ACLU v DOD, DOJ Questionnaire Regarding Detainees 00001140
Download original document:
Document text
Document text
This text is machine-read, and may contain errors. Check the original document to verify accuracy.
Department:qf Jus.tic,e In~pector.Ge·ner·al Ques.tionnaire R~9.a·r,din·g [)eta·in~e·s. n.oJ.-on; INVESTIGATIVE QUESTId'NNAIRE fOR:. REVIEW AND USE dNLY BYINDIVID~ALfBI RESP,ONJjENTS -_. DO NOT FPf{WAiu):OR DIS,SEMI~A:rE" . QU,ESTIONNAIRE ID: test-0.000.114:0' Aso.f ~IJ,~ last time thj!;,·qu~tio.,n~ire.w~s. sa\(~~,-~()me require.d fiel~s: !lav~ n~~ ~een C9J11ple.t~c;I. PJeas'la~revie)lirYQUrresponses.. - .- A. . :. --~.: '• ... ".<;':.~.. ' , .) .... .'" ..:: .. :'.:.:•• f' :-" -~ .......... ~',~, ~~'~~:.• ;.-:.",'. .:-;. > '. ... ',:. . ' p¢r~(:m~I_Infp_rmation Please provide the foIlowi.ng· information: 1. Fi(st hqmEl. 2, IVlIgple Inlt!pf: 3; Last name::. 4•. Entered: b.n Duty: Date (EOD'): :;:; Ci.II:~eh~ DIV,isfqnJ.Ffeld Offife: 6!.·Currel)t ipb: title; ,7. DiI'ectdial office.telephone number: 8, ,FBI cel'[ phone' .illJlliiJer: . 9. f~i p.ager t;lul1)~:er~ 10., Best C;Qntaet number for YO!J~ 6 &;7¢ PER AGREEJ¥1ENT 6 & 'lC.PERAGREEJfJ1ENT 6 & 7.C PER AGREEMENT. ~ &. 7C ~ & 7c; $SA 6&7CPER,AGREEMENF .Ii ~ 7¢ PER,NiREEMENT' 6 ';,7C PER AGFE.E/V!ENT 6 & Ie PER-AGREEMENT B. Backg'round of Spe-ciffc D.e-ployments or Assignments '11. At.any time aftet~Septeriilierll( :2"001;/, aid you serve. a's a member' of the U. S,. Military r 'or' as ah . . employee .or contractor of the FBI:or any other ,government agenc'Y;, at Guantanamo Bay,.. CUba; Iraqj , Afgh~.l)tst.~m 'orin areq$~'COntrolledI:!Y'~lJe U.S'. M'i1jtClry- qr·a I).S. ir)tell!genf:e s~rvlce in 'GQrm~etion·wittl t~e . 'g190al Y!rqr·on· !error? eVes 0 No 12·. t:nter the numb,er or time.sypO. W.¢r.~ ,depl9yed or'assi.gn~d·to each of the.fpiloWitig Ip:caU.ons; .{Guantanamo Bay, "Cuba~ lrair;..,Afghahistan; ,or in any areas controlled by the. U.S'. 1\1i1itary .or a U.S:. inteJUg~Il~,~ s~rJr~,~};1-' . For.each deployment location (select one) . " . . '. or assignment .coinplete'the followi~~section.. ~ep.loyni~.ntor '85,signrperiU!eg~n~h'or ~bou.t DeIJ,i»,Yijiilnt .or·a.s:sigriJjll~n1;en.de~ ·o.n . or abou!: !G·~~'lnta-~ririj-6"BaY. 03/07120.03. 04/17/20,03': 12a. What was.ttie~ger'(er:a·1natll(~ ~np p:urp,6se,QfYQut·assigli.ment and a~ivitl~.s? J. ~"••• _ •• ~ ' • ..:.~_~,....... • assist FBI 'and bther non .DOD ihvesti~ator5 with interview sug,lleStioris' 12b. Please providethe- names of the..specific.camps,. basesi or facilities where you worked . .qrF-~<?mm~D(l P9st , , _ . . .... ..' ." . 12c. NQ~¢: If iilfprri1~Jion'abpLita:sPE:.cific camp, base" orfacilit'l is :C1i3s'$ified :ab'bye SE~RET, iJl~ase .check here Dr include in 'YQur :ansWer that you hav.e. "ad~itj9nal illformation t1as~jf1e<J ·aJ~9Ye 'SECREr/~' and, if y.oil know, ideritify~the:c1assification'lev.el,"ticket, ,mmparfrfient, prag'ram, ,o(other desig'nati0.n that.aPPl!es tl? t~e inforrnatlon• .Do n9t include the,adqltlonaf clqsslfied inform.atIQn!n your OIGQ-004845 qJ.iestionn~ire re,sponse~. bIG personnel with the nece's.sary deararice Will c~mtact you to re<:~jve it. Position ;SSA ,~ame 'oon't recall :i2~. -Old' YQ~f0int~ int~rview'9t- iqi¢~rdg~t~-~ny d~tairi~~\Vi!-h~on=-f~I ~~t.$9~;eJi "OYes ,' I I -- - -'--~'-'- ---'- -'-: 0 No " :i2f~ Old-Yo-uj6fr;tlY pia~ ~ny f1et~ii1~ in"tet-Vlew-,br-interro~~iiio~ ~si~te9Y; bbj~iiei ~Fl3I personnel? 0 @'Yes __ ..... _ -. _ ....... -. .... _ .... : With wh'at kinas :6f nori:-fB.I p:ersbnnel :djd l~l',~rrF .: _. _ • __ .... _ _ .. _ . _ .. . No __ .... '~ _ .. __ ... • _ _. . . 1 I ot t~cti~; w~h n'0~- -; : _ ..... __ a. .. _ ' ... • '. _ yow w.ork jblntl~..?:"" .' ,., : 0 'QtMr U.:S~ Military : D U:S. Intelligence agenGY ': 0 f9r~lgn rntlitary or inte!ligen~'a:g,e!lCY :' ,: 0 O~h.~r .: . ; '. , •• - - - .............. -.. - - .... • - - ... _.. ....... I' .. ~ ........ ." _ 'y ....... . ? " ' , ...... ' '''' _ "" ....... _ .... _ _ ........ _ .. _ ......... _ _ ...... _ ~ .. _ -_ • _. _ _ . : 429. -:w-er~io~ ~Vi(bjtiirWise In-v~lVedi~ :d~~jrtei:rnie~re;;,~;, i~t;rtQg~ti~n:s,-wtth-~-n:FB{~;s6~nei? : o 'Yes '0 N p . - ~. • ---------.------.-------------------------.--.--~-----.-.-.--.~---~----~---~-- , ' ". A.. Training '~'" . .: ..:..... , . ~: .:" : . l ..... Prior'~o Qver~e~s,Deployment or,,Ass,ignrnent ij, Did. you rece.'ive anY'~rciining, ~ln~.tructI9.\1, '~r :gul.d"an¢e 's]eclfic;ai/Y 'in prepa.ra~'rQn' fClr !:l!1Y pf you'r ,(Ne'rs~s d.ep(~ym.elifs. or' ass.i.gnmentS?,' , ." . , ,eYes 'ON'o 0 Do Not Recall . 13a. Who provided this training" iristn.ictionl' br'g,iJidance, and where did 'Iou 'receive it? SS~ landl I '. b6 b7C l$,b. D'e~ripe the ,subj~ct. OD whJGh:yqu reG~iY~, thi.s traiJ:lingi,instn.l~ti(;m orgui9an~. general protocol.and top whom we would be providing assistance· OY~s :ODo No,t 8,ec'alf 15. In preparation Tor any of your overseas deployments or assignments, did you receiv:e any training, lfl,struGtlon,:or:gQI9,al)ce t:0!1<:ef:()ing .the standard s'.of con~uct 'applfca.bl~-to -th,E? .treatrnel1t( irjt¢rvjew" qr .interrogatic>n, ,Qfd~tail)¢es Jjy rion'·FaI ,p~r~onn~l? aDo NofRecali 16.. In pr.eparation- for any'of your overseas deployments:or assrgnments c did Y0U receive:any trainingr instrqdlolJl or gu.ldan,ce qmceming w.h~t .you were'supposed tQ: do iryou 9b,ser:v~d 9r h'eard '9bou,~ th.€:nreatrnent,:jr\t~rvieW, or InterrQg'atjonofdeta'l'tl~e$b y FaI pet.Sonn¢lr- wh(ch' you '.believed ,tQ OIGQ-004846 be inappropriate; unprofessional, coerciyej..abuslve, or l,mla.wful? :0yieS 'ONo "000 Not:Recari . 16a. Who prOv.i~.eq :tbr~ It@iOiOg'lnsuudiof·.n"orgUid?lf)ceJand where ~Uf.1 yo,u re~~ive, in ssN ~nd l . . . . - -_ _---J lJ~b. Briefl,y"des~riDeth~s!Jb5tcm~e',6ftbe.trainlng, inStruction, 'OYguid~mce prov.id,ed. to you. . TIi~Y: t~vered .to 'GTMQ' before. di~atJd ~n:d~ lip having lssu~~, with hoW cert",ili detainees were being i.ntervlewed by the military a.hd now this conflicted' with FBI standards,.of conduct. . . 1.6<:-. Was;-a-riy .of th~ ticiiriingt ihstl1JQipl1/ or guiCjahc~ proVid,Eld ifrW'riting? . 'O'{e~ ~No b ~9 No~ Re,C9[1 , b6 b7C t 17.. In pr~paratioh fqr ?iny' ~fY6ur .6y~rs~a'$. deployments or assignmMts)lid -you' rec;:eiv,e::c:friY trainir;lg.,. : InstfUetion, or .g'lildance concerning what you v";ere.sllPP'O'sed .to. do ffyou observed .or' heard 'about the tre(ltment, tn~erview.r <;>r inte(r.6gation;9~ detainees by ~on-f.a:I pel:'sonnel r whlcn .you ,believeq' tp be ii1qPP(9ptiateJ'I.mpr9f~ssi91lP1,C;:Qer~iv~/ :pbLJsivt?~ <,>r Olilawful7 ·Ia. Tr:aihing During. O.verseas· D.epl6yments or ASSignments I, 113. [lluriny ·any .of y,?u,(overse!=ll:j;p~p!oym~nts, qr ~ss.lg nment~'1. d!p YQlI re~ive ?lny va fn.ln9, 'jnstrqctIQn,: ,qr'gui.dance.c:pnj:;¢rr1ing ~h~stati~ard~ Qfh>Jld.u¢I: :a'pil.litable. t9:tne.tr~atnieilt, iriterVrew~ Qr . ihferrogatfon cif detainees by FBI persoiln'el? .. . 'ODo Not Re~1I t~~ I§yring ~ny .Qf y~(jr ~v.er~e~s.a¢plo.yrnen.ts qr ~rsSlg.ilnietit~} pid VPLJ te:t~Vt; ,C!n.'tt@.lnin:g/jh~tr!Jttiot.J; or'g uidtmce.conC,erriing th'e,sUitidaftls of.c'6nd'uCt "a j:fpHcabIe: to the,treatmerit, ihte,rJie'W.;.or ifIterrogation·Qf ,deta'inee-s by non-FBI persoriner?' ... ·:do-o Not'Recali 20,. Du ring ,any 'Qf yqu'r 9y.erseas t1eP"lbYrhMt.~ pr i=f$sig nmeriW, die! ycj1,J r~c~iVe J;:ihy train iriQI :iil5tru(::tion',' org uidance.totJc:erning What you wer.e.stJpppsep, t6 do jf -yo.u .obser.v.ed or heard .about. the· :freatrhent{' intervieW~ or inferro,gati6ri.bf (Jetaihees by FBI personnel.; which y.oll. believed tb. be. in;'3pproprra~ef uqprofessional,C0ercive,. ab~siver or l!l1lawt'u!?' ' , :OVes , '2.1. Duri[l~ .any .0fyoUr crl2.erseas·:aeplbyments or assignments, did you 'reeeiv;e aliy'trainrn~, inStruction,. or,Quidance'concerning what you were supposed to do' if you obseryed or hear.d about the 'treatmeNt Intervl~wT <;>r Interro,g,ath;mof d~'illnE?es by nO.l1"'fBI p~r.$onn~I, which you b~lI~ve,d to be, .inapprilpriqte, linp)"Qr.es$iQrial" cde'rdvei abusive, ',or unlcfwfiJl? • :OVes: Ie. Adequacy of Trai'rllng' 0No GOo Not Re,calf OIGQ-004847 2.2,'ln -your 6pi'ni<>n,'did you receive adequate training, iristr'udion, org~i~anGe relating to standards of ronduct by 'FBI and non-FBI personnel relating to treatlT\e,nt, Interview, or Inter.rO,g~,tlon'of detaine~s ~ribt to your deployment or a~slgpment? eyes d No 23'. In 'YQU'r opinib,rj'r dr~ YOU ret¢ive:ai;leql,Jate trc;iining,. insjruction,.. or gljid,a.nce reJating to ~tah(tard's .o.f cd.nduct by F:BLand nort~FBI personnel relCiting' tb.' treatment! interview,.. or iriterr.o~cition:of d'efaiheeS .durin.g your deplo'y'menLor .as,sig nmerif? 0Y~ o No' 24.1n your opinion, did' you receIve adequate. training, instr:uctlonr or,guldance concerning what y,ou wen~ s.!Jppq,$~9 JQ'Qo j(Y9l,1 o.bs~rveet or ht:;?lrd. a~9u(jhe tr~atrt1.~nt, intervi~w,'Qr in·~erroga.ti9n of 'cl~taine~s, b,y f.B~ qr l)~n-fBI·per$.>ritlel, ~b.at y~u b~liey~~d N'!.a..S. irlcip,prQprjater ~.rnprbfE\ssiRtialf :cc\er~iv.e, abu'5ive~ of unlaw.ful? ' ·0'yes 0 No 25'. (Optional) 'In .what ways can the .FBI improv.e trahiing on this ,slibjectt for future depro,yments':o( .~ssig IJIl}E\n:ts7 , .10. Comments 2~. Plea$~ PJ0yitl~:arW .adci)ti9-.n?i11nfqrm.~tt<?n;.cqil<;eJnii1g tr.alning assi~nme'nt5_of fBI. personnel you believe is ,relevant.' fQr (lve.r,$¢?.s '<;I~p:loymeflts' 0f . . 'xn= In- this section, 1fI!e:are 'seeki ng lnfi:m'npti(51i reg qrg i lig 'a WlcJ.e. range, ({f . .Intr9:i:lut,tipn,l:Q PC!i1; 'interview or intetrdg atiQn te.chniques and ath.er typ~s: bfdetainee: tr~athientalleged to have ,occu,rted. You should not'assumej- just because_we are:'a'sklng, abCDut a pa rtitular technlque:orpramlce, that w.e: have 'C9J1cJuq e~f ~[1,a.t 'iJ In ~c~ 9ccyrred,' Vje r:e<;og nize ~hat, so.rp~ of these te~~l}iqu'es or p.!pctl~es;may i?t times b"e.li~ce~;;IlY fdr~safi;lty ~l1d $.~lJritY' Ir:l"a d~te'l\tlon~~~ttiJ1g-. Ih.c:#ditI.9n( w~ r~c;ognge JI};:'lt~s9.J!le o'qh~se 't~hniqlles or p.taCtices math-aile 6.eeh authciriz'ed for-use' by m:ijitaty'o(other g,:overnment 'persOrinel•. With respect tEl each identified technique, practice, ,or type of conduct.described belowi we are seeking !nfOlm;;l~~qn ap.qqt .~t~ ,oq:urr:~nce '.d~ring ~r in :corin~~~ipn: with, the i~~~ryi~w or i~terr.oga~i.on·of ~ 'd¢lc:iin~e(:o...-<f~rin:g the~!atention'pf a' detai,r;:¢.e beyond what i~ n~~t:le~ for sClf~.ty ~nd ~se.cu,.ity: In that ,.to.nteitr . we ask you to tell us wh~ther .one Elr m.ore .cif the followiJi~:st.atements 'are true: will 1. r personally observed 'this conduct. '2, I'9.b?~fVffi.:q~t~I.nee(~) In? ;q;m~.ition th,qt I~ Il]e:to·b:ell~v~ thqt thl,s'cond),leJ; hqct ·Qccurr~. 3. [).etairi~e(sJ tq.rd rh~ tHat thiS. c.QndU!=t had _os:c;L1rted. '4, Qth.er.~ Wife ~bs~lVe_cUhis. cQ,nd,lict de$,eribed it t~)' mEl. 5', I have relevant. information classifIed abt:>ve lLSECREP,. OIGQ-004848 ;6. I never'observ:ed '~hls 'c~>nduet nor hei;lrd aboutjt Trom som.tpn~ Who diq, '27. D,epriVing a detainee QHoO'd br water D- r. personally observed this conduct. 0 I:observed detainee(s) in acond ition that led me to believe that this Gonduct hadocl::urr.ed. e. 0 DetatJ:lee(s) told m~ that this conduct h~c\ occl,Irred. d, 0 Othel? Wh.o observ.ed ~his conduc;t descril:led jt to mt~; ,e. 0 [ have·releva.nt I.QformatioQ classified Clbov~ "SE¢REr" .. f: 0 ~ n~v.~r Q.b~erv~9 ~,liiswndlJP~ nq~ heat:~ a~qu't. i~ fr91T)·~ql'J1eQlle:wb.o dip. a. b. 2-&. D.eprlvln'g a' detalne.e, Qf c1ottiln-g 0 h. 0 c. 0 c;!1' 0 e: 0 a. l r pefSGnal!y' oJj'serv,ed this.€of!duct. Lobserved Eletainee(s) In a ',cond Ition' tha't led me to' believ:e thaUhls conduct, had :ocGurr.ed. Detainee(s)·told me thatthis.canduct nad occurred. Otl)e(S, wfr9 ot>sef.'l~ t}1is ~nctl;1ct~~Cfibed it t,9 me, . [ ~a,ve rel~va[1t InrQrma~lon ~l,asslfl~ct ~~9ve "S:E~R.Sf'\ abser.ved ±h,'s conduct someone ~ I' never . . '.' , .. .nor'heard ' . " "about. -... . it from .. . ... . who did~ ~ " ,a: 0 r perS6hally: observed this ~oilduct. b. 0 fODse'rved deta'inee(s)' iii a cohd ition that led me' to believe that this djmluet had 0cctJrred. c. [j Detalne-e(s) told me that thiS' conduct had 'occurred, d,! D. e. ·0 1: halJ.~ r~le~nt in'ForrTlC!tion dasslfieg a~ove' ~'SE~RJ=J'\ 'f: 0' ~ never' q p~rve:Q thrs.!cQn~ u~t ,no): O~hers'who observeq this conduc;t~e$crib~ It to me•., hl;!arq ,a'bout· It frQIT) sq.meq,n~'Wh,o- ~'!d .• a. 0 I perSonal!y observed this conduct. b. 0 I ,observed detaine.e(s) iii , a c6.nd ition that led me to' belieVe that this ConcuCt nad ,occu'rred. . .. .. -, OIGQ-004849 . ... ... ~ .. c. D (Oetalnee(s) told me that this conduct had ·occurred. , d. o lathers who observed this cElnduct described it to me. D II' have_.relevant above' II,SECREf~'. ....... . . information . . . dassiffed . . '" 'f. 0'lr never' qbs~rved ~hls"cQnguQt,nor heardabElut It from sqrneone'w~()'did. e. " ". '. 3-1. U$ing Wat~r:t.a prevent Qreathilig QY a, ,det~inee:dr t\): cte:;:jl¢ th¢ ~en,satjon 9f drQwnjng D r personally bbserv.ed this',conduct. b. D I ~ob'se&ed detaine,e(s) in a ,cono ition:tIiat lcil 'a. 'c. 0 me to beUe.v'e that this co'hd,uct had ,occtJ'rred. lJetainee(s) told me that this cond,ud: had :occurred, d. D Others' who obserrted this condl:lGt'described It to me,; e. 0 Lhqv,erelevqnt inlQfrn,fl~ion dass~fi~ ?lbove '~SEGRET"·. f. 0' I,n~y'~ro,1?serve<!t.hi~ 'COI1~u~t nor ~t:larq ab9ut-lt frorn,s<;lQ1e.q.!1!='wfJo dld. '32. l}sIQ9- Iianl;l,s, .rope, or :anythirf!l else to ·~hoke.ot strang Ie <:i .Q~taine~' a. D II. personal!y obserVed this c,Qnduct. b. <;. 0 r:obse'ived. deta'inee{s) in 'a',cond ifien that led 'me. to: believ'e thanhis mnd u.ct had occurred. 0 Detainee(s) told ,me 'that :this COJ1ifud had occud"ecf. d. [j e. others who observed thiS conduct·,describeCl it to me. o :r. have relevant informat:ion classified above ~IS.Et:REp:. f. 0' L nevero.b~erye<:l tlijS'C00duct n()r h~rd 'abol!t it fromsomeon~nvhoCfid. a. D I perS0nally.6Ds~rVed this:conduc::t. 0 r observed detalnee(sJ In ',a ..cond iti0h that led 'me to, be!.leVe that this conduct had ,occutred. c- D O'etainee(s) told me that this conduct had .0lO:curred. d', D otherS, who observed tliis ceJidlict described if to me. e. O· r have relevant Information classified abov.e, 115:ECREr"·. T, 61 I . nev.er'observed thfs:conduct heard _. . . ' . nOi ... .' .. . ·about . it from ,someone . . . who did. b. , ' , ~ ., ~.. OIGQ-004850 34. 'OJ:h~r.tr~atment or ac;;tipn' causing ?igr.ilfj~1!r. Rhyskal pain ot' injury, :or' ~au$.IJig di~fig.urerh~.nJ qT .tleath . . 'a: 0 I personally observed thls:conduct b, 0 f'observed de~a~ne~(s} in·a. 'c;:ond itlon that led 1J).e tq bel!ev~ thq~·thjs E:ondu,ct had 'OGcurred. '~ .. 0 D~Ji;lil1ee(s) tQlp ro~ thgtl\1is tond<u.c.t h.a~ :Q.ccHrre9,! 'Q •. 0 othelF>: whq 'E:', f: 9b'per:v~q tn.ls tQn~4c;t (;I.~~C;(i!Jed It to me. 0 I hE:ive rele~nt information .tIa$"sifi¢d ~QoYe: l~s~tREf"'. 0 t' never Qb,s$rved thIs cQn,du¢f nor l"jeprd 'pqQ~t it from ~hi~9neWh9·did. :35. piaclrig a detainee PO a libt ?urfaC~ or burntn'ga ai=ta.ln~ . a. bi ~. d.. 1::, f; 0 I personalty observed this;conduct. 0 r observed detal,~ee(s)' In ,a.'cond It19[1 th9t led !TIt; t9 b~lIeve thaUhls c:;and.uc~ had 'occurred.•. O. De~ainee(sJ told me that this concj.uct hacj 'o9curred.. 0 ethers who ol;Jserved .this con.dl!ct.d~scrib.ed i~ "t<~. m~. 0 [ J:1C)ve rele.va.!1t in.forlTlatlon ~Ia~slfi.e.d ~bovl;. "-SECRET"'. I!f I nev.er Qbserve<;l this condu.d: nbr heard abo.ut itftom s.ort1e6n~'wh(;>'did! 36. USing, ~hatkle~6r 'otheji"e.straitits.in a' jJroIQn:g~dJf.j"ahi1er a: 0 I personally ,observed this"conduct. Lobserved detainee(s) in a condition that led me to believe that this conduct had ~ocGurred. b, 0 1;:. o Ib~talnee(.~) tQld fI1~ t~at t~,is <:qn~uc~ h.<'ld 'qs~urre4,. q: 0 Otherswh9 ogseryedl.h!s ~0JlductgesCfi.l:!ed it t,o'JIIe, ~. o !I h;:l\,e rel~\jdpt, in'forrnatiQ"n clds~ifiep Cl1?9v~ "S.EC.REf', f. 0' f .~ 0 n~,!er ojJ's:eryedjhls:cQn~uct nor' h~rd 'a QOUt·It from's9mi?Qn~'l{Iiho: did. II perSonally observed tllis ·oonduct. • , . ; OIGQ-004851 ... ·, 0 I observed detalnee(s) In a .cond Itlon that led me to believe that this conduct had c. 0 Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had :occurred. d. 0 'Others' wh<;> observed th.is conduc::t described it; to fne: ~. 0 I have rel~vant iof<;>rmation j:la,ssified qbov~ "$E~mJl. f. 0' I nev.erob~rv~d this'c~nciuGt ,nqr hea~dabQut it frolT) ~on1eone who did. b. ' ,as. Forl':ingcf(:Iete.tifl~, to ·pe!fonil·demandiiig..libx;;;,:si~ca;;;,:·I...;;e:;;;,:'x;,;;e.~r.t:.:.:is;.;;e:...· a. . occurred. _ 0- r persOnally observed this rondlkt. h. 0 c; 0 q, 0 ~! 0 t 0 Lobserved detainee(s} in a'coRd iiion' that led me to believe 'that this conduct had ,occurred. Detalnee(s) tald me that this-conduct had o'ccun:ed. Others. Who -observ~ 'tNs G('~n4uct~escriqed it to m~., I, l1ay~, re~~va~r.jt i'nt<;>r[Tla~ior:J: 'cIa:~?ifieg aI?9Y~: '~S;E.CR.I:f)\ ~ n~v~r,q,~,~~rve:<l thts,:cot:lg!,l.~t nqp.heaf.d ;a~Q.4J It from :~lTleonew~o d!d,. a: 0 ' personally' obServed tliis .conduct. b, 0 I,obserVed detaihee'(s} in ,a:cohd ition tnat led me. to Delieve theit this cohduct had :occurred. ,c. o iDetainee(s) told me that this conduct had ;occurred. d. 0 Others. who observed this conduct·descrlbed it to me. e, o II have releVpnt information classified ~~0ve' "·S~C;J:~.ET";. f: ~ 1. never0b$E3rv~:cJ thiS conduct n9r heard '~pput it from ,s0!JlE?one'\I\f~o did. ;4Q.I threatening 0 0 c; 0 to use,erectriC~l.sh9<;k6ti a detainee a. I persOnally observed this :cond,llct. .b', Lobse-rved detainee(s). in a co,ndition that led d. d me to believe,that this cOnduct had m:curred', 'Detainee(s) 'fold me tnat this con<:! ott. had .0cGurrecr. bthers who observed .thls conduct described It to me. e.', 0 1. hav,e relevant rnform?tion dassifieq .i:!IJo17e "SEGRET~I •. f. 0 I l)eVerob5~rved. t,hfsx'?l.1duct oQr heqrd ,about it from~sQmeOne who diQ. OIGQ-004852 41, Intentionally delaYin.g -or denying :detainee medical ~are a, 0 I per~Jlally ob~rved this:cqnduct. b. II:obse(V,,~d d.e~irl~ets) !n ,a:q)hd ifjon. that I,e<! .me to belieye tha(thi~ conduQ: nad Q'cc;unep. o c. D 4, 0 ~, O~taine~(sJ t~IQ m~ that this condu~t hap (jccorr~. Others Wtl9 observ~d 'tUI$; ~pndu,ct d~(:r,ibed It to' me.. D- r' have relevant Information' dassifie.d aboVe, "SECRET", f. ~ r n:e,!er'ob$~rv!i'!~ thi~,cQnd4ct n~r'h~rQ :abqu.t it frpm pom~pn~ who' ~,i:d. 42. 'Hooding or blihdfQJdiJig a ,,detainee other than during ttarisportatio:n ~ ,.QjI,obseI;V~q'd,e~9in'eer~) incr'con~ itian: th~} led me to b~ljeye thi;tt thi~ corJduct had ·qCl:c;urred, c" D. !()~tpjnee(s) t9~q me that tn!S, ~,(mducJ na.,d lo,G.curred. 0 I h~y,.E;! rel~vant iDforrJ:\a.,tion j:iassified .q1;l'O,ve, '\~,EC,I~.ETaI,. ,L!:.L® ,I:never:OOServ.ed, this;conduc.t nor heard about It from someQn_e__W_"_ho_,_d'_jd_, e', -' 43. Subjecting a detaineEn6 :extremely cdld ,or hot.ro6m .teni'petatures, f<:fY: extended 'p.erlbdsa. b. :c. <I. ¢', o lIJ:ersonal!Y observecl ~hi~ '<;qn~uct. I o Ii: observed: de~qlnee.( 5) In C} 'co ncI1t1.<;> n' that led m~ to' belle'\l~ thE.ltt~ls conducth§ld 'occu rred. o !Q~~~i.nee(5} tolq .rn~ tjlpt ,this COiJduct ~ad oq:4rre<;! o !Otbers, who ol}se,rved tl:1is, condl1.ct d,e$priQe9 it tg m~, o ir have releVelfl~ lnformeltlqn c1assifleq 'a b(;I\Je ·~EtRET'!. i f. ~ !t never obsen(ed this,conduc.t' nor-h¢at.d abb,iJ~ it from sQm'ebne. who; dJ,d. 44, SUbj'e.d:in'g a ,de~aine~: to ~0 iqUQ music II personally observed this conduct. OIGQ-004853 b, ~ 0 1 observed detalnee(s) In a ,cond Itlon that led me to believe that thIs conduct had 'Occurred. c. [j Oefainee(s) told me that this conduct had 'occurred. d, ¢; t: 0 q(hers wh~ observed t~i$ cOl!duct-descri~ed It to m~: 0 I hav~ rel~van:t In(ormatlon c1assftled q'bove, "SE¢RET'J . 0" r n~v,epob~rv~9 this cqnd uct nQr ,hearfl abQut it (rplT! s,omeone: who dJq. 45.. SUbjecting' a ,detainee t9 bright, fl!3'$hin9...llil:;.;Ii;.;;;ts,-o.::..r:..:,d;;;.;a;;.;,r.;::;;k.~I1~;;;.;s:;.:;.s_, _ a, D' r personally. observed this .conduct. b. p r,observed detainee(s) In a,coAd iiion' that led me to' believe that this conduct had :occurred. 'I:'; 't: D. Oetal nee(s) told me that .this cond uct hadoccu rred. 0 (J~hers who observE:;d tOIS c~nd u~t' <;Iescri,bed it to me: 0 t, !1~,v:.~,r,?~V?lnt infQrlJ1a'tlorr c1a'~5ifJ~c;I al;l(;lV~, '~SJ;'C~"-. 0 r n~v~r:observ.e.~ ~hls'con~uct ngr.near.d 'a~o~,t It .fr:om.$Qmeon~w!lo ~I.d.. a: o ~ personallj-obsenied, tl'lfs.condlltt. ~, ~:' b, ~ II,obserVed defainee(sJ in 'a~co'nditlon that led me'to believe that·~his co,hduct hcid'0ccurretl.. c, d. o Oetainee(s) told me that thiS' cond uct had ;Q'c::curr:ed. n Others, who observed this cond uct described it to me: e. o ,I hav,e relevant inform9tion c1assrfi~ above '~SECRET'\ f, 0 " I never observed thiS c0nduct.norheard:~bout did. ., .. ..... .it.from . . .someone'who .. .,,~ ~",., ~ ~., ~'."'" -:47. Using: ,duc;t tape.I;Q restrait;l, g.ag.'j 'or punish a d,EitaineE:! a. 0 r personally bbserVed this conduct b'. 0 I :obselired t1etainee(s} in a cond itlotl that led me to, believe that this c:6ndut;t c. 0 pefainee{5}'fold me that fhis conduct had ;oc€liti;'€d. d. 0 Others whQ obsefVed .thls conduct describeCI It to me, ~: 0 T, ~qye releyaqt fntOFm?ition dassi~i~ a!Jove I~SEGREt'I .. f. 0' I l)ever·o.b,se.rJed th(s 'ConClu~~·nor heqrd -about i,~ Trorn.sorrreon~ who dJd.. had .occu'rred: OIGQ-004854 48. Using rapid respo.nse teams:and/or fotted ,cell a: 0 personarly observed this cqnduct. 0 ['Obsc('~'ed detc!in'ee(s) in ~·condit.iqn thaj: le<t .me to' believe th?!t thi~ C;ondYQ: 0 Detaln~El{sJ tolp me: that this condu~t hap .occurred. 0 Qth~rs who ob~rv~ (trts Cprl!1uct a~scd,bed It to roe:.. 0 have relevant. rnformatioh'das"Sifieci aboVe "SECRET". 0 I ne~er- <?b,S§\'V¢p thi$.CQnduc.t npr 'h!'Xl(cJ ~bdll~: it'from .soliie.~n.e_ wh~ dJd. b. c, d, e. f. .go. extractions' !lad;~curred .. Please provide:lhe ap(iroximate timeframe,dunr'u;l wbich this·rol1.du.ct.OCcurred. From 03/2'003 to. O~/2003- h. The- .de~ainee(s} trea.t¢d In thLS 1. 0·'Gl.(ar'ltaria~9' way ~ere. ici¢at¢il at the time in : DDo Not. Recalf -- lOlraq :3 0 -Afghanistan 4 0 Other Locat19n 5 0 Db No.t Reeclll j. PJea~e'id.(:mtjfy ~he 'qe~_i.n~(.~) by narn~ a,n~ tl!.Jm.b~r: . It wasn't ~n~p'ecific.df#:alne~:Thl$'.W!ls I;m an--orJentatlo.n t.oqr of the,Ga{T1p Delta'. Tl:Jey. ~pla!ned the, prOc.eSs fOr removing ifrisofiers from J:e!ls.M theY hat! ii' weap'oo .br fe:ftlsed ·to exit. It wa'S the.ir veJ:Y ~IQld pro.toco!. ' . j. 'P:Jea:~.~ 14eritlfy ~h~ per~!1(S} Who ~reate·~ the qetaln~rs) In ·.thfs man~r, including their name«s),:an'd government agenq'(ies): Sge" ab'6VE! . k. ·Please id12:l').titv any 6~her FBI 'personnel or non-FBI personifel 'who ob,seryed' detciirieels). treated in'tfijs>rtialitier:~.lriGludjn.~ their narhe{s] ~nd .a9e:l'i0'(ies)r .. ., NfA . 1..l:hj~'i:Pnd\Jct occl,med in fOrtl:l~q:ion With: .1; 0. Ofle ~.eta:rn.ee >2 0 Sever~1 de~lnees; t2:.04l 30 Ml;Iny .(Ietainel;$ (m"Or~ than ~J 'l.0 DQ Not Recall . m. (.Optional) Please descrIbe the releya.nt "ir.cilr'nsta·ri'ceS· in mQJ;edetall: OIGQ-004855 49,. Using a military workflig dog o'n or near a.detainee oth.er than during ,detainee transportatfai'l a. 0 r personally observed this..conduct. . b', ~. '(f: e.· r: . 0 Lobserved detainee(s) in o"90ndition' that led me to believe that tills conduct had .occurred. 0 O'etaiflee(s) toldme ~hat this conduct . haQ 'oecCirreQ. . 0 Qthers'Wh.Q obselY~ this cqnductdescribe,d it t9 m~; 0 1. have re~vant information clas~ifieci !3lJove "SEC,RET". 0 r nev~r 9,bs.e.rve.d this'-co,nduct ncwhe2jrdabout it rrorn.,sqmeqne'wh.o did. ;50. ThTeat.e,liing to us~ro!ljtarywQrkln'g. d6.gs.:Qn or near a detafn¢~· a. 0 r. p.ersorially·,observed this.conduct. b. [j r observed'detafnee(s) in 'a,cond ition that led me to believe thaUhls conduct had .occurred. c. 0 Detalnee(s) tOld me that this conduct had 'occurred. d~. D t>t~er.s' whp'observed ~his ,c0n,duGt des.cribed it, to, me, ~. D. r h~v.e'reley~m't i.Qf9r.ma~iQn cJas!?ified 9b,~ve ~$ECR.Ef'!? t tr ~ever O,b~l'i!rv~~ t~ls.'cQ!1tju~tf.1()r h?ar~ about I~ from·S<lmeQn,e·~vh.og!P.. o .501. lJ:.s.Jrig spiders,. scorpib.ils, snakes, pi" ·othe.t animals; on' pr near a ,detaitie.~ ·a. D II' rier.spnally observ.ed thlsi!0Muet. b'. O. !r;obser.v.ed·deta·ihee(s) in a<condltion that led 'me to· believe thatlhis conduct· had ,occurred. c. 0 Detainee(s)told me that this conduct had 'occurred. D 'e.· 0 f: 0 d,. Ot.her'S who ol;>ser;veq this cO!1du~t"d~scrlbed If to me; t have relevant iof9rm.~t(on c!asslfie.~ .above "SEqRE;f"'. l.lleY~f "9.b.~rvl3q t.b!?·:q?,1}9 uq~ 'nq,r hear,d ap'ot,J~ iprqm ·sgn:1e9.n~Who d icj, 0 . r persOnal!y' observed. this coJidUtt. b. 0 r obse'rved' detaineer~) in 'a .c6nd ition that led me to believe thaUhis conduct had .occurred. c; 0 Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had occurred. d, 0 others who observed this conduct described it to me. 'a. OIGQ-004856 . . e. D I have relevant InformatIon' classified above Ii'! f. '~SECRET". I never observed thls.conduct nor heard about It from-someone who-dId. ·53~ Dis.re'spectful sta~~ments-, han~lIing"or actions- involving the KOlJln a. D b. D d. D d. G e. D Ii'! f. [ p~rsOnally bl5servet:l dbse:iiled Uiis.t6Mu.ct. de"(alrtee~s) in a cond itlcrl tnat led "me to believe that ttlis c6naud: hat! o:ctu'retl. Detainee(s) told me tHat this.toilfu.tt had .ocCUrred. Other's who observed this tondLrct d:escribed it to me., L have relevant Information classified a'bove "SECRET-. I never observed thls..conduot nor heard about it from someone.who dId. ·,.9I... Shaving ~ detainee'S' facial or .other hairto Mlbarr?lss'or humiliate.a detainee a. D .Pcl"sonally' obServed this conduct. b. D .bbs.er:ved l:Jetainee(s} In 'a· cond ition that led me to believ.e that this CQnduct hoo.o.ctut:red.. c. 0 Deta,l.nee(s') tQlo mell.la't this eondu,tt had '<icc.urred. d. D IOthers- who observed this cdnduct described if fa me .e. [I 1 have Televanl: Information tlassiffed a'bove "SEtREf··. t: Ii'! 1 nev.er observed this~conduct nor'hearo about' it from:someone who. Old. 55~.~.lacing a w.oman';s Glotlilrig :Qn a.detainee D ~ person'ally Obsel'ved thls.co.Mutt. b. D 11 bbserv.ed .detaihee(s). itl.a.conditibn th'at fed me to believeJhcit this-,condud had occurred. ~, D Detalneg(sl told Jh~ toat this c<5nduCt had '~(nifred. {;" d. D lathers-who obseJited thls oonCluct described It to me. e. D 1 haVe relevant information "classified above ~SECREP\ f. (;'[ r never obServed tllls'conduCt n.oF:heard :aboIJt it ffom Someone who did. ..-- " -, •.. ... ..... _.... ._....... - . . ,_. ... " ... . . ... ,... ... _._ ..- .... - --_._- ... _._ .. _.- .. . - "' OIGQ·004857 56. TQ(J(;hihg a'. b. <;:. d~ e. a detainee or acting 0 I personally ob'serv.ed this"conduct. D [:observed detainee(s) in Cl'condition that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred. 0 Detainee(s) Wid me that t~is conduct hac:{ 'Occurred. 0 Ot~ers' whQ observetj t,t! is cO,ne! uet deseri~eP it t() m~ 0 1. have relev.ant inrormatjO'n c1ci?siffe,d ~!?,ove "SECRET". To ~ I nev~r b; c. 1 qbserved thjs'copducLoQf'h89rd apOl,lt it from sqmeqn~who did. S:Z. 'Hold'ing' detairiee($) Wh~9 Were .detalnlng the"p~rson. a. toward.a deta'inee ina S$xual manner not ~ffidally -a~J<ri.o:WI~,gea '" or r¢!;Ji!?tered ;:is- ~9¢h by the'ag~n~ " D I p,erS9n~IIy'0:bserved ~his,C0nduct. D, Lo9'S!'m.;r~~"r:letpln~ets} In ,a 'c;:pn9 itiorrtha1i I,etlrpe t(;r 1?e.I!eve th~t'thl$- o;>r:rque;t ha~ 'Q(!q.~rred~ n '[jetaine~(sHoJq me thqt ,tl:lis: tonQl1c,t ha,d :occurred.. D Qfh,ets Wm) '9Q?ery~d tt)i~ cpn<;luc;t ctes:crfbed it ~(): rn~. ~. D t h?lye rel~vant ll}formqtlon :classifl¢d ~I:>ove '\SEC~!=Til'. f. Ifl r never 6bs.en.ted this:contll,i¢,t nor heard .abo_ut it from sdrtreone.Whq did,. ~:., D. r: per~nalry'o.bserve,d this wnduet. I b; D Lobserve-q 'detcfif)~e(s} in a 'Gondlti0n tDClt led rn~ to believe th~tthis c;:o.nduct tri3doccurred" :c. D Re,):<;linee(s):~oJd fTI~ that this' cond'!Jc.t bad oq::urr~, d,. 0 Qtn~rs jN,ho Qb~erv~d tbis G,Qnd,qct d;esqlped i~ to' m~. e', 0 r: hc;l.';,e relevant i,r.tformatli:m <;:1!3ssiHe<;f above, "SECRET". a,. f. ~ .i n~ver 9.Q~J\led, this Cl;mdulj nbr h~rd ,abpl\t . . . it fr(Jm:sqm!=-o:m~':who'd.i~~ . 59. Threatening to"send a ttetqinee to clno.th'er countrY for p,etehti6nor'moh= a{jgressive.interr6gatjon 'a'. 0 I b~ D. r observed c. personally observed this conduct. cf.~tai.IJ~~{s} in a>eondj~iqJ) that lee! lJle to belJev~ thqt this c;ond,uct o iDe~ainee(s) told 'm.e that th1s c9nduct had 'qccurred rq-d oc;:cl,Irred., 1 ,., OIGQ-004858 " ,. , D Others who observed this cond uct described It to me. e. D I have relevant information classified above "SEC~ET'). f. 0 r never observ~d thi;:vc<?!lduct n9r h~rd apout i,t froms9me(:>n~wh~' , I d. qid. :60. Threatening 19 takeactiQn againsta getaine$'~'faniily :a. b. <::. D I perSQnally observed this :conauct. 0 I ,bbserveddetciiriee(s) hi a eond ition that led me to beUeVe that this eondu,ct had ,oc::cuited. 0 Detainee(s1 told me that this conduct had ,o,ccufr.ed. d. Cl ,Others who ebserved this conduct described it to me. '.e;, D I have relevant Information classified 'ilbove "'SECRET",. t; 0, I, never o~$erved this ~col')d.uct nor h~~d ;~b()l!t it 'from 'someon~wtJo D b. D e': D d. D -e. 0 a. f. ~. I perS9rially,observ,ed this ,conduct. I;observed"detain¢e(s) In a' cOnd.itlc)n that led :me to beUeve tbat this conduct:had ,o.Gcufr.ed. Detainee(s}told me that this mndud had ,occUrred. Others iNh0 observed :this C;:Qnduct descdbed it to me. I hav.e relevant information ciassified above ·!SECREf". 1- never'observed' this-conduct nor'heard aboutit from 'someone.who-did. a. 0 r persOnally obsellled this,conduc,t. ,b:. 0 I b.bseryed detainee(s) in 'a ,c;:orid ition:Ul'at C. did. led me;to believe that'tHis CO'ridlkt had oGciurred. o ,Detalnee(s) told hie that this tond'utt had .occurre4. d.O Others who observed 'this' c;ondutt described it to me. e·IO r have"relevant i.nfOfmatlon :Classified a6oy'e "SECRET". f. It! r never o.bserved thls:conduct nor heard I a bout it 'from someone who did. OIGQ-004859 63', Othertre,atmenJ of a~ detainee that In you'r opinion was unprp(esslpn~11. unduly bars!) ,or ,aggressrv~l abusive, or unlawful cbeJcive~ 0 b" 0 'a: e. I personally' observed thls.conduct. Iobser:ved detainee(s) in 'a'cond ition that led me to believe that this conduct had ;occurred. o pe~aLnee(s} told me tpaf this,cQnduc~ had 'oCCUlTe(:J.• '4: 0 O~tTers \,Nho ob.servE¥! t~ls eondu~t7d~Cflbed ,e; 0 I have r~revant ioformatiq'n .classified ab'ove' "~.ECRET'l. f. rt:r rnev~r 9Qserved this 'cQnpuqt ndr heprd'9 b_olJt it ·froin.,sQrrre.o.r1e WhQ did. [t t0l'!l.e. lfiAV!il't'ij'j(@m\tmj§!!i!Alijiiil@jJ§1i1[m·~.·:.' ><,<.> . . / .::'>~'; . '1) ,64. Did y"6U ,p.b!3l=rve a'ny 'impe(s6natJon' ,of FBI RersonlJ~1 by ,ariypnequrilig an intetvieW Cir interrQ'g"ation of 'a:detalnee?' ' ' DYes o No '65., Did anydetalne~'or oth~r .person ;tell yoo that he or she had witnessed 'the Imp~r.sonatlon of FEU ~i>,ers6n:nel in coimecti0l') with detainee i"ntervjew or lnter-rogation? '0 Yes 0 66',: Are you aware of any' II ?,h a(Tl." or II s!C!g~d,n'<jetaine~interyi~w?,'9r'lnt~rrqgati,po~.cpoo:l!cted for MElm ber!? :ofthe' lJ.:$. Cqng tess' or their a st9m No , - OVes: '0 No, any military 9r 'inteJllg¢nce p,ersonn~l ~even:f~.nY' or'd,eJay F.BIC\cce~s to,'a _d~t:(lriee th~ FEU wanted t9 q),1es,tlbri :becau,sethe delqlne¢ had Su,sl<;flned IIijurle-S after he was cap,tlJr~~n' , Ove.s' ~ N9 .. :9?. To: Y0\.l r knpwledge;..did ,68. Dld'you ,ever end your participation in or observation of a detainee interview'or Interrogation becau~~ .PTth~ intervi~w 'Qr interr<;Jgatic;m m~thod~. ~~ing 'u.~p? , . QYes> 0 No ,59,.W~re, YQlJ'e.ver told thcftanO,ther FBl:emp:lpye¢'ehd'ej:I hi.s or f't¢,r pc(rtitipatil=io' iii ~:fr pbserN'qttQh of,..a· .defaioee in'terview. or interrogation beEalJse of the:interview'.or'jnterrogatio'(l method's Being used? QYes '0'No, lD~ During ·any pf yqur p'Ver~ea$ t\epJqyrpent~pr assignm~Ii~~1 #it! ym.f re'p.ort qOY concero~ r~garding a'ny.:detaioee interview"or interrogatiQn practices', or .ottlerty'pes:6f detainee tr¢atriierit, to, an' FaI OIGQ-004860 supervisor? Q Yes. @ NO" 71, Duriii.~fal)y:ofYo.Yh:fv.etsetls,.d~ploYrtl¢htS assjgnr'n.ents, 9ip you, report alJY c;oricerns,regard.ioq ,any,aetailiee in.tervie,W·.dr interrog.ation practices'or other types of d,etairiee. treatment you observ.ed or heard ab0ut, to a non:..FBI supervisor or other non-FBI personnel?" , or . b:¥es @'No: 71:.. Aave-:}'ou t~ver lteen Qrd¢r:e.<f ~r .t1fr.et:ted n~XtO r,e(:fort, or:dis.c;.q,urc;lg·ed .In'My W"9Y fr.9JTl 're'p·ortllJ9.r QD,s~rVatio'n,s ,or ,~II~~alipns re;lat¢d '{o (I.~tainee tri:!a~rti.'ent or lriterviiewor intert9Q'atidn 'actioli.s 6}" practrces? ~ No. O';yes '7S'. Hqye you e?<periencec! ?!"ny act\Jgl qr t.!lTe.a.ten~~ rett;lliati9Tl: f9T ~'Port:i.ng p'~serVc!ti2!1s<orall,~g~tjon~ 9f.9~tctjti'~e. tr~q.tFne,~~.or' i!i.l~rv.iew Qt !n~~H699Ji9Jj ,agig,t1:? Pr'PI~:I¢'t!~.e~'] ¥:.e~· 0, N9 o 74. (Op.t!onaJ~ Ple.?~ p-r<?Ylcj~ ~n'1 ~d~t~i9J1~J .~Qrnmel)!~ r:~g,~r~l.(og .tb~ r!,!.pQrtf.n·g 'Of ~Qrrs:ern~ r~!a,te.d, to' i,r:!~~ry!~~ at in~,~trqgi3~i,6n:t¢fhn,iql.!es.r ~~Jer1tJQii 'p'r'g'q:Jt;¢.~, 9r~9~hey a¢J;alrfe}~ tf,~'~menJ:, _~:U(~."· . . ., =~; '. 0' . 0 '.' :7-5. Were,;you aeorie(ea!: 'b~henli~in :th~ ~t,ai1d;:l'r(r debriefin FD-n.2):, eonc;:ernilig your ov¢r~as :assI9nment(:s) or-dep'k:lyme"ht(s) after-yoU' cb'rflpleretl :the ae-pldyment(s) or a-ssl.9nml2nt{'s)?< ();Yes' e No 76, -Addltl0nal R~commendatlons: ...... . . . C0mments.and . .. . . -.. . ~ ." TtJa.Okye,u fdr Y9Wr:cobperaticm irt.cqmpletjrYg this .ques~itlrir)~ire. OIGQ-004861