: ~1!3ssiti~ .~bove •...S·ECR~u.
f.

0

I n~yer o~s~n7ed

this ,cQndu<:t 'nbr'heard ,ab.o.ut it fr9m:s(jmf=.o·n~~w'h<?:difl

sa.. Sending a.d~tainee:to ano.ther country for rriore:agg(e.$sive interrogation
a~

.b,
c.

0 I personally observed this,conduct.
0 r opser-ved de.tai.lJ~e(s) in a 'cond jtjon that led (Tle to believ:e thE\t-this «:onduct had 'occurred.,
0 Detalnee(s) tdld me tr,qt this conduCt had ·occurred,.
..
,

..

OIGQ-005054

".

d.
e.

f.

..

"

'

.

0 'Others who ohserved this conduct described It to me.
0 r have relevant Information classified above "SECRET".
0 rnev:~r o'bs~rv~d this"C9nduct nor h~rd ~bout it from someomnvh9" did.

-59. Threatening t9·send a cJ:~tainee t<;>· a09thercoul)try fell' dete.nrion onn.Qre aggres~.iV~ irti;:errwatian

:a. 0

I personally observed thiS :conduCt.

b~

I observed detairiee(s). iii ·13 ,cond.itioh that led me to believe that this conduct had ,occu~r:ed.

0
e. 0
d. []
e. 0

netainee(s) told

me that this conduct had ,o.ccur'red.

bthers who observed this conduct-described it to me.
I have relevant Information classified above !!§ECRET"·.

f; 0. I, nev~n:>'bserved thfs 'conduct n9r heq~q ·abo.l,It it -from sarne()n~w~'o

a.

diq,

I

o !I personal!y,observ.ed this·,conduct.

0 L'observed. delalnee(s) In . a· cond itlphlhat led m.e to be\Jeve :that thiS conduct
Co' 0 Detaihee(s) ·told me that this conduCt had .occurrEd.
d. 0 others who ob.served :this conduct aescrib.ed ina the.
e. 0 1. have relevant information das'sified above.'!SEGRET"·.
b.

had ·b.CCurr:ed.

f. I~r [never'observed this:conduct nor heard about it from 'someone, who' did.

-

a. 0 I persjjnally dbserVea this ,coMuc.t.
ti. 0 Ibtiserved,detaftie'e'(s). in a.cpJ1dition t,hat

lea me' to. believe t1i;:ittfliS condud had od:l1:r'red..

c;

o m~tainee(s) told liI~ tnat this.cond'u.ct had .od:urr.ed.

d.

0' Others Who observed this cehd lIct described it to me.
0 r nave relevant ir:ifoiTnation classified ab6ye "SECRET".

,e:
f.

a

r ne.ver'observed thls"eonduct nor' heard about It'fromsomeone:wlio did.

OIGQ-005055

52. Othenellglous or<se~u,al ha~assmel1tor humJI!atlon of a detaine$,

a.1 0

,1. PefS0i'lallyobserved this conouct.

..

J

0 Lbbserv'ed'detalnee(s} lri'a condition that led me to, believe that thlscbn.du,et had occllrred,
t. 0 Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had ,occurred.
- :--.,- c-----'
._--, --"'-~-"--'-"-""----------d. 0 Others who observed this conduct described it to me.
'
b,

e,

Ci

f.

0 1 never observed

I have relevant I"nformation classifIed 'abov.e, '!SECREf't.

"6'~. "C;>ther t.rea~ment

this,con#uct ngr'heard ab.Ol,tt it 'f,rom sam.enne who qid.

qf a~ d~~ihe~ that in ygur opinio!1 Y'CiS L!npr9(e~5ipnall

un~.lJ.ly nats!;l :or:99gressi\Y¢,j

'coertive, 'cib,usive, or .unlawful
a'.

o 't petSo'nally··observed thls.condlict.

0 I :observed' detainee(s) in 'a condition that led me to believe thatlhis eonduGt llaiLoc€urred.
c. ! 0 jDetainee(s) tcild me that this: cond uct had :occurr:ed.

b.

e.

o p~her:s ~~o o~served '~~is co.n:duc:t des~ribe9 [t to me"
o !I haVe Tel,~varit informatl.~.m. c,assifi~d ~bov~: liS ECRJ:f'! .

f.

0 I

d::

l1ey.efo.p~r"e:d this"<;ont!l,Jtt .nor h~rd :aboul· it frQlTI"sorn~o,n~'WhodJd.

]lil~ltl'lli::~ ~@j.@jjlfi,~ ,

'7" ,... :.."-: P~.:

i,

64. Oid :you ··obser-y,e ,anY irtipE:tsQn~~icm ,of fBI poersonnel oyanyone during' an ·inl.ervi!=W .qr -interrC1gati6n ,of:

,adet'ainee?

.

Q Y¢s;

0

No

:~~~: Old ;:'In)'" d¢~ili¢e. Qr.Q~h~r ,lJ¢twn te)i yb!J tharh~ i;>r'$he 'tiad w.itJiess~~ the 'inip~r:SQ'fla~lqhp{ f~~
pers,o'nnel In connection with detainee intervie.w or iiiterrogation?
'Q:Yes 0· No~66'.,Are ;Y9u aware of:any Upham') :orl'$tag~~·dE?t~il)e~. in~ervieW5\9r jn~e.rro.g~tI9q? c~>nc;lu<;ted f9r MelJ1b~r?
'Qf th~'l);S, Cpngress'9r their staff?'

'a:

.$7. T.O' Y0!Jr kJlowledg~~Qi9

~ny military Dr ·in1e..l\itlerjc;e personnel e.v~r peQY or delay FBI.acce,'ss to. a
detainee the FBlwantE;ja t~ q,u~tlon beca,use th.e de.t~fne~ had ,~~tain¢!:l tnj~rles :~fter h¢ iNa'S <;a'pt\Jteq?'
pYe~s'
·~f.'.I9
.

OIGQ-005056

'IOU ·e.ver 'end your p:a~icip~tiQn In .or o1?serva~j(m :of a detalrtee Inte.rvie~
b:e~lfs~ 'Qf the if:m~rv~w Qi"' il)t~rr9g9tiQri m.ethods. o.eing .!ised?

,68'. nld

o Yes

0 No

O~

~~

or interrogqtio.n

~Q; \IIl~r¢ yop ever .t61c1.tlla~,Bn9th~r FBr .~n;ploY¢~.J;~nd~. his o.t ti$r pc(rticipaJidn In .qr·O:~$'~rv~tiPri i;lf"a
detainee intenliew :or ·interrogation. beCause :of the i'nteiView; o:rJnterr.Oga'tion methods being used?-

.

11); D\ir:ilig phY of:Y'9ur b.y'erse:aEi:C1E;pI6ymE!ht~ Q( 9$s!gnineh!s" i1(~ YQ4 rep-ort. ~n'y ~6nc~ro.s r~gi::irding
ail'y'detainee interview br.'iriterrdgatiCHi practices, .or 6thertypes of-defainee trecftni'ent,. to an'FBI
su'pervis.or1

'

o

Yes. ,@ No.
71. DlJrjng :any ,of your p)7erse'?l.s c;:IepJoyme:nts Qf a'Ssjgnmerit~r:did V9U r~p:ori pOV c'on~ermn~garcl irtg

,a'iJ5ndetciinee'interv.iew Of interrogation .praQtices~6r tither Wpes:'6f d~.tainee tteaTnient :YQU'
obserVed' o'r heai:d .a·oout] ;to a n~i1.;,F~I. supervis.or 01'- other nQn-F~I:persohnel? '

.

.;
.
0. y-es: ''0 No.
7;L J:I~ve:YPlJ :e\f~r bl;~n: o,~q~r.etl t>r:d.i~~eQ m;lHo' ,reR9rt, 9r'qJ~tQQr9.g~<;I In' ~.ny· W?ly".fr.orn ,regortingjt
,op~rv:a!IOrt.~,p.t all~ggltiQIi:~ r~Jf:lte~ t9 !ter?l'inee .trea~ment or i.nt~ry!¢w;pr inl~r(Qg~ti9.ri~~ttiQti~p(
practice's?

'

"

0; Yes

73... ti.a.ye;·Yo.l:l'experienced

.0 NO

~ n,y .~g:yal. od.hr~qt~·ned fetC'llia.tton: for re.por't!ng 'Q!:>s~rVqt!ons or qll~gations

o.f.d·~tain~~.treatm~ritQf tnterYiew :Qr in~~rrog.~tlon' actIon$.
Oy~~
@ N~'

or Piclc.tice~?'

7.4. (b'ptional)'· Please provld e any:addltional comments regarding .the reportlngQT concerns' related to:
intenli~w. pr inte~rqg.atiQn tec;:l:miqul:\~; det~.ntiqn p!:actk~.s,·or"Qth~r·ge.taln~.!~Jr~ptm~t!t;.

~~;;i;'l~'tOC~@i~ .?

0'·.·.,;,'·;·.:·<>.( .. \;~.;~<.~

.:;.::t:f.

. ZS,:< Wereyou deQrLef~~l..o,ther·than the statltlar~, g.ebrl~f1n FD-;77Z, cp.t)cerrirng .yo".lrover$€a~'
. as~jfl timerit(5) 'or ·dep loYm~rit(sJ.afte.r you :completed the tiep ioyment{$) brassIg rit.n'Emt(s)?
:0' Y,es @. No.

I

26. Additional Comtnents!and Recbmmendations~
Oqviou~Iy,1 in- q c1Qsed :~flv.ironmel1t such' a!? GTMbi the~~ '~ere :ai~y'~ ~u~o~s ~b<;~t' Ii ~~'~~al'd~tai'n~e
'
tre~ttnent. by yario.u!? 'Q~gan'izatiQnsi However, non~' Qf ~h'ese rumo,rs w.er.e '~ver leveled at .the ,FBI, nor dic;l

I per.~9I1all'1f 9ti~erve; ar]y' aetNltl~ which] felt wOLi(Li npt hav~ beerr~p'prbp·rlat:e·In<a U:·$·..aU[~aC1 bf

Pfisor:ls detention ·fa.bili~Y..

.

Thank .yo·.u''for Ybur'c'ooperation in co"mpl.etih.g
this~ qi:Jestibnliai're·
.
'

OIGQ-005057