Depar~ment'of J~s,ti~.e In~p~c.tor Genefal 'Questionnaire R.e9.~lr.Qi~g rie~ain.ees,

O.OJ.-Ol:<3 INVESnG~Tlv.E QUESTIONNAIRE

F.O~ ~~VIEW~~DN~EF~~~::;'Ig~I~$U~\~~~:.ESP(jNDENI~
QUESTIONNAIREID:tes~~~002154

.As·af ~h~ I~st time th.is q~~tionn~ir~. wa~ ~a\(~~,. ~ome r~quire"d fields: hav~. nQ~ I?e~n cQ~pleted.
~I~s~·.r.eview·yburresp'onses-.
-= .~. ..

:;.':'

.A.

Per~onal

...'.

Informatipn

Please firovide'the following information:
1, fi(st tiqm~"
2.; Middle InltJClf:
"3'~ Last name:'
4. Entered bn D:uty Date (EOD):
,5; t'ur:r.ent Dl'1lsio.n/Field o.ffice:

() &;.r6.PERJM~~EEfII1fSN.T
6 &.7C P.ER.AGREEMEilT
6 '& 7.CPERAGREEME/'JT
6 & 7C
~ ~ 7C

6._ l:4rret:lt fob ~itl.e:
.7.. Direct 'd ial office.lelep ho'ne nU'rT'lber:
8... FBI t~1I Phorie' nlJmUer:
9. f~I p:ager numb:er;
1O.6'e.:>r cQntact numberforyolj:

'6 & rCPERAGREeMENT.

.B. BackgrOu"nd Of Spe'bifk: D,e'ploy'me'nts

or Assigrim'ents

$B,AA
6 &}7C, PE~ AGREEMENT
.Q &..1(; fJER,AGREEMENT '

~ ~,76 Pt=R4 Gf{EENJENf

,11. At any. time aft:.er~September 1l{ .2:0.01-, did you serve:a's a member Qf'the U. S, Military, or as an
'employee .or contractor of the, FBI or any o~h~r.government agencY.r at Guantanamo BaYI 'CiJba; Iraq~
,
A~gn?ln.i.stcm;··or i[l afeqS'·controll.~ ~y·the l).$~ Miljtqry. qr a V.S. inf~lIigenqe s~r,vlce in 'C0l1nect\on,with the'
:919bal WC1( on ~~rrot?
.
0· y.es 0 No

1:2. !=nter the number .(jf time:sypO, wer.~.d~pioy'ed o.r:aS$igned to each ofthe.fo.i1oWing lo:tati.oris:
by the. U.S. fVli1ita'ry or a u.s.

{GiJailtanamoBay~ tuba;, Jraqj~.A{ghahistan;.or iri:any areas controlled
i!1t~lIig~nce s~rVf~e.)Jl·

For .each deployment or assigi1l'nent .complete the following ·section.
Location (sele'et one)
.
l:?\lp-'.oYm~.nt 9. r ·il5.5ignrrerit'lieg~n·o-n.:cjr Cep'~ilnt or ii5si.gnl:ilent·.en.ile~on.

.. . . . ,
.
\.... , .. ".•"..
h.
~Guantan'amo
...
, ..... ""
... '-.Bay.
... ~

.~

"

.'~

abou.t

.

0.8/05/20:.02
.

or about

0.9/1312002
.-

l?a. What Was tJie ~geh:er.a'1 nat!) r'¢ i:!.n.c! p:(J tp'Q~¢, Qf y'QUr:.assigJi.r't1eri~ a'he! :a9:iVities?
Provi!:1e benaviora I. assessment and ir'iter:vfew strategy: to .interView teams -assig ned,
f2b. Please provide the' names of fhe..spedficcamps; base5.(.or facilities where you worked.
.C.amp' peltp
~2.~. Nb_t~: 'If inf9tm~ilon:.~bo'u.t C!:$!ie.cfflt .camp, base,. arfacHity'is dasslfjed :afi9~~ SE€R.E-Y,
pl~ase .ch'etk her~ 0, i~lude in Y-Ql!f:answer that you hav..e ~1C!d.ai~.ional·ill(Qnffation dj!3ssified "a,~ove
'SECREf,I\I' and, if you know, 'id.entify·.tbe.da'ssification' lev.el, 'ticket; ,compait'meiit, program, .or,other
des'lg!1a~i~n that ~pp!les t<? t~e (n.formatlon•.Do .n9t.lnclude' th~,ad~ltlonaJ €.!assffied Infprm~tron II) Y9ur

OIGQ-004771

OIG, l1ersonnel with the necessary clearance will. c<;>.ntact yOll to rec~ive it.

Que'stionnaire response$.
,N::'e

~

I,<=:
)le~.

:

.J_'_,

0 id Yo,1,! jojlitly

"

:i2f~ olcfYO-U)~~tIV

,~FBI personnel?

'

'_ JdnJ~~!lj~fL ~§I!~_v!o[~I~A.!l3!Y.§t~,~il!!:,~ _'_ - - - ~

_'_j,

int~,r.Yi,eW Qf !t1t¢tr~gate any det?iri~e with hQn-f~X per$9hneI7'

,O~

I

@~

:

-

o Yes

,

0

No

.

\ibrt§ jointIY?:'- --- - -- .-- --- ,-- .-- -- . --- . -- . -::

CITF

'Other u.s. M.ilitar'y:
iii' U.s. intelligence agency'

': 0

:

:0

b6
b7C

plan -a"ri ya~t~ih~ i~t~~ie~-~~r-I ~t~7rba:itio~ -:st~teg 1,-6bj&ti~'~ ot ta""cti~;,with non--;

:-With':Wh~t ki~ci;'6f'n~~:F~i ~~~riri~i:did \i~U

,: 0

Position

'

-!
':

.F,or~ig n military 9r inteJligenc:::e ageoC'l

: 0 ,O.ther
..

..

-

~

--

...

.-

...

-

-,

"

•

•

-

-

•

-........

•

.,

'.,

..

..

....

....

-"

-

"

i

-

.'

-

.....

-

-

....

'"

-

-

.-

,

-

....

-

-

-

....

- ..

, ...

-

.~

""

..

~

...

-.

_

•• '

-

...

i

)zi. -wci~ :y~~ ev~r~b~hirWise j,n~oiv:ed T;;dti~lj;~~Tnt~tVie~~,~rr~t~rro9aiibn:s- with- ncf[i:FBY~:er;'~ncli -:,
:
.'
_.- - -- - - - - - - - -_ .... -- - - - - _.... - - - - - - 0-...-.-Yes- -,------,0- _rilo
........ --- - - -- - -.- - _ - - - _.- - - - -- -- - -.-....

A., Training p'ripr to pverseas.Deployment.or Assignment
rece.'ive any tr~inirlg, -im;truCtlQr)', df guidance 'spec'lfi~a'iIYln prepa,lQt1on: fOf i3n¥'~Ofyolir
,oVerseas d.eploy'meiifs or assIgnments?,
''.
. ' .,
.
.

i3, DId you

Q.yes

0:No

Qoo Not Recall

i4, lit RY¢Pc;lrqtion for qlW dfYQur:9ver~ea?, trejJJoym'eht~ or as~tgnm~lJ.t$,..gi~ Y,o'u re(:~.iy.e:,any t.(C!fning., ,
Ib~n.lC:tlo,nT,br,guldan~cdncernjlJg t'he,$tandi:irds of ,conduct applicable'tel the, treatment,
interview, Qr iiiterr.og:ation 6f.detainees by FBI personnel?
'

o Yes

(VNo

'

.00'0 Not'ReCall

you recelv.e::any tra1nin'g"
instructibn, :or.igUidance cCH'1celliiri'g the.sta,hd~r.dS: of condUct appIiGable't(Hh~ treatmerit,
,
interviewj' or interrogation 'of detainees by non-'FBI personnel?

15. Xn preparqtiprr far My pfYQuf pverse.a:S. depJ,oy'hl'ent5'or assiQnme.nts, dld

'@No

000 Not Recall

1.6. Iii pr.~parati6rifor any b,fYbut oVerseas: depioyments o'r ,assignmehts".did YOlf receive 'any training"
inst'r:Uction",or ,gllidahce concerning wl1at 'you were,:sLJpposed to- db if'yo'U observed .6r;heard aboUt"
the 1;fe,atlTl~nt, inJervi~wi or-interjogat,ipnUf detainees by FBI person,r:tel,,'W~ic.t)you ~!i~ved to

OIGQ-004772

be ll']approprlate, ul')professional; coerc!ye.i ?Jbu$ive, or unlawful?

:QYes

'0No

Obo Nat Recall.

17. Tn preparation for' anv'ofyour' overseas dep'loyments or assignments, did you, receive,imy training,.
Instructlonf or:guldance concerning what-you wer.esupposed to:do jf you 'Obser:ved'orheard about

th~ treatm~nt, interview, Qr interrogption ~f pet9inee~ by n.on-F~I' p~l'$onn~l, which: yo~ be!i~Y~<;I
'to ~e.lil~j>propria:tef,lii)p.rb.fessjQnal~ j:ders:ive, .ab~sivj§, .or l..iiilawful?

I

lB.: T~Cfi_hinQ. D,I,I)'ing, O:v~rseas peployments.ot Assignm¢"t,s

Hr. 'Qu rinQ" any .of your ,p,v.er~?s.,d~pIQy.l'J1e!'\ts pr ,a'ss~g nm,ent!?, ~ ip Y.~ll .re~~lv~ qi1~ftRi inlng I j:nstr~!=tion,',
or guldance,Concerning the.,sta'tidar,as QLt,onduCt applicable to the, tr:eatmeilt, ii1te[Vrew~
inte'rl'og,atioh .of d,elaineesliy FBI personnel?' '
"
.

()r-

,

:0 Do No,t. Recall

OYes

19:. Qurln'g ,any' ofY9.ur' Qvers~a's tle~joYni.ents: pr a$sjgnmen~, ilid YQ!,I r~ce.lv~ .~ny' training t in$trlf~tl(m,
tir:guldancle,cdhc~rrTing the.;·stand.ar.ds ,of.conduct applicable to the treatment) interVie.ir,or'
interrog.ation of detalne'es bY. non-FBI pe'rsoriil'el?

byes

',bDo Not Recall

.20. Dutin.~ ~.ny. .of·your o.ve'rseas,~~P.lQyment$ ot' a:ssi'fftlm,e,of$! did 'you ~c';¢jva an,? fra'ining', ii)s~ruction,.
or Q.uidance :cohcernin.9 'What you'were sUpposed 10 dO':if you .observed ..01' heard .ab0ut the
.
treatment;. interview" or interro.gation,.of detainees by FBI personnel,. which y'ou' believed to be,
• i,na.pp,r0Pfipte·, j.J [1pr0f~~iona I, c.oerdve, a~u?iv~~ 9r !J nlawfu 17
.

DYes
:2~1. During any,af yoiJr mrerseas'deplayrrients or' ass\gnrhetlts, did you receive any trai'l1ing~rnstruction,:
0f 9"u id<:ln.ce:·e0nce~n·lng wna~ you. w.e.re· sl.! p~.ose.q to, QO .if. you 'o~~~.ryed or hear~:?l~out-t~e:
treatrnen.t, InrelVli;:!w,.or Interrag aJlq1n~f ,9.e~lnEle~ by. npn-FBl p~r~onnel",Whicb YOP Qelleve~ .~p
be inci'p.lir;opria~e'~. unprofessional"
. . c.d~rcjv:¢",abLfsive,, .Qr'uolawt'ul?

Qyes

0Nb

ODo Not Recall

Ie. Adequacy of Training
.

:22'. In ,your'opinlon(,dld

Y,ou 'receIve adequate tralriing, fnstr.uetlon!.:orguldance'relating to standards

'Qf t.9n~,uQ:· ~y FBI-ancl non-.FE~I p~rsP!Jne,1 relating to tr~trnel'lt, ipte.rview, ·Of ilJterr<;>ga~i(m of
.~,et~ih~ees pr,ior t,o yqur d~p.lo.yni'¢'l'it Pr'a'$Slgnm~M7

'

2.3.1n 'y.our opinion, did YOll receiv.e 'adequate training,. instriJCtiQrT, or gUidct'nce telafing·. t'o:Stah'd.ar.ds

OIGQ-004773

'of condUct by FBI'and noh-FBI p¢rsbnnel relat.i.rig to treatment! ihte.r\ifew~ bf jn~errogation of
.detainees durin.g your deploymentor assignment?
' .

a No

:0 Yes

24.1n your-opinion/ did' you receive adequate training, instr.uctionr or gUidance concerning what y.ou
were suppose!1 ~~.qp lfyou qJJseryed or h~ard ab.·out the treatment, intervJew, '0r interrogatkm of
'd¢ta"n'~sr by FBI -pr nOI)""Ff?I p~rS<in~l, tha~. YO:U'be.lievea ,wa:s inapptopdate, Ur'lpro~ss)f5.n.alr
.coercJve'1, ·ab.uslve,. or unl~lVffl.JI?'
.

~: NQ

O¥es

,. "24.~.: PI~a-5~ ~~~rib~'-ih; w~Y$~i~ ~bjch ~y~~ ~~~lf~V~ ~th~ if~i~ing; fu~r~~~tk>;; .'Qr ~.~id ~nc~ wa"'s .. - .-- _. - ,
in~d:eqJ1ate:
.
.
My traihil1g regardihg -standaras bfconau¢t reh3tinf;) to tr.eatment( inte.rvfeWt. or lnterro,gatidp .of
...

detainees· was the.traihirig,T teceived .duroirig, training .sthool in 1985 and as an,agent. in the field forlhe
'subsegu~!1t 17 y~ars., Nob9dy spe~ific.?lIy addres.seg. wh.aH() .do:~hile a$s'igl)~ ~o~·rt)i1itary .in~ta.IJation
if yql.! Q'pserv~d,or heard qJ;)(::lUt in~pp..r~prja.t~trefltmerit.
.

...

_

-

...

.....

,..

".

_

....

_""

_

""

lo'l>

.......

~

""

_

'"

_

:25.,(Op~j9a.al)In 'I\'.hi3~ V'Jays. €qn
a?slgnrn:~l:.!t~?

~

_

~

'"

'""

_

-

••••

_

-

_

_

..

tD!= F!3~ifl1PrQve:t.farnjng

_

_

_

..

_

...

...

-

....,

....

~

.....

_

......

• .1

...

..

__

"'"

",

of],t~ls subje<;:t f9r future qeploYn::'~nts.or:'

Add r:.ess:~he'~!.J.bjlFq: - ~I~ti~r fQrl)1~lly pr .IlJform~l!y. It wa's, mY'Q~?eryC!tiQn.u p:on: my·, retur.n from 'GTMQ
that 'noboCly ·at FeIHQ te~lIy' w.arit~d ~Q discu.ss· th¢'.mi3tt~r.:

10. Com.men~$2.6. pl~se pro\lide<any ad.ditional informatlqn con~erning tf"?!ln!rm 'for'Qverseas .deploYments·or
~~s,ig r:uT.i~nts qf F~I p$r.s<;lnn~1 you "beJiev,~ i~' "tel~v~n!...

'

.

l:Who fs. nqw· retired) and: I pmyicje(l trqin'ing t<;rSAs trom FBI ~nd'
, CITF ahC! iht~n(jew teams from the Military 'regardihg b"ehavip'tal:i:fppr.oach to interyjewstra~egy. We
developed ,and delivered a PoWerPdlnt presentation 'specifically addressing, the 'lsstl~ of respect and
rallPort builcl)ng with·detCli!1~s. Ttiis typeuf trainin,g wa~ not being pres~nte(:l ifl'any"other ~!1vir9nr'nellt,
:",t ~b~ iii:ne;

'My parirterpt 'G:TM'O· (ssA/

'

b6
b7C

-I!1troducti~., ~pPC!r~ II,I: In this se~tion, W~'are qe~king, iQT9rmCJti9r,l.regar~i!1g.a wicje' f<:lnge of
irileMew,or in.t.erro·g"a{lp:n t~~hhiques' and other .tYp!=s of (i~~~iri~e trer;tmertt :?illegea

tQ

hc!)(~ bccl,mejj.

Ypu should .n<>t:assuine, jiJ~~ because. we. are:asJ<in~f .about a p~lftjcUl.a.r teGi.n.iqile·,er pra'!=tite, that. w.e·liav~

,€oncfuded that it i'n' fact:oCl::;t1rred" We 'reroghize tbat<some pf these technifj"ues..or pl'CIGtices may at times
b~' rr~cessary for' 2afety and !lecyrity i!l ~ defe.nt.!on. setfiD9.. In' ~,dd ition; we recognjz~ tha~'5omeor-these
:re<;;hniCllJ~s. orprqc~l~es. m.ay have.be:en aU~ho.rli~ for use: p¥. mIlitary. qr Qtber gtlveromen!p'ers()nn~J. .
Wl.th respeo: to. -eacH identified tetliriiq i.Je, practicer-or type of.cOliC\uctde:scrjl)ed b.elow,.we .are s'eeking
infonnation'about its 0ccurrenceduring,:Or in connection with the interview or interr09,ation ofa
d~~ain~e,,or d!Jring. ~!1~ :de,tenti9ll .01' ~'d.e:t~i~e~."~y'<?nd ;wh:a~ is, n~eded for ~~felY,~n.d ~~~.yrity,i
In .th13t ,l;:QlltexJ, we w.ill a'sIC YQu to :te.Ir!,ls .whettr~r one Qr mqr8 :qf·the. fpllQwing stat~m~.nt.? ~r~ t(lJe~

OIGQ-004774

1. r personally :observed this cond.uct.
:2'. r.,ol?s~r;recl :de~aj!l~(s) In a ·(;.01')<;I1tlon t~9~ [eel mE? t9 b,eHeY~ !ha~ thi's;<;:onduet had -'9~~urr~.
3. D_etaln.e~(s;l Jo.ld meth~tj:h'is c6n'dutt ha-d 'j),ccurr.ej:j.,
4, Others: who, ob_s¢N¢d ~h!S;. CQodffCt de.strib_eil ]t to me,
S. I have relevant in-formation dassified aboV:e-"SECRETn "
,6-. I p'ever'obseryed tnisconduq: nor heard about.it 'from ,so.me()ne Who. <:lid~

a'. 0 r- perSonally observed this.conduct.
b; 0 I observed detainee(s) in a condition that led me to believe that this conduct had ,occurred.

c. 0 Detainee(s) told me that thiS conduct had ,occurred.
d.
e.,

0
0

btf:Jers whn observed this cqnducj;.descrlbed

!t to m~:

1 haVe relevant jnfor-m?ltlon dassifi~q above "-SECRET'!"

l. 0 t never oP~rv~9 tPis ,~o nd,uct .!'lOt; hel:! I'd about it fror)"r sqlJ1eone. wtJ.o .d i4.

,:i&. Depriyin!J cll:letai.Ii~_ of clothing
a. 0'11 personally oboorV¢d this conduet,
b~

c.
i--

tl.
e.

o Ii ,obse'eVed ,dela'ihee(s) in a .coooltiOh that led me to, believe thanhis c:o,nduc't had occurred.
o lDefainee(s)-told me that this conduct nad 'occurred.
o !othe~' Who observed this candu~t'd'escribed it to mE)"
o II. ~ave rel~vafit information elassiDe,~ 'C3b9'!~ "SECRET"'.

l. 0'

!I. nev~r obsef\l~,~ thi~"conductn.Qr
,about
.
-. ,h~t:.d
_.
. . .it frqm ~Qm¢on~who did.
"

....

.

.

.

...

,

b,

o !I. persdrially"observed this ~ohtliJct.
D,II observed detalnee(s} in a cO'Ild'ltion'that led 'ine to believe thi3tthis conduct had occurred.

c,

o

:8.

!Oetainee(s) t01d me that this conduct had :occurr.ed,

d, [j !O.thers who observed this CElnduct described it to'me.
e.

o iI: have relevant fnformat!on classlff~~ ~bO-v~- "S,ECREP\

f.

011 never observed thls'canpuctnor,b5:!rd aboltUtJror:n,someone wlJo qid.

OIGQ-004775

a. 0 I. persOnally obserVea this conduct.
b. 0 [ .observed:detalnee(s)- In 'a.cond itl6n that led me' to, bi:llieve that thiS. conduct had -occurred.
C. 0 Detainee(s.) told me that this conduct had .occurred.
._-f-"---..
.--'--'-'d. 0 Others who observed this conduct described it to me.
e. 0 I have relevant information classified abov.e. '!SECRET'\
fi(:>rbeard
itfrom someone who
f. 0 ~ never'observed thls.'conduct
.
......
. about
"
.. did.
,

a. 0
b', 0

perSdnal1y

obserVed

"

this.condud.

[oeserved. aetainee[s} in 'a,e'ohdition tliat lea me to· DeUeve ,tharthis cor1duct llado.ecufte'i:I.

'0.

p
Ll

·e.

0 I

f.

Itt

L nev.er observed this conduct nor'heard -about It 'from someone who did.

8,

D

I p~rsOrialiy. obi;~rV:ed thj~H:6Jiduo.

€;

b. 0
lc; 0

Detarnee(s)·told me that ttils co"nduct had .ocdlrr.e:t
Others who observed this· (;oJidud described if to. me.
have rele~ant infQrmatioO' classified abov.e "S:ECRET'~.

I.-observed detainee(~). in a·coM"itiOii that
Detaln~(s)

lea

me, to b~lieve.tliat'this.di'ndud had 0c·cuhed.

told me: that this Gonjj'uct had :oCCUlTed.

d. [j Others' who obServed this conductdesc(ibed it to' iTle~
!I·e. 0 r hav.e relevant information Classified aooye' '(SECRE[~'.
j f. 0' 1 never-observed this-conduct nor 'heard ·about it frbm someone who. did.

33. Threfltenrng other action to cause. physicaL p.ain, injury, .disf,g~u;,;;.(e;:;;m.:..:.e.;;.;n;..;:t~,..;;t>.;..r'..:::;.Oeat~.
::.;.:;;.;h:-.

_

,a. D [ p~r:sbnafly" 6b.serv~d.· this ~oMO.ct.
b, 0 I ol:;se(v.ed de.tairiee"(-s} ili·a condition that led me. to beiieve thcit.this tondt,Ict had :o:ccurred.
c.

D

Detainee(s). told me that thiS- conduct had ·octutred.

OIGQ-004776

"

d.

0

Others, who observed this conduct descrfbed It to me.

e. [j I have relevant information classified -above ,"SECRET",
f,

0

r n~verobs~rv~cf thjs 'c;onduct nor heard "9bout it from s9me0rt~ who. c! id.

34. Oihl:!r tr~atment or actiQf! qausiilg sign.ifj~ht phy.sical p!=jin or lnjl,lry r "gf c;aqsing ~i5fig,uremE;nt or
:oeath

0 I personally observed thisiconduct.
h, 0 Lobserved detalnee(s) In a-cond itlon that led me to believe that this conduct had :occurred.
c. 0 Detainee(s) to),~ me that thIs conduct had 'qccu!:red.
'd: 0 q,~e[S ~ho ()~~ry~,r;ll~is cqqduct'de~cri.beil it t~ 1Tl~
e. 0 I have rel~va,rit lnf9rma~i9n classified. CJl?:ov~ It'$.ECRET'';
'f. 0' r neVt;!r-o,b.~ery~p_ thi~,'condutt nQt h~rd ,a,po,IH it fl:9m Mmeone Whp <tid.
.a~

',3:5. pia-cing a, 'detalriee,:dn a h'ot'surface pr b:\lrnln~ 'a d~t~in~.

b:

o II' personally observed thfs conduct.
o iLobserved detainee(s) in a cond'ition that led me to believe that.this conduct had occurred.

c.

d

d',"

o rOt~er.s wt)o obser\/ed~nls conduct descrIbed ,It to me,
o II, have,rel~vant lnformation classJfied above "SECRET".,
o !~ n~ver gp?:erve~ t~is '<,;91Jc;!\,lct,nor heqrd 'a1?9!Jt if from,$Q!11~C?I1~:wh9

a',

e.
l

1Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had .occurred.

<iid..

3,6. U~iO'!l shackls;:s or oth~ne'stralntsIIi,a prQlart9~ rn.anner
,
a.

b.
'c.

d',

o III personally obserVed this contllJct.
I
o fr",observed .detaihee(s} in·a ,c6nditien that. led me: to, believe thatlhis amduc:it. had occu'rrcil.
o Inetainee(s)'told me thaUhis conduct had occurred.
o IQthel? W,l:l'9 observed ~tJis ~nd.u9t.qes<;riqed it to me.,

e. O.lr, ha,\le relevant Information claSSlfie9 ~b~ve "SECRET'''.
l 0lr rev~n)bserved this 'conduct I)Qr hear~'abQutiHrol'Jl ~meon~who'.did.

OIGQ-004777

37.

Requiring .a detainee to maintain, Qt restraining a ~detaiiiee In, a ·stre.ssful or painful p.osi~ion

a.

o It persohally observed this:Conduct.

b,

q

[.observed detalnee(s} In ,a ,cbOO itioD. that led me tC?, believe that this conduct had occurred.

0 Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had :occurred.
0 Others who observ.ed tnis cenduct described ft to me,
e.. 0 r have relevaDj: fnf0rmatlon e::lassjf~.d '~~Qve' "SEC'REP\
f, I!J Inever0bseryed' ttJis COIJP.uc;:~ nC?rhf;x:j'fO 'aboy1 it fror:n someof1~"Y~o
G.

d.

3~.RlI:dng a detainee

to perform .demcmcHng physical exercise

a. 0
b. 0

I personally' obserVed this.-,c<>.'ndu¢t.

e. 0

oetai'hee(s)'told me.that this conduct had .occurred.

d.

D.

I
did.

.

I ',observed delainee(s) in a·~6ha ition that led, me to belieye that 'this conduct had .occurred.
Others who 'Qbsenred this condl:lctdescribed It to' me.

0 I h,ave relevant infon-nation e!qsslfiea apove II·SEG~ET"·,
to 0' r' never'observed thls'cond,l,Jct nor h~rq ·aboyt it,f.romsome!>[l~ W~o did.

'e.

0 I personally observed this conduct.
0 I.observed detcirnee(s). in 'a,cond itiohthi:lt led me to believe thanhis conduct had 6<itu:rted.
c. Cl Detciihee(s) t01d me thanhls coiiduc1: had ,clecurrecL
d. 0 Others who observed ,thls- cond uct described It to me.
e. 0 L have relevant i'nformatlon c1assiffed a'bove. "SECRET'!.
f~ 0' rnev~r·observ~dtlii$J<;ondu~t I)or heard,abol,lt iUr<?rn. som~~rre:who-did~

a..
b.,

a. 0

1. personally.obserVed this.:tofitJuct.

b. 0

~ oBserved. detainee(s} in 'a,condition.that led me to bel.ieve that this .conduct b'cid ,6crcurr.ed.

OIGQ-004778

c. 0 Detalnee(s) told me that thIs- conduct had :occurred.
d. 0 Others. who observed this cood uct described It to me:.
e. 0 r~~ve relev~.nt informqt[on d~ssiff~ C!~ove "-S~CR.ET~.

't. 0'

1. n~~(·o.pserve,d

a. 0

r. personal!}' 6bseNed this :C;·Qhduct.

b.

a

thls;tQli~u~t

:nqr heard abOl,lt It from sqneon~Whp.dld.

.observ.ed detainee(s} in a c6.nditiotr that: led me to believe that thiscondtlet had .occo'qed..

·c, 0 Detainee(s) told me that this conduc't had :occurred.
d. 0. ,Othern who absented this moduct d'escrlbed it to me.
.

.~

f.

0 I ~C!,ve re:lev~,nt infor[Tl~ti9n, dassifi~ aboy<;:. ·SEGm....
0' I, f!~v:f?;rQ:~serveq thf? 'coO.duet llorh~Xd abpu~ I.~ fl1?!Tl SQf.!1'?Q!1~·'vV!}9

QI~.

42.: Hb.Qdlng dr bJindfo"kling a 'i1etaln~'other: than ~ur.i(l9:~ransp"Ptj:ati.Qn

a. 0 I.pe"rsor'faJ!y observed this :c'oOduct.
b: 0 r:ob$e"r'lted detalilee(s} in 'a-,condition th'at led me to. believtHhatlhls' eonducit had occur:red.
c. o ~Detainee(s}told me thatlhis conduct had .occurred.
e.

o :Others who observed ,this conduct·descrlbed it to me.
o 11 have rele.vant informatfon classified above "SECRET/{.

f.

011 never o~bserve~ ~his~conduc~ n9r hecjrd:a~ou~·.ltfro~ s9rT\~n~'who did.

d.

,

4j, $ubjflC1:ing a d~taln~ t,Q :extremely. co!Q"Or h,ot fOQm ~mpera~re'S" for extende<f'p~r)pd:s

.a, 0 I per56nallY'obserVed this conduct.
b. 0 I bbse[ved detalnee(sJ In 'a.condltlli5n that led. ,me to. bel1eve that this chnduct. had.6ccuirett.
c. 0 ,Detcii'nee(s) told me.that this conduct had .occuned.
d. 0 ·otherS who obserJed tllis cMdliet de·sc::ribed it'to me.
e, 0 I have relevant lnformatkm classlffed abov.a \!SECREf"·,
I, 0' I l)eV~r"QbservecJ thjs oolJdL!C;~.n~Jrh~r~ ~bol.;lt it from sOl:p~~m~"Vf)o did.

OIGQ-004779

44. SU~jecc,tjn~ a petcnl1ee to iOl,ld musiC
a',
b,
,c.

0
0
0

I persooalfy observed this:conduct.
I ,observed defalnee(s): In :a.,condition that led me to believe thanhls conduct had occurred.
Detainee(s)told me that this conduct had 'occurred.

e,

o lathers who observed this cQnd uct described it to me.
o It hav~ relev~!lt Information G!ass[fre,g ~~ove II,SECRET"'.

(

~

d.

1, nev,erobserved thIS COI)!;f,lJst 'n',?r hecjr~ ,about it from som,~()n~ w~o cpd.

,45. Su.bjecting a detaine~ to bright fl 9shing lights 'Or darkn~~s
'a.
b''.

e.
d.
'e.

t

o II persdnally' observ.ed this ',conduct.
o lLobserv.ed detainee(s) in' a'c6nCl ition:that led me to, b'elleve that this tond,ud had ,om,orrea,
o \Oetaihee{s) told me that this conduct had ,occ'urred.
o !Others who observed this cond l:lCt. described it to me.
o It h,qV,e relevc!l1t inform.qtjO'Il c'q~sifjeQ ~pove, IJ'SEGREr".

o Jr n,ev~r'qbserved

thrs"coQd,uc~,noLh~rd',about it fromsome~:>new~o did,.•

a .. 0' !r personally observed this 'coOctuct.
b"

c.
d,
e.
f~

o IL6b$¢rved detainee(s). in ,a,cond.itiotl,th-at led (he tb believe thi=lt this co'ri.duct had occtlited,
o !Detalhee(s) told me that this conduct had ,Gccurrecf.
o ~Others. who observed :this conduct described It to me.
o !Lhave relevant information classified above 'ISECRET'!.
o Ir 1)~yer Qb,ser\(~d th!sJCc,mdl!ct n9r heard ab8ut it 'from someQfT~'wh9 did~

g', Please pfQvit;le the ?lPprOXlmqte time 'fr9me, 9uring vv~fch this'<;;ond!J<:t occufreq..
Frqm O&/QS.j200~ ~o 09/13/2002
OD'o Not Recall

,h. The detaine~(~1 ~r<;ated 'In thfs way w~re, Iq~at~c;/ ~t th~ time il1;
i ~ ·Gm:!'ntgl1p!110
:2 [) 'Irpq

OIGQ-004780

3D Afghanistcln

4 D other Location
50 DQ: Not I<etall
t· Pleqse fch:~rimy the !JE:tairr~(~) try name qild n.Llmb~r:

·#63

.

j. Plea~~ fd,e,ntj.fy the person(s} wh9 ~[~ated the petaioee(s) in t\1is.manner, includ'ing their
n'qm~(s) an9 goV¢rntTi¢ri~~genCY(I~).:
.

I:am nqt SUr,e. who _ordere:::l this isolation but Colonel ~
,
~as. certairily- in\ZblveClZJ·
~he individual into lsolali6li. Several fBI Persoriiieir iJiclti'dif\Q :SA
S
L-Jweret.ask,e~ wl~t) lnt~rvi~ing ¥irrc.i'~~rvJ,l").9 him.
.
k. Please-identify a'ny~6ther FB] personnel flr- hon-FBI personnel ~who,obseived detainee(?} treatcil

I

In t~ls manner,

FBI:I,

["crUd]"; their [l~me(s; -;nd rge_l)CY(Ies)~
, , . Iss
rotif,," SSAI

personnel who·observe .i:fetaJn.ee VJa', e eVISlo.n momtor.
I. ThlS'mni:!uct pq:uri:ed in connection with~

1:0 ·One.detainee

b6

riid

b7C

lano numo'"'''' Olh., FBI.

.

2" ,.0 .5e\£eral detainees (1-4')
go Many Qe:taln~es (more tnCl.f.l. 4.)

·4 Q

D~ Not R,"fB1l

m. {Optional}'Please describe the relevant circumstances in mor.e:detail:

47.. ,Us'ing ~d.uct .taPe to

0
b. 0
c. 0
d. 0
e, 0
a,

I

.observed detalnee(s1Ina'cwndltion that led 'me to believe that this conduct had,:occurred.
Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had occur-red.
OlhersV'lho"O~served

t!!is ~J1dlJtt

desCfj~ed

it to qt€:.

,ha'1.~ re~~afit Intonn:a.tjon ~a~?irj~: a~ov~ ~SE:CI~Er~'.

0'

0
b. 0

_

personally, o'bserv.eCl tnis.condtld.

ney~r:obselVe~ thl;s ·condu.ct·nq~·hear..d abo.lJtlt .from.SQmeoQe'whp did.

4"8. 'USlng
·a.

restralii, :9£9:, or .~pu,"h"ls",h.'-·"".,c"e"ta"·ih"e,,e'---

rapid. resP.6rl.s.e te:a'm.s .and/or f6r~ cell el'tt@tticins
perSonally observed. tflfs .conduct.

.observed.defainee{sJ in·a'c6ndition that led

me fo belielle thaUhis c::onduct

had occiirred..

OIGQ-004781

.

.'

,

,

d. I~f Others who observed thls conduct described It to me,
e.
f.

"

0 r have relevant information classified above "SECRET".
0 r n~ver obs~rved this 'c<;>n~uct nor \:Ieard ~bout it from ~ome0n~ wht? didA

g. P.le~se p.rgVid.e the appro?<irnatf( time fr?irpe c;luring'whr~h this'l;oodug qcc!Jrred,
Fr:om :CM/QiYYYY form:at qr M/:fYYy) 19 (MiD/YYYY forma,t 'or MiYY¥Y}
00'0 Not. Recall
h. Th~ deraj.(le¢.(s) ~re.~teQ.)n this \I'(~y we.re,19~,a.t~ ?It. tb~ t!rT)e 111:-

0 '<;iu~l1tan_amo
2 o 'Iraq,

,1

.3D Afghariistim

0

'4

Other l.:oeatlon

5 d Do Not Recall
'j. P.lease'identify' the :detairiee~s) by rian1'e and number: .
, Unknown. .It-was.descrlbed generally 'by guards,
). Pl.e~s.e: identify the; p,erpon(~) 'Wh9 ~re,qted th~; de.,aln~e(s) In t.bls. mann,er., Jncluding ~hE!lr

'hame('s) ahd goVe.tlin'lent::ag'en'tY(ies):
Oi"ikilo,wn.

'

.k

PleCise: i.denlitY any·ptli.er fBI persbiinel or non-FBI p.ersoiinel who' ob.served detairiee.(s), treateci
iil tbis ilia'nner, including their ilame(s) and agendY(ie'sl:
.

,

L This ,conduct ,oecurred' In €orinectl0n ,with:
1 '0 One'detalnee
,;l 0 'S~v~~1 d:etC!jryee'~ r~-4J
~ '0 Many d~tpj.nees '(!'JlQre: ~han 41
4,~ J;)b \'lot Recali

4,9. !J~ing' ~ miiitEll'y war~in'g. ~lOg (1) 6r near a d¢tcHn.~ other than' d!Jring a~tainee tr~ns~j'bita.tlon

~ d, r. personally' observed thiS:conduct.

e.

0
0
0
0

f.

10

b'

",

c.
d,

I'9l;>,s~.ryed detai,n~~(s} i,n a 'cqnd i~)9!l that I~~ lTle' t~)' b~!i~v,e thpt thi!? cQn.9.UGt nap :occurred.

O'etalnee(s) totd me t~at thIs conduct had :occurred.
Others who observed .this (;;ondLtct:d,esctfbed it to' me:
'..

•

•

•

•••

R

~.

J

•

~

~

•

••

•

•

~ hav~ r~leyan:t i,l,lf~rm,qtrqn ~Ii;l~sif~ep pb.9v~ "SECRET!';
I. n.l'!ver 9.b:s,~rv~~

this

~dndll~t nor. tteard 'abO,ut it fr.,om ~om~on~whq, dJ9.
. .
..

OIGQ-004782

. SO. Thr.~tenilJg to use military working dogs,on or near a detain.ee

a', 0 I. perspnany observed this .cond·uct.
b. 0 t":ob~~'{~d d.et~ineets) ]n .a-cqnd itjen tha;t J~ me ~e' b~lieye ~hat this cpndu<;t t)(?d ·Qq;urr~.

c, 0 Defainee(s) tol~ me-tl)at thjscondu~t haj:1.occorre.d.
,I, 0 others who observ~ 'thl~ cpnqu.ct d'esc;:rlb'ed ft: tp' fQ~,
e. 0 [ha~e r'eleVEllit infoni'latloh' :Cla'Ssltied aBoVe. "SECREt'.
f,
[ h'e\(er ab.s:¢iVS$f ttii~,c9nduc.t 119f hegrd ~ab9lJJ it from ,some.one. Woo did.

"".

.5.1. ,Using .spiders~

.scotpi6.ns~

snakesrpr.Qther arllinals"on or near-a-!1etajnee.

a. 0

[e p~rso!l.<!,IJY obsel"'{ed, ~h"s ·con~uct.

lJ, 0

I :o!?~rv~q d~~~ilJ~~) 10 n 'cp~ itJon that· led lTJ~' to' ~elieve th;;lt t.hi~ wnduct had ·o~curr:~.

c. 0 !Q~{a.ine,e(&) ~9J~ ..rn~ thClt t:bls.l:.olJduc.~. had b<;CUrre<:i,.
;:, 0 Others WIJ'P QbseJYed t~is, l;poduc;t d~s'"crib~ it Wme.
~:

i.

O. "h~,~e rele...-an~ iofprn:apJiqn I:lassified ~1?O~e ":$EC,m".

""

I. rie!\{.er·o.liseried .this::oontluct ilor h~rd'abQut it from sdm-eqrie- whQ dId..

.52. Thr~teIiJtjg- to lj's-e.:spld!'!rS, -$cdr'e.!dns, :Sl'lake~( or ether ~lnlmalS' bn.a,detalhe.e

a..

b.

o h,personally'o:b~.d ~his:<;onduct.
o lI,ob~rved._det~lnee:<s). In.a 'conQlt~Qn't!lat led.(l1~ to· be:llel/~ tftaUh!s oond.u.ct had occurred.

0
~. 0
e: 0

r have relev?\n,t Ir:tform-atiotl d;:isslfl.ed d bpve' "§Et.~"·.

f:

I ne\!er ob~rVed' thj:;;,oonduc.t npr h¢ar'd'aboJ,llit from. SQm"¢bn~ \vho' dkl. '

.W

""

Q~~~,jlJ~(s). tql~

fIl!'! t.hat tt1is:q:ll1d.uc.t had

O"(:~rre(L'

Q~ner,;. wh9 9b~erved tl]is. q:lI1Quct·d~5=ri~eQ

i.t tq ooe;

01JJI personally ooserved this.conduct.

OIGQ-004783

,

b. 0
<::. [1
d. ·0
~. 0
f.

0

..

I observed detalnee(s) In a condition that led me to believe that this conduct had 'occurred.

!Oetainee(s)'told me that this conduct had :occurred.
'Qthers whf? observed t~is conduct'descri~ed it to m~

I l1,av~ reI~vant Ihr9rmatlon da:~slfled ~ bov~ ".;SECRET' •
~ n~v.erob~rve,9 this·wnd~Gt.nor hear.d ·obo.ut. it from'sqmeQne:who did.

54. Shaylh'g a,Q.etainee'$:facial or oj:her~airt9 emBa.rra~s:o(humiliate:apetairiee
a. 0- r personally observed

this,c6ildlkt

c.

0
0

d,

o lb~hers wh0,{)bser:v~ l.h.is Gql')duGtd~cribed

'e.

0 r. f1ay.~

b...

Lobserved ,detainee(slln ,a'cond ition.that led me to' believe that this conduct. had ;occurred.
Detainee(s) told me thatthls conduct had accurred:
r~levar.t rnf.;>r[ll,at!qn< c1a~qrfj~~

t. 0 r never- qb,~,erye:d

It to me."
.?l1?9V.e . .·S:i;cl;(q·\

~.hl§:cQ!1q\J,~t nQr' h.~rd

;aQQL!t It froJTl,~rneon~who

~Id.

5,5. Rlq!=ing a woman's' c!pthlng qn :a detainee
'a.
b,

c,
d.
e.,

!--

f.

0
0

I personallyebserveCl, tnis .conduct.
·..obserVeddefainee'(sJ in ,a·condition that led me to' Iielieve that this eonduct had :occurred.

o IDetainee(s) told me that this condud; had :occurred.
o \Q.thers who observed this cond uct described It to me.
o Ir.h~e relevant infi;>rll)ation clqssffied above.
I~S'EC1~ET'\
.

'
o II neverobservet4 thiS condu~~ m?r'l1~r,d:ab,out it frol"(l S0meon~'who
C!ld.

~

.5,6. Tquchjng :a detairt~,9r

actih~ :toWaro a detailief; 'In"asexual manner

a.

0 I persOnally observed this ~ond.uct.

b'.

o

ILohseiVed detafnee(s) in a condition that led me to believe thanhis conduct had ,occu'rred.

e. 0 Detaihee.(s) 'fold me that fhis coridu'ct had ,oc<iurred.

0' Others who observ.ed this conduct.d'escrlbed It to me.
e. o II hqv,erelevant jnrorITJati(:m, qassifi~ Above l~sEtmJl·.
f. 0 I f.le~e.r observed thi,s"condu,ct n9r !leq,rd aq,ollt it frol'fl SQl11e,o,ne who piq,.
d.

OIGQ-004784

57..H6Jding aelainee(s) who were not officiallY. acKhciwleage'd or r.egistered
detaining the person. -

0
b. 0
c 0
d. 0
e- o
f. 0'1
Cl:.

8.S

such by' the agene(

-

I personally' a.bserved this cofldue;l
fbb.selY.ed d~tajli~~J in );i;'cpr'Klitioh tnat I~ me..to ~lie~Jhar ~t'lI~;-ooMuct
Detainee(s) tpld hl~ ,that thji?.c(mch:Jj::.t had o.c:curr~.

ifad occl,lrred.

Others.. who qbserved this. conduct deis.crib.ed it t6. me.

r hav.e r~Ie.v.aOt

jnfbrm~trOh da:;sifi!'!d abov.e ·:SECRET....

L ile\t.er·o.bsehieo this tonCiutt "nor heard :abdut It fi'ort'Lsomeon.e wtio: did.

58 . 'Sendil"\g a detainee to another OJuntry for more aggresslve'interrogation
if,

0 i p¢r;:;pnalfy' oJ)5e!rVe"d this ,c;;on~utt

b, 0

ob.~.rve~ eJ~~lfl~e(s') 11)"'.<;1. ao.nd.i.tipl)' that. led m~. to ~lie¥~ th;::lUhiS" cond.u~ h?d oc;:~urre·d.-

c:
.~~aJn:ee.<~) tptd m~ t~~ thiS: ~olid.u~.t had~·eturred.
d. 0 others· WhO. 'bb'sewed thiS: ctinduct destribed it ttt me.
e. 0 have relevaht information' .cIas'sifie:d :above. '!SECREf'r..

r2

f.

0'1

never obserVeo this:toliouct l1bt hear'A 'about it fltim· siJmeone who dli:l:

59, Threatening to-send a detainee to ahother'cOuotiy ror detention or more agg"ressfv.e inteh;ogation

.,.

I per.son.aIIY' C?~s.e~.Q, this:con.ct.L!G.t
r observed' detain'e~(s)- In a .cpndftloJl that led m.e to bel[~vJ;~ tbatihis. c'ond.IJet !:lad oc'¥Urred.
pe:taihee(s) told tne that this<C.9~I,lCt. h~'ict 'o'ecurrea.

e.

0
0
0
0
0

f.

f0

I never·ob.serVe.d thl.s:q>JitiuQ: riQr h~r~ .abOOt Itlrprh.sorrfeon.eWhl)" dld.

b.

c:
d.

ci~h~"rs' Vo(hp o~~'rv!,!d -thl!:; C.dn:d.l,lC.( des:cr.lbed It. ~q m~:

r have reievalit information' Classified above "5ECREf

.
ir

•

·SD. Threafening to take adion against.a detainee's fainily

OIGQ-004785

,

0
b. 0
c, 0

a~

~.

p

I personally observed thls..conduet,
I observed detainee(s) in a',conditioll that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred,
D~~ainee(s) told fTle that t~i?, e0~yd: ~ad 'OCCI,nr~.

qthen; whQ 'ob'ser:v~ this, cond Lfc,t: ~:e_~¢Jlbed It t~ me:

0 ~ hav,e relevant lnrormation dassifi~9 above. "'S'ECRET'''.
t: 0 r n~yer o.bserved, thi~ t:~n9ud nor h~rd 'ab_out it from, SQmeqn~',whQ

e.

:6.1. 'O.ther treatment Qr' action causing
a.

0

~ever~

pid.

emotiOnal Of psythold!:jrcal trauma to a d~t,alhee

L personally observed this conduct.

h, 0 L:oDserved deta'lnee(s) In a condition that led meto belleye that this Gondl;lct flad :occurred.

0 Det~i!l,ee(s,j told m~ thCj~ this, condu<;t h9d 'Qccurr~~
~1 0 Oto-el§ ~hl) 'O.bserYf?d· ~thl.s. ~Cil,Jld ys;t (te~~.rJbep It t9 m~. ,
e. 0 ~ hav~,r~l~vari,t I.nfprma~191) ~lC!:S$.,lfl~ il~9V~ ":~',I;C~".
'f. 0 I n~ver ob,~ehfe,q thjs'GQnQuct !lor h~r~ ;~1:?9ut it from. sbme~ne Who, did.
c.

' ,

E 00
lb.

I pe'roonaUy- observed

this,e~nduct.

i,observed detainee(s) in a'condition that led me to believ.e that this <!0nduct had 'Occurred,

c.

0

d,

o ,Otners who obse~v~d this cO:l)du,c.t"Oescriq~ it ,to me;

Detainee(s) to'ld me that this-canduct- had ,occurred.

0 ~ helve r~l~vant !nrofl1l~tj9n; _c.l~ss!fI~d d_~<?ve "5E¢RE]'''"
f. Itt I. n!=v~r9~?f=rve~r ~hi,s '~Qn.dud 'Ilor. ,he,ar~ 'abQut it In;)ITJ 5Qmeol1f; w~o dJq,.

e',-

6:3-, QJh~rtr~~tm~ntQf fl ~et~ine'~~bi;l,t in·')rQ.ur Qp'iniQn' wps u)'jprQf¢_~sj9,ri'al, .l;!ll~LtIy' h~r.sh or,~.!i!Jres,~N,~4
,coerCive, abusive, 'or u n l a w f U l '
. "

a;,'O I, perso.n.~lIy obs:erved' t,hi~ '~Q!lqus:~,
b, 0 r:'0~seryed cjet9Irl:e,e(s) In 'a ~<;:Qnd l.t:lotl' ~l1at led, Il)~ ~O" belIeve ,th,a~ this ~Ciln:du~ had -occorred~
~~ 0 Detaine'e(~) told me t!lqt thiS qmduc~ h~d olX.urreq.
-d .. 0 Pth~n;' w,ho op~rveQ :this candu,ct'd.estr.il1e,~ it to l:Tl~,
.. ..
,.
..,
...
.,.. ..
.. ..
,

,

.

~'."

..

-

_

,

OIGQ-004786

D t have relevant Informatlon classified above "SECRET".
t: 0 r never observed this'Gonduct nor heard about it from someone who did.

e.

Mm0
'g;~@1~~
ynu
~4~ Di~

,~

c;>Q.~rv~?II1Y ,impersQn,atlqn ,of F~I persQnnel bY'iln'l0ne'during an int,erview,or in!~rro.gation of

cf,<!etaihee?

-q y~

'~,

No

-6~. P,ict any, d'etainee:ocpther ~rSO!l tell YQQ t,hat 1)~,Pf site h;3~ ~itne$~ed \he imper;s:onation Off~i
'pe~bnhel'ln cQhnectiQl'rwith 'il de,tcline¢ interview or iriteiTogatiQil?

:QYes.
66~ Are 'you aware

·0No

of any ";sham".or Ustaged .detainee'interuiews or interrogations conducted forlVlembers
O

:ohh~' u. s. C'ong.ress;or -their st?!ff?

.0, Yes 0, No'
,
;(;l6a: De.sC'ri~:tlie,JlatJ.ir'e, tlm,e, place and' dther re,ievant.circums.tencesra.rid identitY-the.persons:
involved: :
"
.
.
I did not personally. obseNe this. lwasad,v:ised by a DRS interrog,~tor that It was' being .d of'le, In fact,( he <
P'Ja"nne~ t~)' le?lv.~.the miljtal'¥',l,Ip()r) hi,S tetU.rn ,tp tlie.L!.$; partl~u~ Qfthi~ pr?lC~iCei H~, wa,s'arj Air'
FdrCfi! eOlisted
r\pm~
,

m,m

.67., To your knowledQe!, did any, rhllitary or intl?IIi.gence personnel ever deny o~ delay 'FBI :access to,o .
'de~ine~ the FBI \:y'anted' to qu~ti0n becau~e·th~'detp.inee h~d.:sJ"s~ail'!~, inju.~i~s aft~r he ~s captur.ed?

OYes·

eNo

68.. Did 'you

ever :end Ydur paitil:ip,atiort ij) .or dbs.erYatibn of 'a 'detain~' inten./.iew: or iiiten:o~iatibii
because of the intervieW,6t interr.~,gation methotls bein9 'Used?'
•

0: Yes' .@ N.Q:
.69·;"Were. you ever'tQ!d :t;ha,t~'a'Qott1'7r FB.I :em,ploy.ee 'ended ~IS 'or 'her parl!i5=ip?tion In or o~setvatlon of, a
Q~~Qin~ intet"li~ p'r int:errQg~tiqn b:eci;l'~e Qnht;:: intervfew o.r .int~rr.Qga~iQ.o rn~thQcts. b,~ing u:?ed?'
,

~: '(~~

0' No

'Sga.. Brief,ly, d,escr'ibelhe 'intervi~w or J:n~err<?9,~tipn m.etbods ,~eing used! and whe.n
!cni~ where thr~',Qcqlrred, in!=luplng t~e' nqm~·ofF8I·an~to~ ncn-FBI per!i9..l')n~1
inV9rV~~.

'

~~pVPs:t tjm~fr~r.rre'
-other Personnel Involved

'GTM9

Unknown

jNon.,.FBI Person!

OIGQ-004787

b6
b7C

any detainee interview or interrogation practices, or other types of detainee treatment, to an FBI
supervisor?
Ves 0 No
16
70a. When and to whom did you make this report?
b7C
September 2002 to
70b. Did the report relate to conduct by FBI or non-FBI personnel?

o

uq

I

1 D FBI Personnel
0 Non-FBI Personnel
Identify the agency with which the non~FBI personnel were affiliated.
Unknown
70c. Was this report in writing?
1 DYes
20No
70d. Was any action taken in response to your report?
10"Ves

2

2DNo
3 DDo Not Know
My after action report was merged into one drafted and submitted by the
team from the Behavioral Analysis Unit that followed my assignment to
GTMO. The report was authored by SSAI
71. During any of your overseas deployments or assignments, did you report any concerns regarding any
detainee interview or interrogation practices or other types of detainee treatment you observed or heard
about, to a non-FBI supervisor or other non-FBI personnel?
@Yes
0 No
71a. When and to whom did you make this report?
INelS folloWing my return from GTMO.
71b. Did the report relate to conduCt by FBI or non-FBI personnel?

I

b6
b7C

I

1 DFBI Personnel
2 G1Non-FBI Personnel
Identify the agency with which the non-FBI personnel were affiliated.
The report was non-specific.
71c. Was this report in writing?
1 DYes
2 LtJ'No
. 71d. To your knowledge, was any action taken in response to your report?

b6
b7C

:t

l!t1Ves
20No

3 kDnoDo~
1
L_;w~- Know ~ook these concerns to his chain of command within the
U. S. ra .
72. Have you ever been ordered or directed Datto report, or discouraged in any way from reporting,
observations or allegations related to detainee treatment or interview or interrogation actions or
practices?
.
OVes
0 No
73. Have you experienced any actual or threatened retaliation for reporting observations or allegations

OIGQ-004788

of d~tainee .treatmeot 'or interview- -or interrogptlon actions or practiees?"

.

.

0

¥~~

..

·0' N.o'

,

7.4. (Optjqlla)) p.lea.~. p'rQvid~:any a.d.ditiqm;l.l €Qmm,e.nts r:eg,cmli!1g ,th~ r~l>Drtrng 'pf cQn<;:~r!ls,related

t9'
lJ1~ery,J¢W·Qrln~e:rf6gaJlp[l1e'chnl.ql-J~~lJ:!~t~n;l:fotl p':ra!=tl~~, !;>r Qt.h¢r ~¢t~Jne,e tr~tment.
:I proviaed' 'add itional comments and obsel¥atl0 ns. ta:cr U. S. Navy Ueu tenant ,Comma nder
(L~D R.) W.h~ wa,s <:!S?.ig·n~ 'l9 .<n!1Q.. a.? 'pa !1'ot·!h.e t~~m: p!~nn !rig 'tjl~ tribl.!n.als-l·t9.'fJ~.~d. s ~t).~,entf .aT
my t~ilUr~ ,there, The'!=<;!nc;~ns I ,ma~~ y.'e(~. gE;!n:er'?ll' jnr1~tlJre b.at sp·~tifit;~lly a~vi~~
that iriteNjew .t~a:m"s-at GT.MO:sh6Ur iJti~ b~ hi-v.olged il'faJJY'Rind 'of ihtervie,w:strategies th'a't were

b6
b 7C

n'Ol "r.espeetfuland b'ullt on rappor.t\
nCl .r alsb had ~bnver.sat1G)ns w.lth ttle"CIT/:' on scene
cor:nrpal1der at the tlm.e :re~ard i,ng .lot,erVlew s~ra~eg"ies. ~nd wIlY they n~ded ~o:be b,uJ.lt on .r:a ppo.rt;
,b.uJl~!ng. ang re!:ip~c~,. We, l~er-a(ly P..9I.mq~9 thiS' n9tl9n Into' the· h~d.s Qf all. with w~qrn V'Je cam~
into, cQnta,tj:.

Talso' praY-ided training at .the Militar:y In'teiligence Training, Academy 'in Ft. Hl:Iachuca'( A"L
t9 ,apP'rm:(II11.a!~ly7~ millt.ary· re~rylst% y.JhQ:,#er~ gn"!helr way tQ. GTMO. Tt)I,~ tr~lnil)g -W~'S: the
$am:e that· we. RrQ~iid:eQ tQ b.l,Ir 'p:eople. to GTMQ - r~SlleC.t, fpp'poit'b,OiLdijlg jrit~rvl~w sttateg'ie,s.

'ru:\YAig.~.~~,

'r

. 75', Were:Y0u debrIefed,. other than the standard debrlefin FD-J.72~,cancernihg:YQur:oyerseas
, asslgl'!rTJ~n.t{s) ·0~,QeploYment.csJ after yol,! c.;orTwJeted .t.tJEl·d~plC?y.m~nt{~J ~r a~slg!1r.n~D~(~yr'

0'V~
75.8.. Who. debriefe'd

you?
-b,sAC Fran.~ie ~ttle .and ud

0, No-

h6
h7C

I

75b~ W.h~n

and 'where .did the debriefing(s) .occuf?
CIRG, Sep-lember 200,2.
. .
,'

75c.

w.~~ YQl,f ~~k~ ~~opt ~~t~il')~:detenlion
debriefiiig(:s)?

'

Qr'

irit.~,rview.

'Qr 'in.t~rr~g<;l.tiQn

praci::ic~~during

th.e·

: CiNes
.O·No'
7~d. VV'J:l~~ Qther su bj eq:,s 'Vf.er~ cq~.~re~ du Ring Y9lJX ~ eb rlefi.~g,( 51?'
When: QUr'jjolicy' sh6ula be·'aliCl.hdw. we €<>Ultl best s'Upport:the inission.-at GTMO.
'].,~e; Was any d.ocurri,~n.t p:repar~d ~O' memQrlallze~th~'d~b'r[¢flrrg7
b Yes .0. No' '0Do Not Know
7.6:. Add itional Cdmm'ents 'ah'd Recommendations ~

Tha ok you

for your .co¥oper:atiori rn .t'6m pl,eti fig tHfs: questi0nriair.e~

OIGQ-004789