,
Depar~ment'of j,..s.ti~.e ·In!!pec~.or C;;en'er,al 'Questionnaire R~aa'r.di'1g Detainees

D,OJ.-OIG 'INVESTIGATIVE QUESTIONNAIRE
FOR R:EVleW" A~D USE ONLY. BYIN[jIVIOUAL FBI ~E'SPON[jENTS
... '. . 1:1'0 NOT FOR,W,ARD OR)jI$SEMI~ATE ..
, ,
QUESTIONNAIRE 10: te'St-OOO 015.6.0'
·As of ~h~ I~st time this qu~iiol:ul'~rre.w~~ ~\(~~" ~~me r~quire.d (iel"s: hav~, n9~ l?een'f::C?mplete·d.
PI.E;aSla;r,e,VieW'your reslionses·. .
'.

A.

.

,',

P~r~ol)pl Infprmation

Please p'rovide'the fQlI6vJin~ irlformatibn:
1. flr.st hame,
9 ~,7,? PER!U:?REEME{'J,T
2.. Mldqle Initi~I:6&'1CPERAGREEMENT
3: Last name:
6 ~. 7.C PERAGREEMENT
4. Entered on HOt-y Date (EOD):
6 & 7C
. ~; cill:r:ent D1VJsfpn/fieLd Office:
,6&.7C·
'6: Cl\rre[lt :fob titl~.:
Sl..!p~rViso:ry Speeji)IAg:eflt
-:7:. Direct~ia.l office.telephone hLi'ri1ber:
6 &7CPER,AGREEMENT
.8. fBI :c~1I. ph.one: il\Jriiber:
~ &jt PER,.ft~SEEivJEN~
',9. f$i p.iiil~er numher:
·6~:7C.PERAGREEfll/FNT
fa. eest cQntact numberfor'You'~
6& rCPERAGREEMENt

.B.• B'ackgroLind of Specific D:eployments or Assignntents
;t1.. At .any time a·ft.etfSeptember J.1( .20.01, i:lid 'You. seNe.as·a member o.fllie U.S. MUitary', or' as an
emplQyeeor contractor OT- toe FBI'or any other,government agency,. at Guantanamo Bay.: 'CiJba; Iraq;
:
Afg~9ni.sta.n; 'or frr areCls C9r:ttroll~ QY ~he 1).:8:. Miljtc!rY Q,r'a lJ.$. Int~I.lig~nc::e ~r\llc_e irn;~nt:'JectiQn:with ~~e:

:9lpl;ial

W~r

on xerroT1

.
@·Ves

0

No

f2,. Enter the nu.mb~J:of time:s ypO, w¢r:e depiQy~,d .or~cis::!ig netr to each of ttre-foir6wing lopa~iolis
{Guantanamo Bay, t~ba;; lraq;..Af,ghanistan; ,or ili-any areas eoritroJled by the. U.S. MilitilIy.ora .'u.S.
i!'lt~lI.ig~.nq:~ serVrc::~J>¢

For,~each. deployment

Location 'select one)
- .. ' - "
.
r.... ..,........,.. .. ......
~

'.

.

or assignrileiit .complete the following section.
..

l?ep,lIwm¢pt'or a~sign'!J1erit'~eg~J1';il~r

aboll.t' .

.

[j'!lp.![).Yri1.en~~ir.~.55i.gn)ill~lJt.en,iledon.

or. abput.
.

lG'u'ant.anamQ .BaY.
0.6/02/2003:
0.7/0'2/2.0.03.:
1;z.-a. Vv:t:lat was tlie:gen:e~a'lliatur~ Mf:! P:l)11iq~e. 9t'YQU'i"·~ssiglirnelit.and :a!'=tiVftieS-?
Superuise, fBI·agehts..Gohd uotiriQ intet:\t.iews-Qf detarnees.
.
1'2b. Please provide:the names of the~spedficcamps) bases" or facilities where you worked.
'
;t Ylor:k~ ·at §amp Defta-( the 'Intellig erlee .Cent~ri ? nd ·~he. se<;~re~t9rn partrn~lJted Jnt0r:m_a~iOn FaciliW.
lZc. N.Q~~: I,f infprmation' :a/;>dlit a :Sp.ecific .camp', bas~,. or 'facil ltV i!?c1assifje,d ~abJlY~ SEeRET, .
please .check h~r~'I~t ioclude in YQ~r:answer that you haye;llC!adi~iqhal informatIon tla:?sJfi~q"abQve
'SECREf,"" and, if y.ou khow, 'iCl entify the,c1assification: lev.el, ticket, lCo'in partlilentl. p rog ram J ,or .other
designa~ion that·applies ~9'·t~e~.!nforr:n~tion~.Do: nQt incluc!e t,he ·addJtJo.nal·C1asslfied inf9rrnation: It:! your
,. ' • .; -.

~

.1'\ .... )...

~

_'

'.~ ,~.

x.; _

...

•

OIGQ-005308

'"
Q

q~stionnaire'

e

re,sponse!i. blG persdnnel with the necessary clearance wilt contact you to.rel:eiVe it.
,Positio~

-

:

.__ gQ.i~~i~fLk111i!.,!ry J!al@[l g.nltt.~l!mg
';12~. D'. ViiI,) JOIntly in.tervi,eW gr inl¢i"topa~"any detainee ,Yltth hQ{I-FBI p¢rsonne.l? .

~

_.

~

•

'

_

•• _. _ _ ,

.' With: what

•• _

kinds

•

__

•

_.~

•

~

0~

~

• __

~

of t)on.-FB:I p~sonT)el

'CI.1~

~

O~

•

__ ,

•

_. w

~._.

__

~

_,~

_

b6
b7C

.__'__

.~

'

~
•

~

_. __

••

~

'you w.9rkjoin~.LY?·

: 0 CUP

; &1 ·Q.ther U.5. Military
: 0 U.:5, ilJ.telilgen~e, ag.efi<;y

:: n f.:ore~.fn'milltary or lotellr~em::,e:,a·g.etJCY

.

::- 0 O!her
'

•_

.'

~

"-'-'-

_

~

__

~

__

•

...

~

_

• __ w

~

_

•••

~

__

"

' __

~

):

~

_._.~- --

- - - - - - -- - -~ - -,-- -- - -'- - ~'-'-->- --- -- -- - - - - - -,- - - -,--- - - - - _ ... - - -'-- -'- - -"
.:t2f. Old 'youjointly plan any. detainee Intervlew'or Interrogatlon·'strat89y"objectlvesr, or tactics wIth' non- ~.

~F~I per:sQnn¢11

:'

~

~~

~-W~h wh~tki~ds~o(non~FBi per~;;-n~ldid -y~~

0

.~

CITF

:: 0-other

0*

W.0;k:JoilitIY? -'- -'-'~ --'---.--- --- ~,- --_..

;:

R

-'-

-'-"---

~'- ~::

.

.;;

.u.s.. Military.

.,'
,.

,; ~ US, int~lfigen~ agen,q:

~ 0 ror~.Ig)l mJ1itary Qr lntelll~nce.
::; 0 Othi::r

:j

a;g.enoy

~':.:: :,,~ ::,.::::.::. :":':'.: :::: :,:::':: :-.::.::: :':::':: .::,:':..:: :.:_.:: :':..::: :,= ::..:::.;::.:.::. :':": i,
.129, .wer¢'you ever o$herwrse [ovolved.ln detalne,e.lnt~lVJew,'>or Inte-rrogatlQnS_Wlth ,non'.,fBI
:
.0 Yes
No
_
L~~tio-;;,(:;:;~:)~ -

e

- - --..,.- ...- - '- De-ploYrri'e-nt;f~;~ig~;ij.;~b;;;
~liQ,I!~

.

.

per50lin~l?

~ -:-0";' - - oc:pj'o~e~nt,;r'~';$iorime}t~';n:ded~o-n - IIr~.b:O,,,,t·'

,

.:
:;

.

,gil"Titan"mo Bay,

D:7/~lrioQ~,
09129120Q3
12a, Wh'!lt was th~ ,general na!JHe a',fI(:I purpos~ o'f'yo~p~~ig nlTJ.eni: ~mq ,i3qt~vi~ie.s?'
Sup.e!'Vise.. _FtR~g~nts:Cl~Mli~ing iiitervi¢W's(6:(detaJneff~,
·l..zb. Please PlbVitie the-,names Qfthe\sp~CiflC camps, b'ase's" or facilities Wber.e you w.orked.
lworked cat Camp Delta, the-lntemgence·center; and the :Seo:ure Compartmented Information- Facility.

i'2<;

NQt~,~

lf i.nrorm~Jii;m ?,bout C!'spe<;ifJt;;;:qlmp,

I:?,,!~e; O'r fa:~i1ityjsJ;Jas~!fi~4 :al::!o:v~

SEC;RET,

p.lease·ch~<;k' here:2fr lrK;lu,c!E;' in ,W?ur-<m"Swe,f that ;you. h?lv~·JOa,dqitj9nal [nforrn5l~ion'(;lassi1i~d it.bp,ve
'SECRET,'" and. if ,you' ktiQw;. jp¢ntifY :the·'cla's~ifi(:alk:in, i~ve,l, ticket, c,oOJPa.rtrhent, 'pr9g.J1lnl, or 'other'
deslg'hatlon tha't. applies to,:·t1'ie,lnformafloil. Do n6t IhdOde th'eClCldltloha"1 classlf1ed lilf.ormation·ln your
~!J~sti.onn.aire, respon~. DIG personnel ~ltll tl)e'l1e,~a,ry ~learanc~·w.iU ~on:tact yel.! ~~ receJY~ ,it. •

,C,l_.,. __ .. _' __ .. _,"- ..

.::.. _ '"' '"-'-

-,,_ "- __ '- __ ,,-_ '- __ ..

~

_:.. __ '-'-_.__.. "_'--__ '-' __

J.~'!,!l~a~ld.e!:!~~," 2X, ~~~; ~~1ec;S!tl°.r_ a.!..!~~ ~,f!l~,-t..~!f;if~~~n_~~~ 1.9_~~~ y~u_«!l.~e;!,l't !:e.P.9~~:
:~,g t:!'!9.:. 'lb_U! E~e.lgyO]~tl.F _d(~sJtn:..~~ri!-:
f'lIame.

I

Pc,sition'
Unit

chlef. MilitarY Uaisoh Unit" FB1HQ

b6
h7C

OIGQ-005309

ydetainee ~it-h-n-o~:FBI Re·rso.n;el?- -.- - ~ -.- -.- --- - ---:
Yes
0 No
-_l-'
-_ -':;- - - _._-'~.---'-- -!.

:.ii~ ~[jid yo~Toin1iYi:~terview ;-r-in~rrog~te '"a7J
<:)

I

~"::_

--=---- ---_..

t-

-

-- --- ---

-,----- -

·t12f. DId 'you joihtly plan any i:I.eJ:ainee
:FBI p¢rsdhhe.\7.·

-

-_~

.

I.

_:-.

int~rVie.w Or

-_

';'-,...-

-

-,...

-_-

interrogation' :strategY~Qbjectivesl' or' tac;tii:s w~ttr ilon- .
., .

0 Yei>

0

No·

:-w~i1whit ~i~is~Q{hQn:j:~i p.~r~.~n~ai~ "Y'Qv w-o~kj9intiY? - -- - -- - - - - -- - - -- - -.- - --,- -- - - ---

: 0.cnF
= 0 OtHer U.S. MjJitary
: 0" US. iiltellig.ente ag"eney
.: 0 Eor'eig n military or 'iht~iligetll:::eagency
:~ d Ot.l)er
.

.,

_.

_

.:..

...... ' _ _

.. - ' , . ' _ _

. . ' _ _ . _ . _..... ...;._ , _ .

...,

_ _ ........ _ _ , _ .

'_'

.....

-' _ _ '.-' '- _

"".,.

_'-.'

,

~

.

~

'.

_.

_

l»

_

.........

_'_

~,
...
.

:iig.W~r~Y~u e~;r~oth;rWjse'j~vglv~ 'in""'d~~·in~~.i!1terview~ ~r iht;r;og,~ti~ns~~£h~iib-n~~~I -pe~~ni)~i'~: .
~

o~

<:;/z~-

@~

- - - -,- - - - --: _.-- - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - . . . -:.-------'- - - - -,... - -- - - - - - _.. . - - -'- - "-'- -- - .................... - - - . . . - - -'
~

.'

~--

<1'-

~..~,~'."~"

~

."~'~"""

.

. .-

;f::jj- .... ;.~ ..

:C' .

... "

'. - ,~ ':': :r-,":--"

.'

is. Dip 'YQU recdve i:iny, training',' instrucfion; or ~gui.dcms::e .sp:eqiflcaIlY in' prep.arati\)n for any of YO/Jr
Q.'(erseas.d€!ploY!'T1¢ht,s or' a~sjghments~

.

00.0 Not Recall

llJ. ~n prepi;lrati6n.·f9f any.·9(yqur.;Qver§ea~· dMiqY[lents or assigplJ1~!lt~i'~.id yo.!J' (e:ceive~a\ly. trainingj
in$tn,rction,:.or:g.Uidance :COilceming l!ie:stahtlards"of.cohdui::t .appliCabl¢.to the treatment,
interview! or interr6gatlon:0f detainees by FBI personnel?

OYes

:b,bo (\fot.·Recall

15. In p"repar<;lJ;iqn, fpt Mr'Q(Y9~rQver~E$~ Qeplqy.ri:l~nts'or a5sjgnm~n~djic;l .ygu· r~~ei'{e~ny. training; .
jristrud;iQn; or gJ..l i.danee conc.eniing 'tl1e;slanda'rd s-of"c'onduct:a pp Iica ble; to' the tr:eatr.rient,
.
interi/lew" or inter-reg,ati6h of.detainees by n6ii-FBIpersoniiel?
.
~bYes.

.(mo Not Recall

, 16-., In, pr¢para.tipn fQr ,i3I1Y :o.f your Qver~ea~a~ployril'en,t5 or ;:l~si~;mnielits,. did' YcilJ· r~l:eive'any traihin9J .
ihstructibrl,or',guidance i:cio'cerriing :wt:iat you Were supposed to db !frau 'obser-ved,or .heard ,ao8ut .
·the treatment,' interview,. or interrogatfon .Qf detainees by' FBI personnel, whiGh you believed to
Qej.l1~ppropr!ate'J.u.nP'rqf~!?SjQ.lJClI,coer-c.IYe.f"gb~~iv.ef'Qrunlawful'?
OQO Not

ReqJI.

OIGQ-005310

17. rn preparation for any of your overseas deployments or assignments, did you receive any tlClining,
l[lstructlon, or gufdanceton~mlng'what you were' SlJppOSE¥! to'~9 if you .obS"erved Qr h,eard about
·the:'t~atment,'intervle:o,v"or in(errQg"alion of:~l.~taine~ bY nCiti-F~I personnel! which:you helieved
to b~ lna'pproprlater llnprOf$sIQn'al.~ dlercIVe,_-abuslve,. ,or unlawful?,
000 Not Recall

·0N6

a. Training During ·O'yers~as'Deploymel1t!; or,Assigl:tlJlents
18', ,?~~O.g".~.~y b,f Yb~t' ?lJersea~rdel:ilo:yr.ti~':\t~ o~ assl<1flrh.~~ts,.d i~ ,you 're~re an~';t@J~!~g.1 Insthi.ctlOor;
or:guldaooe:CQncernfn.9 the standards. of;conduct apphcable to, the.treatment, Illtervlewr or
interrogation of detainees by. FBI personnel?

Q'pp NQt,8.~~~H

OrJo

.@Yes·

~a.a. Who. PfOv:jl;le9 t~j~ t~aini,l)q" l~sJru¢i9nj- qr'guidan.ce,?
Myself/.senior FBt-ag.ents, -and fBIHQ' Behavior'S.cientists,
l&b, BrigJY'd.escribe the su,b!?tahce of the :trainin,g" ihs.l:rPetiOri" of g:Oi.dahce·pr6vided ~P'You,

¢ultur<ilJ l~sues We~·~IS!;:.u~~·~.!?wer!2 Inr~n(l~w '~e.chnlques;alld rapllQrt J:;lullqlng',

Saf~lr-i~sue:,s 'vU~r~ :di.s'~u~ed,
1.80, Wfjs·,a.l)¥ PT the ~~in!ng, In$b]Jq:(on, gr gUI(:f~I)~~ pro¥!d.eq I'n wr.1tlng?

'DYes

0No

;0

Db'NOt Recall'

~9. Durin,g any ,gf ','o,ur py~rse'ps-tt~pJo'ym~n~s or as'sig oment~,

.

tI ict 'YO,u

re<;ei~ My tralllihO~ instrU!::tiori,

o'r'9uJd~ncj:!-,cj)n~rnlng the stanll.ar.d~ Rr:c.ondu~~qppllcabl~.t!) the tr:e'atmertt, If'l~ervlew:"or

iiiteiTb9atiOn'ofdetaine'es, by non--FBI perscmnel?

.0Y.es.

b.No

.

Qoo 'Not'Recall

·19a. Who ptOyided this fi:aihi.il91 instruction,. orgtildanc!:f!
CITF'ano D,oO persbtfrt¢1.

19b; BrleflY'de$trib,e to!: su.bstan<;:~:of .the tr~'iningl .instructil;lIir

orguida~,r!n>V:ided: ~b' you;

How to interview- people-'Of the Islamic faith was·.d(scussed along-wlth cultur.al-and faith
~$e9 I~u:~s.'

19c. Was"dny

-

of"the:tralnln9I'lnstructlon~.or

"

,..

"

.

.

gtildanl!e pro.vlded In:writlng.1

Oy~s $1'f9 Q: DQ I'fpl ROC.II
'29~. bt,lr:lpg '~ny 'of y?.ur ~\lersea.s d~,ploYrne.ny~ o~ ~~s!glJl1)e~~s, qld

yOQ

re~l~e any'trainlng, 'l.nsi::n,fctlon,\

jjr,g.uJd.?Inc~'co~fnln.g w~a.t YQU were StJP'P..Qsed to dq'lf ~u ·QPSE;OIE;d 'Qr hea(d _a~Qllt

tt)e'

treatrti'eilt, iritervi~w,"Qr iriWl'r6,g,atfOn -pt:d€!ciih~es by FBI' p.~r:$Onrlel ,. wHich' $'9\1, believeij to be
lria'ppropriate, 'unprofeSsibniil, .coeJ'ciYef abusiV.e... or IJnlciwfol1.

OYes

'

ONo_

-2L Dudng <:I:ny: ,of'YQur,ov,erseas' deplqyments pt C!:;;!ilgnlTl¢ri~si-iUd yo,u r¢.q;!iYl;!" ~nY:'(!Clinihgi hJs!:ructidtl,
-cfr gt,ll.dance·cbhcEfr.ning what YOU·Wen!:·SI1pposedlo. do,if you:opseiVetJ or hear-d,about the
tteafr'nemt, iriteruJew,,:6i' interrogaflon'of detainees by non-FBI personnel" which ;ybu' believed to..

OIGQ-005311

be iqappropriate; unprofessional" ~oerciyeJ;al>.usive, or unlawful?

:OYes
22.1n V,our.opinion, did' YOQ r.ecebte adequate tidlriing, Inst;ructi():n: or gUld,ahce reiatlng to ~tafldatds
of roriduet by FBI,and non-FBI persOnnel relating to treatment! interview; or interr.0.Qation,of
detainees prior to you ["deployment or asslg nm~nt7

0'Yes

0. No

2.;3. in -youropil)ipn" ,c:Ud you receive adequate training r instru,ctio!l,orguidanee r~l~ting to~tandards
qf <:Qnd.uct Qy TBI :and o'on-FEH per,spline! r~1<\ltiJ:lg to treatmentJ :ihterview,. pr interrqg atl~n,.of
,detaJn.¢,esdurhig. ydut deployment, or ~ssi9nment?

'

24.1n your ,ophlion,.,did you reGeive adequ'ate training.. iilstro,ctio'n, :or'$Juidante ,cdncerning what you
were supposed to ,do'lf:you, observed, 9r heard, about the treatment, Interviewl 'or:Jnter'rogatlon of
'qetgJliees;, b'1.F.B.~-9r nOI1-,Fi?t ,!?erSbnn~Ji th~t '1ou beli,eved was jnappt9PrJat¢; YM.r~Jes~loljarr
:<:;o~r(;lver :,abU$M~J or unlawfUl?
,

------------------------------------------------------ ------~-----~---_.

,l4a. ,Flrease describe the ways in which you believe the trainin.9~' fnstruction;or guidanee was
'
inadequate:

'_. jf~,~~:~?~!:!'!'~~,:Y"~ J<!1~~'y(h3i !9}P~ l·.,;d~~npL~~S~I~Leg:'jyiEJ,9 JB~cltt~_it!~t~.9~iqf!.~.:.
.2-5.. (Optional} !n whC;l~ way.? <::al-gtJe F~I 'in:rpr.ov~. t,railJ!llg
;p,ssig nm!=t)ts'?

0_,

~

_', _ _ ' . _ _

~

em ~hl~ '$llbj~ct fQr fut4r~ ~1.~pI9y..l11ents '<;)t

:\o.corrtm¢nts
~6.

please proVide any a'ddlt!ohal.lhformatI6n concernln-g training for'oversea'!> dt=plqYments,or
.
assig,nments of FBI' personnel you belIeve is relevant.

Infroductiorito Part III: In this seetion~.weare.seeking information regarding a wide rang~ of
interview or interrogation techniques and other types' of detainee treatment all~ged to', have ,Decu ned.

''(gu s(lolllp not_as?ume;; ju~tb~ause W~',!=lre' asking (jbol,l~ a P,l;lrtl~!Jla[ technlgu~'9r p@~iq=, that;we. have,
j;onClqd,~ th,at i~' in f;;l~t o~c)Jrred~ We r~Qgni;z¢ thi3t ,som~ pJ ti:1¢se t~hn iqu~s 'or pra'cj:i(es may at ,tiITH~'s
be nece$Cli)' f6,t safety a'nd, secur.lty' In 'a 'detention setting. In: add Itlpnr wg recognIZe that:some :of th.e'se
.techniqiles0[ practiGes may. have been authorized fanise by military or'other gi)vernmerit personnel.
With

(esp:ect to ,each

ip~l)tjft~ technjquer P-tgQ;i¢e; '6r typ:e"Qf cQndM,dt d'~crjb~ .b'eIQYi, we :ate se~jhg

OIGQ-005312

·inTo.flTla~lon =abqut its occ4r("~nce during or in connection with the interview or interr.ogaj:ion of a

~~taln~er'Qr d~ri'ng the:d~t~n.ti9n '(jf'a 9.etain¢e. beypnd what Is'n.eeded for s-af~tv ani;! se~uri!y;

10' .that $:Ont¢x~; we' will ask you to. .tell us whether one _dr mor.e of tbe fbllPwin!t ,statements .are true:

.

L IjJer'sonaIIY.observed this conduet.
.i~ ~:~bser:ved ~etain~ts) ill a '<:of\dit,ion that· (~ me:to ~eH~.vefl1a~ .~hJ!:i Gondl;let had: 9cq.med.
:3. D~t;lin~(s) tQlt!.:m~·tha~ this co.ndllct nqd :9cclJr(ed.

4. Oth~rs. WhO. b~servep' ~his <o:nQm;:tde's~rLQe:q it.J:O m~ .
.5. I nave relevant information classified above '~S.ECRET"'.
fl. I never .observed this conduct nor heard about it from -someone who did.

·21, Depriving a l;Ietain~e' of fQqd or ~a'ter

a. 0 r personalltobserv~d
b.

q

this -.conduct.

I :bbseIireti defainee'(s). in 'a,cond itibn that led me to. believe thaUtiis cdndutt bad .oc!Curred.

e. D Detai'nee(s) told me .that "this' Gond utt. hao .occu·rrect.
.d; 0 b.thers who observed -this conduct described It to me.
e..
f.

D ! ~.aw~ relevant Infol"\TI~tlon classl.fleq il~ove: I~~ECRET!!'.
D 1, ~~v~r ·ob!:ief\(eq this 'conduct nor heq~q iabo.lJ.t it Jrom. SOfJle9ne who did.

'g. PleasJ;. prqyJd~,t/1e appn;>xlmC;ltl:': ti.rneframe during. whJ~h thl$ cOIl~!1A·'9·ccurred.
.
Fr.drriP6fo2j20Q.2 tp 07f02,/iQ(-)Z
' Dna Not Retail

_h. tfl~-~et~ine:e(.~) tr~~ed in ~his. way were [qc~.ted 'at th,~ time :io.:
0' ·~u.antanamo
20 trqq

:r

3D .Afgha.nlsta'n
d Orher Locatloh
d Do Not Recall

·4
·5

i, PJffis~; IdentifY the detairiee(:>} by.:narne ~rid number:'
Detainee #6!fwas ~OT:deprived aHoad] ·but·for a time. he was kE!!pt In the' brig and only·.g,iven
,meal.~ r~dy ~9 eat (M~~). I;.cJ:o IlQt recqlltbe name .of detainee #69;
'j. Ple-as-e id~ntify' the perS6n(s} 'who treated' ih~J:letCiirie~(.s) in this manrier'~ iriclud.itig tKeit

name(s) and gove'rriment:-agefit'i{ie~): .
.
The above activity· was carrlea out by guard p'ersonnel asslg ned to the brig who,were acting. on
~h9lf qf the FBl.
.

k.. p'leqse Idernlfy 1:lnY~9ther FBI. personnel0r nqno:FBI pers.on'1el w'hq.obseryed' detall1ee{s) ~reqt~d
·in this r:nann-eft including their m~m~($) :a.nd qgency(i~s):
T.I:iEH:ircufustah~es.surfO:ifriarng #69 were known f6;CIAHQ, FBIHQ~. and DoD p.e1:Sohnet. .
I. Thls',conduet .occuri'M In tonne.ctioh .with~
1 0 'One. detain~

2..0
.sev.eral-. detainees .c7~J
..

OIGQ-005313

3.0 Many detclfn¢es '(more than 4)
4.0 Do'Not Recall
'

tn. (Oplipnal)

Please: des'<;rlb_e '.tne' releVant tJ(c\Jnist"ances: in more detail~··

.2&. peprivirrg -a·detainee

of clothifrg

0 I p,ersoncil.\y observed tbis t;onduct.
Qo, 0 ~'op,s~rveq r;l.etairt'ee(?} io..g -cghp itiPn tDClt led m.~ tp b,~Ii~Ve th~t t!Ji~ c9hduct Q?l.d ,p~ggrreQ,
c. 0 Pe.t~l.nee(sj,-tOl.q me that ttll?: C9I'Jd u~"t Ij q d ·oq;urreq.d. 0 Others whQ :ob$erve;o '.this. cbnd uct ct:escdbe~ it tp me.
~. 0 I hav~ rer~.v~mt infqn:natiqn' ~la~sifJed cib'py¢. 'is'ECREJ'I.
~.

fo ~ l' n~V.er 9,b:s.,e'r\l'ed· ttil$ :cQnct L!C,t Iiorh'¢a rd ·e;tb~OlJ~. it from '~mepn~Who: ~.td.

29. D.epriviJig :a. detainee' of sle'(:;p,

or interru pting sleep oy frequent cell feloe,atidns.o(other rrieth6d.s
_ _20..-...... : :

·a.
.b.

D I persomj)ly opse,rv~d th,i!;'cqnduct.
0, r. obs~r:v.ed det,ai.lJee(s) in Q'lcQ.ndition t.h~t

e.~~l:'t

I~ ,me, t9 b~!ieve.th9t-thi~cp.Ilduct· pad 'Qc,cJJrred•.

I

9,- ~. betain~(s} ~~Id )'n~ tr9t :thiS: ~ond.uc:,t h~d 9cwr~t;!C\:
(j. I~r !6iher:s' Wbg 'tlb~rYe,d '~his, «;P'n~uGt d.!-'!s~'ib~d it to:m~.
e~
II h'a'le releVant l'nfonr;c{tio.r d~ssiffed ;;lboVe "SJ;CREril,.

o

f.

0 r= rir='(er 9b$~rv:e~rttlls··c6nd

u~t n9r'h~ (0 'ab'ou~' itfrtffn '~(rre3),ri~Will?' d jel.

,g'. PI~Ci5e: ptoVid~:Jh~ approxImate timefrariie·,durirlg
From 06/02j1boi to 0.7(02/2.002

which this'cotJdutt occurred.
,01:)'0 ,Not ~~G:all

h. Tne d,etajn'~(~) treatea in t~is '!lay. ·w,e;r¢, ib¢a~-eClat tne tim~ in:
1 0' Gua ii.tariarnp
.
g [JJra4.

gO Afghanistan
'4 0 Other Lo~tion
.S0

[l'p

NQt .B.~~II

,~ PI~se. id~n~ifx,the~etaj!l~(s) by !1C!me alld !1umb~~.:

T!l~·'t~c!lJlique:·9f sl~liWdisryp'~i9r:J IiY~S

unknown'to m:l;.

.,

used 011 ?ev.era! getainee5,who~~ n!3m~s' / nurJ1J)~r~ are

OIGQ-005314

,
..

j. Please identify the' per-sones) who treated the detainee(s) in this manner, iriciudinQ their
name(-s) and governmentagency(ies):
DgD personnel~ FI3I{ and, CITF.
k. 'P'lease identifY· any other FBI person'riel or non--FBI personnel who. observed detainee:(s) treated
in this; rnannel',-1.ncJ.udlng tj1~ir name(s) and agercy(ies):
,l)hkndw'n.

l. This:conduet occurre,d in cqnneeti9r1 Y.;lith:
1 '0 One detai.n~

2:9 'Several detainees (2-4),
3,0

Many detainees {more than 4}
4.Q bo. Not Re~1I

rho (:O'ptfonal) Please descrIbe

therelev~lnt circumstances in moredetail:~

'30: 'B-eq~ing: a detC!ir)~
a.
b'.

0
0

e.- [J
d. d,

ooserVed this :cbMuct.
I,obse:rved detarnee(s) in -a ,e:oriCl ition 'that led
I per-so-nal\,!

Detaihee(s}.told

me to, believe that this cdndiJd had occurred..

me that this c6nduet Had .,6ccuri:ed.

,

Others who observed ,this conduct described it to me.

e.

0

I have rele.vant inrerma'tion classified above' !·SECREf

f.

0

I ne.v~ro.b.serve~ this --C<?I).d\-lct oqr'.heard .ab,Ol-!t- it JroJ,T1·~0IJ.le9ne'vi.h9'd,lq.

i,
•

,

'31. ,Us.ing water to prev:~nt ~reathing by a d'etalnee<cr to .cre~te :the s~nsati9n qfdrownl'ng

a.
b
..t.

o l personally· observed, this ;cooCluct.
o i~·,oDserved detalnee(~) lo'a.cpnditl&n that led 'me;to bellleve.thatthls.co:rfduct had oC'clri:-r.ed.
D

!Ddainee(s,)-told.me that this eonCl uct had o,ccurr-ed .

,d. 0' fOtherS who .6bserved .this conduct oescribed it to me;,
J.e. 0 I. have relevant i'nformation classified above !'SECRETIl,.
f.

0'

I never observed this conduct nor heard about it from someone who d'id.

'32:,lJ~ing. hCln~Sr lope, 'Qf 'anyt~ing'els~ foe,hoke or ~trang Ie a'ge~C!ine~
.'

OIGQ-005315

f.

. ,

,

"

a. D
b. D
c. D
d. D
e. D

.-

I

I personally,observed thls..conduct.
I'observed detainee(s) in a'condition that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.

iD~tainee(s) to!d l1le t~at this cqndyet ~ad 'qcc::l,Jrre9~
bth~~ Who 'ol1~r:ved 't/:lis condu.ct' 9es.C::Jibed It tl;> me:

I hav.e reievarit information

=1

dasslfie~ ,alJove, "S!=CRET":,

rn~v!=r·9.bserv.ed this.ct)nch.lct nor heard·ab.ou~ it (rom;someqn~Who 9id.

0

'33. Th J:eat~n Ing other a.cUon to cause. phy?lea I pa In r Injury,.d Isflgurement,. or' death

1::,;

D t personally .0 bserved' this conduct.
0 Lobserved detalnee(s) In 'a (;:ond Ition that led me to belle.ve that thiS lZonduct had ,occurred.
D. iDet~inee(sj,tqk~ me tJ:tqt this, ~onduc::t hpd '<;iccorred.

cL

o iO~lJer:p whp. ·o!J$er..v~C! t,hfs ~o;nd,Uft q:<?~C?f.i1:1~ i~ ,t\;>, f1le.;

·a.
b,

0 I hGlV!=J~I~V,cHit flJf~rma~19,!1 flcr~sJfl.eg ;?b9Ve "'~·ECREt'!.
'f, ~ (I n~ve( o/l~erv~q thjs'c;onduGt nor !lear~ '~bo_tit it from ?()lJl!=~tl~Wl1o ,Qid.

eo'

34. Qth:enr~aptjent

gr a~tiott:~u~iog siiln,ffe;:,nt phYEitca! 'pi;lfn Qr'lhj~ry nqti:qusing t1isfig li(~men.t' Qi"

;t1eath .
9~

0 I: personar.lY··o'bs~lVed

tDI~ ton<!4,ct.

11. D I obseryed detainee,(s) in ,a:wnd ition t,hat I~ me t'9' believe th8t, thfs ,condutt ~ad qCGurred.,

c,

DjDe~aJ n~(?) tOJ9. tn~ bn~t {{lis' c,9n4 Uj:t h~-d -oq;:u ~~~ ,
d. D Iqt~~11> Wbo Qb?erv~'9thls Cb.ndlJ.ct des~rlbed It to, me.
~.

0 r have re,leyant information 1;:lasslfi~d cj b9ye '\SECREf";

f: 0. It n~V¢r o.bs'¢r'.(ed tl'iis,q;;Jid u~t mj(h~td :fl'bpJ,1!, it froin 'sorriepne, Who, ~l.id,

35. Plating a d,etalnee on a' hot 'silnace or burning;q d~tainee:

D ~,p'E!.r~,,~.t.Iy ob~ry<?d, th,is s<?ri:!uct.
b: D I;'ol?seryed qe~ln~~(s)' 1I1·a.-c9IJd Itl9IT ~h9t Ie<:! ,me .~o· bel.leve,th~t,thls con.duq had :occurred~
'~, D. ,Det?line~(s) tqlc,l rn.e t/1<;lt thfs C909uc,t had -qc,CJ.lr.~,eq.
d" D ptper$ who O!:l§erveq 'tf,tis tondu.c::t des~ribe9 it t9 me:
a'.'

...

..... -_.- .

._--

- .- ..

_.

~-

--

-- - --

~-.

-

--.~

......

...

..

.

..

"

-

...

OIGQ-005316

,.
..
'r'"
.
r have relevant Information classified above '(SECRET".
'

e.

0

f:

0, I

,

,

,

never observed this:conduct nor heard aboutit from' someone who'did.

3,6.,l.,Jsing shac;:kles or other re~traini:sil1 a prqlpD9~d mal1ner
a.
b~,

c.

0
0

I persdnally ob~rVed" this ,~on(/uct.
I ooserved detciinee(s). in 'a·cond ition that led

me to believe thantiis t6nduGt had o.cc'urred.

.

o 'Defainee(s) told me that this cond'uCt had o.ccurred.

d. l~f others-Who observed thisp,mdilct.des{;ribed it to me.

0 I have relevant information classified above: '\SECRET'''.
t- O I ne.ver-observed thls.conduct nOf'heard 'about It fium'someonewho did.

e.

P!~~,se p.roy!~e 't,b~ ap'pr:-~xi!:DC!t~ trm~ "frame '9 ur[ng, whiG!l
,rrQm '06/Q2!2P02, ,to Q7/02/:J..002

,-9...

't'l. The peta,.Ine;,(~'(?") trE3at~ In "~hi~ way. wer:e lO~9ted
1 ~. :Guantanamo'
.'"
, .
,.
~.

'

thIs: ~QTlj:lU<ft~ o~(Sl,lrrecf!
'oD'o Not Recall

9t t~e time In:

~,

i. 0 Iraq
3. 0 Afgl'i.anis~n
,lI- D 'Other LoCation

sO

D.o'NotRecal!

I. Pleas.~.Identl1Y'th~·;detalnee(s.)

E!y name and

nl!mb~:

I do not recall.names:6rnambers.'
j; Please ~d~ntify' .tire: person($) who tre.ate~ th~, detainee(s) fn 'this J;T1Clnner, irwlud ing t!;reir
nalTie(:~)'.ar)'d g~iVe.rrim~rit agency(i¢~}:
.
DoD, FBI" and CITF.

k. P'ieas.e identify' i'l.!:fy.o,ther FBI p'ersqnnel qf n'Q'ti:'FBI p.ers~onh·eJ ·who. 9b.~rVed det~i,ne~:(s) treated
in this, mani1er1." inCliJding their name(s) ,anti· E!~endy(ies):

.uhkrrow/l.
L Thls'C0nductd<::curred in .c-onnection w'ith:.
-O!l~'d~t~i~~~"

i'o

.'

. .. ' .'

2 Q i-S~e?erall;let9inees (24)
3 0. Many deta'ihee.s· tmot~. th.an
21: O'DQ No.t RealI!

4)

tn. ~'.Q'piIQna'I) .'p(eas~ describs;l ~hia 'rel~yant dr.cumsta'h:c~S' Ihm~re>,d~tan:

OIGQ-005317

'~7.,Requl~lng:a detalnee'tq m~ln.r<;liill pr re,stralning
a.

a 'detainee inl a stressful or pCllnlul position

o ~r. persOnally observed this :corlautt.

0 Lbbs,erved detalnee(s} In a,cbnd ition that led .me to b.elleve that this. co.ndu,ct had occlirred.
c- D m~tainee(s) told me that this conduct had ,occurred.
.--_._·_--.
d. 0 o.thers' who observed this conduct described it to me:
e. 0 I have relevant I'nformation classified above !!SECRET'l.
f. 0
never observed thls:condilct nqr heard ,ab,ol,lt it fror.n someoneVl(no did.
b.

--'~---'-----'--

'g. Please' prqvide: the ?IPprpxTmat'e ~ime Jr~me 'guring, whfGh thi~c(j'nducto~q,.Irr~d.
Fr:-qm 06]07/2,QO}.: Xo 07/02.{2002'
,tt" The 'd,e~a.inee(~) treaJed' in 'try!S W?-.Y were, lqcatep :a,h~e Ume In:
1 0' Gu~ntaJ'1amo

'DDc> Not Re'C>ci1i .

i D,IT<;ltj

3D A-fgha,nistcfn
4 0 Other Location
5 0 Do Not Recall
j; Please'identify' the: defaitiee(s)

bY name and

I, do net recall-the naines or numbers.

,j. 'PJepse: Ide,nUfY the' PersQn (-51 'WhQ tr~.ated'
li~u'n~t.s),ahd government agencY(ies.),~

D6D I F.BI~

aM CITE

'

num ber:'

the d~hilli~e(~)

in th i~

maoner:7

iDeluding th¢ir

"

ide;litify'any other FBI pe'rSbril1e', or nd,n-FBJ p.etso,nnei Who obser.Ve'd
in this, manner" including their riElI:ne(s) and 89.ehcy!ies): '
. Vn~noVVD
k. Please'

d.etai'ri~efs) tre;:itep
' '.

I., Thls;conduct pccurred i!l'coJln~cti9nWith:
o[j~ det~lne~

,1 0

2 'OS~Veral tle.t:ainees: (;2-4)

~,0 MallY, d,eta,inees Crp:ore than 4J

>

40 DQ'Not Recall
tn. (optional) piease dl$crlb.e,the rele.vant cir.curnstahc:;es' in more;:tJ~tai'I:'

~3'8. F.ordng a detainee 10 perform ,demand lng physkal exercise

~l 0.11' pet;;analJy ob~ryed this mnpuJ:;t.

l,

OIGQ-005318

- -

D I observed detalnee(s) In a ,condItlon that led me to believe that this conduct had -occurred.
c: D Detainee(s) told me that thiS' concl uct had occu rred.
d. D q~hers-who observed this con.dlJct-d~criqed it t~ m~.
¢. D L h~WE? relevant InforflJCltion l:la.?sifi.ed C\bove liS Ec:RET" ,
f. 0 t n~v.er;obs.erve~ this.cpnquct nor hear~ 'abqut it frpl11 ~mebne. who did.
b.

-a.

D' r persOnally o.bserved this Gonctlkt.

b.

I:!
D.

Lobserved·detainee(s).ln a"coRdition that led me to believetliat this conduct had;occurred.

c;
Detainee(s-) told me that this cond uct hadaccu rred.
cf, 0 O\hers' who ()bsery~c! t.Ois ~0n~uet:~'e:?cribed it t9 me;
E:!:

r:

D I. h~y:~ releva:nt rntorlJl:(3~[on c!as?if!~_9 ,~1;l0Y~. '·~s.~Cl3-sr"'.
@ I, n~w:'!r ,o.b.s.erveJi ~hl:S 'CQrl1 uft J!9,f _~~'f~ ·a.b.(?Y,~ It from SRITl~one

who- cild.

,-40. Thr¢atening to 'us·e,ele:ctritals./iqck'Oll a ,delain¢e

a.

0 r personally obseruea tnis _conduct.

.b.

I:! I .obserVed 'detaiilee{s): in .a·cofldition that led me'to believe that-this conduct had 0ccurred.

i--

c,

0

Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had :occurred.

d.

Others who observed this mnduct-described it to. me.

e.

D
D

f.

ItJ t ne\(erobserved this.conduct norch~rd'ab.out it from,someorJEil'lJ,/ho <;!id.

II. haMe relev,ant; inforr:natfon c1assifteq i;j b9ve: "S:EC~ET'''''

-41..- ,Intentionally dela.yir:fg 'or~de:nyhig :detaine¢ medical.care

a. D L personally ob,served this (fon'duct.
IL-obser:v.ed detafnee(s) ir'1:a,c6ndition tnat led me

I€"

D
D

d.

d

bthers who observed ,this conduct descrihed it to me.

b~

to, believe thatthis conduct

had occurred:

Detainee(s}'fora me theft this cbhdott had ,occurr,ea.

e. D r have relevant rnr,ormation dassr~i~ 'q!Jov~ I\S~GRET"·.
f. 0 t lJev:er'o,b.s~Jved· ~hi? 'c~nduct nQr heq,rQ apput it rrqm SOlJ1eo.ne Who t!!Q,

OIGQ-005319

4.~.

Hb.bdiilg or blindf.olding .a :detai nee 'other than during transportation:

a.,

0 I pefS(Jnally ob~rv~~

b.

o lI:obs~(ved de!qin'e~ts) !(I.i:l'q>ndition tf1at Ie<! me to' b~fiey~ tha.t: this C9I1d!J<;t p<;ld 'oGcurre~i..

c.

D

'0;

this .cqnd·uct.

D~.talnee(sj tol~ J:11¢ that this. conduct ha~(Q'(:t(Jrr~L

o lothers who observ.~ 't.hl~ t;:pm:,l1-lGt deScribed It t9: m~;.

e. 0 r' ha\le re!evci'rit infor'niatioo' clas1iified aboVe, liSECREfIl •
f. 0 I n~yer 9b~erv.e~' tljis condup.t nprh~r~ab9~,t it fr~m ,solT!et>.n~ whO' ~Jd.

4S. 'Subjectibg a ,d.etairiee to 'extremely· cold .or hOt room tern peratLi res for extended per.iods

a. D r, pe~?On,qlJy-'~;b~rv~d

~hts:conduc~.

LO,l;Js~r:v~d TJ~ti?in¢er.~). i~ cH;:gndit,igrrt;har I,e.d TJ'le ~9 beH~YJ; th?t this C0n.duc~ !lad 'Qc;.cufr~q.

~:.

0

<;;

o ;De!ajnee(s} t9J~ :h1~ tha,t ~his: t.<meJ).Jc.t- had 'Q,~cur:r;~ ..

9:. 0' IQthers W,hg Qb~eryl;d thi~ C?QlidJlt;tq<~s-c.rib~C1
Ie: D
f, 0

it'tQ:m~.

~> h?!.ve reTe'Vclnt, ilJfbrr(l~~jon J:lasslfied 9~'dye "$'E¢BE'T'''.
I ri~ver'o15.seNe'd th)s-:conduct n.Qr h¢a'rd ~abpJ.Jt

It from SQrTreone wnQ tJJd.

I

~:. piease proVld~ th'e a'ppn;ixlmate lJr)i'e fr;;tme darIng Which this, conduct occurred,
From :0.6jD2j1.'OO2' to; 01/0'1:/20020 D~ N.0~. 8-~c::all
h. Th'e d.etainee<,~) tr.eated in this way were. Idcatecl :at the trme in:
10' GLJailtanamh'
2: 0 .Ir'a'q
3D Afghanistan,
4 0 D,ttie'r Lo-ca,tion
q q Dp N9t 'R~~II

f.

Plea~e fc;lentify' the:de~ain~(s) by

I:'~O not r~ptl name~ 'qr- m~mp~rs.

narne ana

I1wnb~r;'

-j. .P-leasejdent,ify'ttie p~rsOn(s).Whp,treated the t1.etaiMe(s) in
name( s)',and governm'ent:ageTIC:y!ies):
",
09d." FBI, and ,crr~.

this'manner, irjcluOih'g therr

OIGQ-005320

k. Please ideritify any other FBI personnel 01' non-FBI personnel·who.observed detainee(s) treated
in-this mannerr incluaing their riame(s) and agency(ies):
Unk.D9wn

I. TblSCQndLiQ: .Q!=c,urred in ~Qnh.ectiQn WitH:
1:0 'One. detalhee
2, 0 '.Several detainees. (2-4)
!3

a mal1y-:detalne'~ (nibre·tha.n4),

.40
rn.

Do NQt Recall

(.O~tional) Please describe the:relevaht circurnsta.rrces in

;44. Su'pj'ecting a detainee to loud

..a' o It p~r$jjiaHy,dD~rved

music

this :Conduct,

lJ. 0 r Qi>serr;~ed det~fli~~{S), ili :<3, tond itfOrj tllat jed

c: 0

ril.ore :d.etail:

me. to lieri~Ve thanhis t6ni!li cdia.d 'd¢9U tred.

D~~t:aine'e(s) told ftie ifiat this: condu,tt' hifd ,ocCUrrEd,.
Others: who ,ob.sef:Y.ed this c6i:1d.Lict described it to, me.

e.

0
D

f.

0

I never observed thls..C0ndud nor'heard laooulli frorn s6meohewho did.

.d.

L haVe releyai1t information Glassiffed a.b,ove, ':SECRET" ,

,45. ,SlJ't)jecting a;detainee t<;> brightflashing Iig~ts or darkness

0 t pet.soliaHYQb~erVed thIS ,condu.ct.
0:. 0 I 9b:se,IV~d detallie¢Cs). in a 'CqnO itiqn ~hat led me to b~liei/e that this c9t:i:qu~t f'ia:d :occ;iJrr~d.
G', o IDetainee(s) told 'rl:ie tHat thiS' et>nduct h;;\d .oc,corretl.
d. 0' Others who bbServed this tciriduet d.escribed it to me.
e. 0 I have .relev~mt Iti'f6l'TJ::lcition Classified ,aboVe, '~SECRET",
f. 0' II never-observed this cenduct hor::heard ·abOlitit from.sOmeone Whed'id.
a.

'46. loolating a detainee :for an' extended period
.. -

"

(~r.

0' t' pe:r50nally.:9b'~rved tbls cQI1~u.ct.

0 iQb:serVedd.e.taiiiee('s)' in p 'condition' that lea me, to' belleye .that, this: conduct had 'occu rred:
c, D' iO'etairiee(s) toid me tti;;it this i;:ondut:t hadoccllfr.~.
. _.
...
..
..
,-- .
- ..
-- .. - It

'.

~

-,

-'

'

'

,

'

,"

OIGQ-005321

,

,

,

0 Others who observed this conduct described It to me.
,e, 0 I hav:e relevant information classified above "SECRET".
f, 0 .. !1~ver observ~d th{~'O?odl,lC;~ nor heard ~bqut It from 59me0n~:Wh9 ~i4·
d,

;

g,_ meaS:e prQviQ.e .the iOIPprpx1fT.Iate; tim,e;fT<;I'l1le.du.ring WhiGh this C:;QnduGt"Qcc,urreci.
FrQm 00/02/2002 ,t9 07/02/2002
"OD'o Not. Recall

Ii, 1n~ de.tp'i):lfi~eCs) ~remed.".in "thr~ w£y were.lg~a~~~t i:~ tlm.e: In"
10 GuanJanpm9

20rra•
.3. 0 Afgflanistan
4 0 other LOcation
5 [j Do Not Recall

i. Please idci1tify'the:.detainee(s) b.Y naine ~frid humber:
Detainee #69, Name.J..mrecalled.
j. Pl.~s~ i~~nti1y: the:. person{s) 'wh9 i:re.a.led

hame(:s)· ahd 9<ive.rhment.ag'enty(ie,s)::

'fBI,

,

til!,!; ~~1ain~.e.(~) in this. manll=t, lncludln"g th~lr

'

:k.. P"h~ase'iden1ffy'any"othe'r" fBI

p"ersOririel or nbn-FBI,p~rsohnel who
in this manner:~ hicludiilg' tneir' nam¢(s) and "a.Qencv.(ie·s):
OJ::l[}, FB.I,1'!nd ¢rrf.

observed det:l.iiiee(s) treatee:t'

> .

l;'~his,condod:octofred" in ~ni'(ectrd!T W~lJ~
:f:~ ,0n~.~etAinee
20 ,s¢v.elaf de,~inee~ .(2-4)

's.'O
4

b

M'a'hY detainees {r:ri6rethan 4}
Da:Not Recall

m. (OJltIOj1cij~ ,Ple.as¢ d~ri.be: the,releyant cir,cllmstam:;es,.ln m'6r'~ de.tall:
4/.• Using ,duct ~pe to rf;'S~rclJtl: gag! :or pu nlsh a detcl'lijee

ct., 0 I p1::;rsol1aliy Q~*lved this cOn#li~.
& 0 t9b:served detalne~.(~) III a c~ndltioli th~~ l~"rri~ wbelleve th<t~.th's 4O!id,uct i-ia:d O·!=Q.!rreif..

,-

t, 0

'Detainee(s:) told tile tliat this tcindutt' had :deeurr6.l.

0
'.e. 0

oth,ets who bbse[V¢d this tPnduct, d~crj~ it 16 me.

d,

f,

Itl

I have reJe1ant In"f6ithation classified aboVe '~SECRET'~.
I never obserVed thls.coMuet nor ,heard 'abOOt It frOm,someone'wHo did.

OIGQ-005322

48: Using rapfd response teams .and/or forced cell eXtractions

a:

o !I per~nally observe" tnis :cqnd·uct.

b. 0
c, 0

Iob~rv~d, detqin'eets) iwa-c9hd jtjon that

led me to beljeve tliqt thi~ cond,~Q:

h.ad ,Q'cc;urrej:I.,

pe~ajne'E)(sJ tolq m!= that this Gondu!=t hap ,occurred ..

0 Others who bbsery~,d this ~pnquc;t d~'ScriQ~ It ~o', me:.
e. 0 I have relevant lliformatioii t1as'sifie,d -aboVe, "SECRET".
r- lID I n~e~er ~b~:¢rve'~' this, cO,nd uet r'lpr h~rq '8 b04,t itJnjm' sotr:\epne/Wh9' ~Ud.

cJ"

4,9. ,using -a,military working (jog ,oil ,or nea'!, i3detafoee,,6ther than during detainee,tr:a'nspoitation

0 t p~~~\!'!C!lJy 0l?se~eQ this ·condu~t.
b\ 0 t;9!Jse~~d det;~iin~~(~} in a:eond'iti.9.r1' tniiit·I,e9 rn~ ~o' ~~neye thgt'thi? corrqul;'t !lad 'Q6C.LJrret!,
Cj' D. IOe(a,inet;(s) tol~ 'm~ ~hat tbl?, t.c;indv,c.t hq:,~ :oc::c;urr;~,
~L o !Others- W,hp. Qbsery~9 t.his q:m<;l,Ust d:est.db~(f it t~ rn~..
e' 0 1 h~;\!~ rele'Vi:mi: il)(of{1)~tion:~lassified <;l~'o\re '~~3.ECJ~ETri,.
f. ® r: ri~V.¢t'Qj):?er\!ed this,;cQoduct nor b¢a'r'd ',abo-uJ It frQ'in SCim:eorie Whq d'iq.

a:

"

50'. ThreatenIng .to use ,mlllta!t ,working dP9_s,-,o..;.b,..;.o_'r"_n..;.e_a_r..;.<l_o_E!_ta_"n,..;.:e_e_:

a",

b;
,c:
(I.

e'.

f.

_

o 11; p~rS(')nal!y'oQ~rve,d ~hisc;qnd~<;:t.
o lto6s~rved detC)ft}e'e{s} In a"corll:lltlc;>n'thGlt ied l:l1e'tO' befleve that this conduct had occurred~,
q

;peJ~i.neeM tc>.Id me tflat th'jS' conduct had oq:urre9'

"

o lqtrel'$, whp observeR ,tl:).i~ ~on,a!1ct-d,es~riQed [~ ~Q'me:·
o jr ha~'e relevan.t I'lJfbrrnation ylClssifl,bd 'above '~$.EtRET'!,
o Ii n~'.{er d,b~enied' this 'CQrj~uct opt' h!=ClrlpbQU~ i't frorn.'sQrrjebne whet dla.

51. Usin'!'j

~l 0

spfders~

'storEiQns, ;s'nakes, or either cfnirrials:bh or hear a Betafnee.

!I personally observed this conduct.

OIGQ-005323

..

,

..

0

1 observed detalnee(s) In a .condltlon that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.

c.

o IDetainee(s)-told me that this conduct had :occurred.

d.

o

'Others w~9 observed thi~ cOl1duct·descriqed it to m~.

e..

0

[ have re~varit Information c1assifie.ct abov~ "SECRET".

b.

f: 0 I

n~.er'ob~rve.~ thfs'C9ndu~t nQr .hearp·abqut it from someone. who did.

, $2. Tht¢at~njn~
a.

0

to

lise s~iders, scorpions, 'Snakes,. Qr bth¢r anImals' on a detaine¢,

I persOnally observed this,condu-ct.

b, q Lobserved detainee(slln a'coAd ition that led me to' believe that this 'conduct had ;occurred.
c. 0 Detainee(s.) told me tflatthis conduct hadoccurr:ed.

tL 0

b~bers who -observed this c€ln4uctde~cribed it to

me.

0 I: n.9Y~ rel~vaJ1t-lnl'ormat!qn cla~~ifI~g ~~ov~. ·'sgC$'''.
t 0 I n~v~r'q.bs.erve:d tj1($ cpflquct nqr',hear,<i 'aQCl!.~,lt 'trom;~m~ql')~.who·

~.

d[d.

, 53, Di~respectful statements, handling, cit':aqicins m,Volvirig' the koran

0 r personally' eb.served tnis .conduct.
b~ 0 r. observed deh'linee'(s) in a':,c::dhd'ition tnat lea me fo Deneve that ·this conduct had :occurred.
c, 0 Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had :occurred.

a'.

e.

o \Oihers who observed this mnduct'described it to me:
o II have.relevant fnformati.on c1pssified above' !ISEC~ETJ\

f.

0

a.
b:

o II personally 6bs!3rved this eQndutt.
o !I :ob'served t1etai'nee(s). in a'cona ition tHat led me' to, belieVe that- this conduct haa ~ecutred.

C.

0

Detainee.(s)'t61d me lha1: this 'c0n<fuct had.occ'urr.«I..

d.,

d

Others who observed this c::onductd'escrihed It to me.

t;,

o II. ~a.v,e. relevalit fnfor~,?ti~m.dasS!i~i~ Clbove llSEGREF".

d.

I never p~bse~ecJ thls,conduct m)r h~rd .~,b.Ql,If~ it 'froJTI,someol1e.'w~oqid.

f. 0 r !J~y'er o,p.s~r'iled

thi~ 'C9ndl,J~t nQr neqrd qboul,it from 5()meO,ne "Yho
.,
-

diq.

,~

OIGQ-Q05324

55..PlaCing a womat\'s'c!othing on a-·detaine,e
a.

0

1 personally observed this .conduct.

b.

0-

r :observed de!Clfnee(s) ilJ a'cond it.iorrtt}8,t

lee! .me to beH~Y~ tha.t thi.s colJduc;t ~Qd ·OGcutred•.

c. 0 De.taine~(s) tolQ m¢ that this cond u~t ha9 ,o·cc(Jrr~.
d. o Qthers' who bbseryed :t.hl~ qmdijct described It to' m.e~.
e. D. Iii?\le r'elev~rit inf6rmatloh' da"ssffied .above. "SECRET" •
f, 0" tn~~et Qb)3~'rV~~ntit~.Cbnduct npr'h~(d ·ab9l).t it th5m .sdmepne.whQ' d)d.

It'

56. Touching a .detainee or acting 'tbw~'rp a det3ioeein::a seXualina!ilier

D t p~~~lJC!l.ly: ~b~rved ,~* :c6ndUct.
~h 0 I ,oQseJ:\fe~ d,eti=ilne~(:s) in 'o'egnd it;jp:rrth?lP I~Q. lTJe to' Q~lieve th~t:thi~ C~J:rguc:t had ·qqturr~~.
·c.. D (jetp.in~(s)tQlg me th~t tljis. tPi1du.~t, QqO !Qc;;currea,
4,. 0 19thers W.h'p -qbser'y.e.d thi~ GPt)du~t,Q.es¢rih~d itt~.m,¢ ..
e. 0 t h~~e rele'Vi3nt iUform~tioJi J:lasslfi~d ~I;)'(jye '~S.E~J?):r·\
f. 0 r riev~r-QDsehie'd this.,conchict nQr heard;a Db_ut It 'from ·s0rTreOOe WhQ. did.
,a.~

<

,

57. Hold I~g detalnee(s) wtto Were no.t offiClaIlY',ackf1oWledged or reg)stered as ~u~h
;~etaj'ning the· perSon.;
9·

bttti~:-dgericy

P 'r per,sonal iY'ot>s.erv~,~, thi's :cQm;lud.

b', 0 I'o,bserv¢d detain~~(s} in a;cpndftiQn that.l~ m~ to b,eliev~ thClt .this. condud
¢: D. oet~iriee{~),tQjd me that th'is:¢~riductI]i'iqoccurr:@..
d. '0 dt,h¢rs ~ho PQs.e·r;v~d :thi~ Gdr{d.[Jt.t. d~s:crlb~e~ It ~o,me:

had oc!;;urred.

e. o ~'have reie:V:atit iliformation' das'sified aboVe, ".SECREf'i.

,.

Iil·

r nev:er-o:Bs-erved thi.s:'C9JiaU·¢,t nQr' tieard 'abtju,t it 'trom som~on.~ whO'diQ.

58., Send lng' a detair'lee IS another

£ou ntry for more 'a.gg ressive Interrogation

OIGQ-005325

,

0 I personally observed thls,conduct.
b. 0 I observed detainee(s) in a condition that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.
c. 0 D~~ainee(s) told me t!'lat this condl)ct had 'occurred.

a~

:d.

q

bth~rs Who 'ob'~rv~d this c,ondiJct d:es~ribed it to me;

0 I hav,e relevant jnto,r(natiQD classified above "SEC,RET".
._-t: 0 r n~ver ob..,?erved this ~t~n9u,~t no( heprd abol!t it from.,~rrieQrTew.hQ. dip.

'e.

5,9. Threatening to ~end d d,etalnee .to aMthen:oUntry for detentloh ormore dg:gressJV~,lnterro.gatlon

~ L perSonally observed

a.

this conduet.

0 I'observed'detcllnee(s) In 'Q£ondltlon that led me. to belleye that this G:onduct hail occurred.
e.. D jDetClinee(s) tqld m~ that this ~olJduc.t had occurred~
'q~ 0, Othet:? Wh,9 \i/J~e[v~d thiS co,nd,l,l~t d~~C;:fib~ iUo me;,
e. 0 ' h\3ve re.l~va:rit 11J~<?rma~19.ns:l~rs~)fi~ ,~b<?v~ ".~ECW::r!J ..
't. 0 I neVerQ):l:;ervec! this'c;ond~Gt nor hecar~,ab9,u~ it frorn~~(jm~~:n¢'who djd.
b..

"q;.

pl¢a~e: p,rovid~ the ~pprQ){ll:n.at¢tJrne fr'aml:!.,durlhg

whidi thl,s.q)ndu~t

QE?i02/20:02: to 07j02/2002
:b, The 'qeta,in!=:~(s) tre.clted. in ·ttli's w.aY yVerf! J6cat~ 'pt ~h¢ ~,irh¢ 'ItT:
f 0 'G.ucintan!=!md
,From

QCc;urred.
OD-o Not Re~1I

2DIIClq
3 0 )~.fghcfnls,tal'1
,4- 0 ;other Location
Do'N<;>t Req31J
5

b

i., ,P.lease.'identify' tbesdetaitJee(s)

by nanie and' number:

Q'et~il'lee';*,6~"

~'j. Please ide'ntifY tli~ per?o,ri(s) who·,tf"ei:lted the d~taine~(~) in ~his, iiial)ne~r· int;/udIng th.eir
iia~:e(s) arid :~o.v.ernment agency(les}::

DoD 'and FB-I.

.

,Please, identif.y any'other FBI personnel or non-fBI ·p.ersonriel Who,ob'served a,etalnee(?,) treated
in :thls: manner, including their name(s) andagency(ies);
None

1(,

L Thls,contfuct 'occklrr.ed in (:~nn.ec.t:l~rr with:-

1.0 ·One, det~ln'e:e
2 Q 'sever,a', d~tairi~ {Z~j
0 Marry detainees {rrior.e tlian 21:)

3

,

,

OIGQ-005326

4 0 Do Not R~,<:;all
Ill. (.Optlqnan ,Please descrlb'e,the relevant drcumsta{lces in more de~ail:'

r was at one meetfng where this technique was' specifically discussed concerning detainee ,#69.
'and C?ther qetaineeswnpse, ni='lI:ne~ I J:jumber5 r do not recq!t.
,6-0. Threatening to take

action·.ag~a~ln.;.:s..:.t..:.:a...;d.:..:;e;.:.ta.:..:;i.:;:.ne~e=-'s;:...:.;;fa.:.:..m..:.:iJ.IY.'~'~

_

a. 0-

r pet:sqnally pbse;rved this,conduct,

Do, 0

r' 9b:s~:rv.ed .detaine¢(sJ il) i~fcbhP iti9n'tl\at led nie t,o b'elleVe that tMiS tbJip,l,Icj: h!3'q ,occl,Irr¢d.

0 Q,e.t?lin¢e('s)'tQlp me .that ,thJ.~ P:9r1dl,ltt. DaC! 'ocQ,lrrep ..
dJ D Oth.e·r-s: wi:io 'observed :this conduCt descf,(bed itt6.' me"
~,
0 L' ha\te rEiievaJit inform'ation tlas.sified 'a15QV~, "SECREr"
f. 0 I.neVer.o.bservet! thls,cO,Mutt nor heart! aQoutlt.fI'o'm.sOmeone'WJ16 did.
¢.

0

61. 'O'ther treatment or action'causing 'sever.e emotional or 'psychologiCcll trauma to a detainee

a. 0,

r gi;rsonaHy ob~f\le~ tf:\ls tondoct.

rQ.p$~XV~g d~tain:e~(s)' it\a'¢gjl{UtiPI1 tha~ (~9 llJ~.i9 R.eliey'~ .tnC:)tthls ¢QJ)9.LIC~ Q9:cJ O~~IHTeQ,
i'ii'tHhat tlifs, ~QrjdlJct, h~d oq:urred.
d. 0 jOt,hers' )f{tl'O ptrservr=:d .thi~ ~on.d \Jet pe~c.dbe~ it W me.
e; D I have relevant information t1as,sified 'abo.ve. "SE.CRET
f. ~ I neVer observed thj!LdohdUct nor' hea rd aboiJt it from -someone who~ did.

p. D.
C. D

b-etajne.e(s'): told

ft

',

',&2~ Other"religimis;o.r sexual'~hafassmerit or hu-miliatiolt.of a detainee

0
b; 0
It: 0
a. 0
e. 0
f. 0
a;

~

I. perponallY:q,b?~,rve9 th!?,c_O.nq,uCJ;,

:
,

.

II obsef'ied.det~inee(s» In'~ :tbnd itipn tl:i~t led me to oeJie'Ve th~t..thiS: conduct had ,occurred.
b.etalnee{s.) told me ,theit this, t:ond uct had 'oec'urt:ecL
Othe
bbseh/ed
it .to me,
. rs:,.Who.,'
,,,. '. thl's..' .'t.bIiduct
"
.tfes'tr'ibeo
.'

I have. relevant inJormatiqh t;las.sified 'a~bv~ "S.ECREr'·,
r never QDs¢rvetl thisicoiiCluGt,rioJ heard .abol!t: it from sQrrieQ'ne whO d,id.

OIGQ-005327

'l~:?. Qther tr~atflJent of a: ~~,taine~ that iii YQJH' bpinio.ri \ova's: urlprpf¢s$iqh9I, ,un'ouly

'coercive, abusive, or unlawful

harsh ·01' ,agg r¢ssive r

'

0 I personally observed this:conduct.
I?. 0 tobserv.ed deta~I1~~(5) ill a'cc;mdition-that 1e,4 ~e to beli~v~ th9t ~hjs cond,uct
<;. 0 Delail1¢e{s) told rn~ tnqt tnjs: cgnd.uct had :9.cclJrre<;l~
~. 0 Others Wh~ ob'$ery~ this ~Qn~4c;t (I,escrl,bed I~ to me.,
e. 0 I hi;ive rele.vant i,Dformation d~~sifiedC!l?oVe' 1~~SEcRErJl,.
f: 0' r neY~r O:QM!r'V,ed this tQn.du~t n6r ~,eprd 'a'~Ql!t it frqm $OrTl$one·Whg ~id.

a.

~ad UCCl;lrred.
,

.

.:

~rWf_'(jI1~~'
:~.,~~:.!,,-~I~::<·t:,,~:,,:,:::,yq-~,f"":' :'-11
':64. Did you cibserYe'an'y imper$onatibn of FBl persoll'r)'elbV:piiy6ne dl1l'ing ~ti jntervieWbr'interrogation ofic3,.detaTnee?
'
'
dYes
'0 No
,~65. Did any' detainee: O'r other p.e'r'$dri tell1'ou 'that he- or she had WitO'es$ed the impersonation .of FB~
jJeis~m'hel 'lil connection, with.a (Je'tainee interilie-w
interrog,atior1? '

or

.
66.

O~

,~~

Are. Y,pu ~!Nar~ of'arw, "s h?I1l",<?r "s.taged" '~etai!1~ in:t~ruiews. gr interroga~ion~ 'cond\.lcted 'fpr Mem I;>ers
of-the.U.S. Congress qnt)~ir staff?'
'0 y~s, ,(!) No

;67. 'Tp'your kn9Wledg~t,(fid, any' military 'PJ inlellIgenc:e·per~9'nnel '~V:er .d~ny or ·~~Iqy' Ftil i=l<;ces~ tQ~9

detainee the FBI wanted to question- Qecauselhed~tijine~,had .sustci'ii1€d injuries ~f!;er he was ,Q~ipljJre~:I? ,
.
:o.Y~s
$1\10

.6~'. Did. 'you €'{~r .end Y04r partiCipation'

in Of observ~ti0nofa-de1~:tnee,irterview or tnterrogatjon

b:etauS:e pf the· intervi¢w or int.err.ogatio,n m~tttbds·l:(eing U5e9.?'

o

Yes 0 No
,ft,Q~ Were, yOJ,J eve-nord ,that an'qtherFB.I,.eMpldyee.,ende.d his'PT 'her parti(:ipation in .or' obs,erV~tiQ,n ofr.a'
d'etalnee Interv.lew.br interrogation because of the InteNleW,br'lnterrogation methods ~Ing used?'

Q Y.es

'0 No,

.OIGQ-005328

any detainee interview or interrogation practices, or other types of detainee treatment, to an FBI
supervisor?
0ves 0 No
7oa. When and to whom dId you make this report?
Military liaison Unit, F8IHQ
70b. Did the report relate to mnduct by FBI or non-FBI personnel?
1 0 FBI Personnel
2 ONon-FBI Personnel
70c. Was this report in writing?
10'Ves
ZDNo
70d. Was any actfon taken In response to your report?
1 Dyes
2DNo

3 0Do Not Know'
71. During any of your overseas deployments or assignments, did yon report any conce~ regarding any

detainee interview or interrogation practices or other types of detainee treatment yon observed or heard
about, to a non-FBI supervisor or other non-FBI personnel?
Ves
0 No
71a. When and to whom did you make this report?
CITF and DoD Attorneys
71b. Did the report relate to conduct by FBI or non-FBI personnel?
1 Ii:J FBI Personnel
2 DNon-FBI Personnel

o

71c. Was this relXlrt in writing?
1 DYes
20No

71d, To your knowledge, was any action taken in response to your report?
1 DYes
2DNo
3 0' Do Not Know

72. Have you ever been ordered or directed not to report, or discouraged in any way from reporting,
observations or allegations related to detainee treatment or interview or interrogation actions or
practices?

o

Yes
0 No
73. Have you experienced any actual or threatened. retaliation for reporting observatfons or allegatIons
of detainee treatment or interview or interrogation actions or practices?
Yes @ No

o

74. (Optional) Please prOVide any additIOnal comments regarding the reporting of concerns related to

OIGQ-005329

Int,erview 9r interrogati9ntecnniques, detention practices, 'Or9ther detainee t(eatmen,t.

~.~~~.'.-

7~, W~re~yqu ~ebrl~'fed, qtheJ:'tl1an the.~tandard dep.rlef'ln FD-'],7~, qm<;erfllng your,ov~rseas'
:assj~nment(s,) or:d~p'lo.ymerit(s) .after you .cQn"ipleied the de'~loyrt(ent(s) Qr .assig nrrfent(s}?-

OYes
1.6" Addition'at Comments and

0 NQ

Re~rhmentlati.bns:

OIGQ-005330