1

found in violation of the Public Records Act during the specified time period cannot be related

2

to the allegations in Plaintiff's complaint. For similar reasons, this interrogatory is overly

3

broad and unduly burdensome. Plaintiff has equal access to court files if Plaintiff desires

4

additional information.
Without waiving the above objections, here is information about

ANSWER:

5
6

PRA cases from 2006 until 2014 in which the Department has paid money either by settlement

7

or penalty:

8
.Name

9

\• Inmate., Forum:

Ca5e

'

..

:;

.•

>. .Date

Cause.'!#

;

.'

'PayOut

: Closed .: ·

;

'''."

;

.

:.

Penalty/ ·......
Settlement . .

.;

2006

10
11

12
13

14

15
16

17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24

25

Wilson,
No
Carl P. v.
Clark,
Harold,
DOC & the
State
of
WA
Roy,
Yes
Nicholas v.
WilsonKirby, Kay
Martin,
Yes
Samuel D.
v.DOC
Yes
Parmelee,
Allan
v.
Clarke,
Harold
Lawson,
Yes
v.
Leslie
DOC
Roy,
Yes
Nicholas v.
Barshaw,
Victoria

Superior
Court
Thurston

05-2-02098-6

216106

$4,534.10

Superior
Court
Spokane

05-2-05800-0

4/1/06

$450.00

Superior
Court
Spokane
Superior
Court
Thurston

05-2-05547-7

4/28/06

$4,500.00

05-2-01317-3

5/21/06

$15,000.00

916106

$2,100.00

12/3/06

$277.94

06-2-08166-6
Superior
Court
Snohomish
05-2-02326-8
Superior
Court
Thurston

$26,612.04
2007

Prison
No
Legal News
v.DOC

Superior
Court
Thurston
County

01-2-00828-2

719107

$541,154.69

26

DEFENDANT'S 1ST ROGS AND RFPS
AND PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS AND
RESPONSES THERETO
NO. 15-2-00672-7

2

....

;·

ATTORNEY GENERAL OF WASHINGTON
Corrections Division
POBox40116
Olympia, WA 98504-0116
(360) 586-1445

1

2
3

4

5
6

7

8
9
10

Greenhalgh
, Shawn v.
DOC
Hutcheson,
James
v.
DOC
·Gronquist,
Derek
v.
DOC
Parmelee,
Allan
v.
Porter,
Carol
Moore,
Douglas L.
v.DOC
Wgeishofsk
i, Eugene v.
DOC

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Superior
Court
Pierce
Superior
Court
Snohomish
Superior
Court
Grays
Harbor
Superior
Court
Mason
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Pierce

07-2-06009-5

915107

$9,500.00

06-2-13022-5

915107

$40,000.00

06-2-01324-3

916107

$2,500.00

06-2-00520-5

10/17/07

$9,641.23

06-2-01040-7

12/3/07

$65,000.00

07-2-05785-0

12/28/07

$9,000.00

11

12
13

14

$676, 795.92
2008
Gronquist,
Derek E. v.
DOC

Yes

15

16
17
18
19

20
21

22
23
24
25

Gronquist,
Derek E. v.
DOC
Elliott,
Samuel J. v.
DOC
Matthews,
Brian
David
v.
DOC

Yes

Yes

Yes

Superior
Court
Spokane
Superior
Court
Clallam
COAil
WDC
Tacoma
Superior
Court
Spokane
Superior
Court
Pierce
Superior
Court
Grays
Harbor

-

-

07-2-00562O/Settled
07-2-002122/Settled
36948-6II/Settled
C065543/Dismissed

5/18/08

$27,500.00

s

02-2-05518-9

5119108

$79,000.00

s

07-2-12105-1

8/29/08

$34,300.00

s

08-2-00269-8

915108

$5,325.00

s

-

$146,125.00

2009
Ashby,
Michael
Eugene v.
DOC

Yes

Superior
Court
Snohomish

08-2-04 778-2

217109

$600.00

s

26
DEFENDANT'S 18TROGS AND RFPS
AND PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS AND
RESPONSES THERETO
NO. 15-2-00672-7

3

ATTORNEY GENERAL OF WASHINGTON
Corrections Division
POBox40116
Olympia, WA 98504-0116
(360) 586-1445

1

2
3
4
5

6
7
8

9
10
11

12
13

14
15
16
17
18
19

20
21

22
23
24

Silva,
Yes
Matthew v.
Francis,
Lyn
&
DOC
Wilder,
Yes
Jack
v.
DOC
Yes
Coats,
Aaron w.
v.DOC
Boyd, Stacy No
v.DOC
Brownowsk
i, Steven E.
v.DOC
Elliott, Sam
v.DOC
Greenhalgh
, Shawn D.
v.DOC
Gallagher,
Douglas v.
DOC
Silva,
Matthew v.
DOC
Volstad,
Steven v.
DOC
Carter,
Germaine
D.v.DOC
Silva,
Matthew v.
DOC
Williams,
v.
Carlos
DOC
Hamlett,
Kevin
Maurice v.
Gaylene
Schave

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Superior
Court
Mason

07-2-00929-2

419109

$320.00

p

08-2-00723-2

513109

$75,000.00

s

08-2-03114-9

6119109

$613.29

p

08-2-02485-1

7/4/09

$80,000.00

s

09-2-00666-8

7/11/09

$2,610.00

s

09-2-00908-0

6123109

$8,325.00

s

07-2-01063-0

7/21/09

$30,000.00

s

08-2-05132-1

9/21/09

$12,000.00

s

08-2-00140-1

11116/09

$2,595.00

p

08-2-06048-7

11/20/09

$15,000.00

s

09-2-01295-1

12/7/09

$500.00

s

07-2-00922-5

11/23/09

$8,085.00

p

08-2-07800-9

5123109

$2,750.00

s

09-2-07703-5

12114/09

$900.00

s

-

Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Spokane
Superior
Court
Spokane
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Clallam
Superior
Court
Snohomish
Superior
Court
Mason
Superior
Court
Snohomish
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Mason
Superior
Court
Snohomish
Superior
Court
Snohomish

$239,298.29

25

26
DEFENDANT'S 15TROGS AND RFPS
AND PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS AND
RESPONSES THERETO
NO. 15-2-00672-7

4

ATI'ORNEY GENERAL OF WASHINGTON
Corrections Division
POBox40116
Olympia, WA 98504-0116
(360) 586-1445

1

2
3
4

5

6
7
8

9
10

11

12
13
14
15
16
17

18
19

20
21

22

23
24

25

2010
Chester,
Yes
David K. v.
DOC
Quinn,
Yes
Daniel R v.
DOC
Bronowski, Yes
Steven E. v.
DOC
Francis,
Yes
Shawn v.
DOC
Levy, Percy Yes
v.DOC
Yes
Gronquist,
v.
Derek
DOC
Greenhalgh Yes
, Shawn D.
v.DOC
Cunningha
m, Carl

Yes

v.
Burt
to
DOC
Parmelee
Francis,
Shawn v.
DOC
Kennedy,
Diane

Yes

Yes

No

WA
St.
COA, Div.

28126-4-ill

3112110

$3,000.00

s

10-2-00572-0

7115/10

$800.00

s

10-2-01711-6

10/25/10

$3,500.00

s

63433-0-1

11/13/10

$484.83

P/Costs Only

10-2-01087-1

12/3/10

$3,161.00

s

08-2-00758-1

1/07/10

$360.00

p

08-2-00431-3

7/7/10

$18,260.00

s

Settlement
only, no cause
#
80998-4

6/10/10

$4,987.50

s

612110

$922.55

P/Costs
Parmelee

08-2-10813-7

12/15/10

$32,355.00

s

Settlement
only, no cause
#

2116110

$1,035.00

s

III
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Thurston
WA
St.
COA, Div.
I
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Clallam
Superior
Court
Grays
Harbor
n/a

WA
St.
Supreme
Court
Superior
Court
Snohomish
n/a

to

$68,865.88
2011
Blick,
Richard v.
DOC
Greenhalgh
, Shawn vs.
DOC
Greenhalgh
, Shawn v.
DOC
Leigh,
v.
Aaron
DOC

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Superior
Court
Snohomish
Superior
Court
Pierce
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Thurston

10-2-05983-9

2/21111

$14,812.50

p

10-2-06108-3

2/24111

$7,000.00

s

08-2-01203-1

3/10111

$35,000.00

s

10-2-02081-8

3/17111

$2,640.00

p

26

DEFENDANT'S 1srROGS AND RFPS
AND PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS AND
RESPONSES THERETO
NO. 15-2-00672-7

5

ATIORNEY GENERAL OF WASHINGTON

Corrections Division
POBox40116

Olympia, WA 98504-0116
(360) 586-1445

1

2
3
4

5

6
7
8

Baker,
Yes
Shappa v.
DOC
Leigh,
Yes
Aaron
v.
DOC
Levy, Percy Yes
v.DOC
Greenhalgh Yes
, Shawn v.
DOC
Greenhalgh Yes
, Shawn v.
DOC
Hill, David Yes
v.DOC

9
10
11

12
13

14
15
16

17
18
19
20
21

22
23
24
25

26

Pecnik,
Gertrude v.
DOC
Mitchell,
Kevin
v.
DOC
Malicoat,
William v.
DOC
Hamilton,
Jimi
vs.
DOC
Ashby,
Michael v.
DOC
McKee,
Jeffrey v.
DOC
McKee,
Jeffrey v.
DOC

No

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Superior
Court
Thurston
n/a

10-2-01552-1

3/25/11

$2,450.00

s

Settlement only,
no cause#

5/10111

$1,000.00

s

Settlement only,
no cause#
09-2-07448-6

5/11/11

$885.00

s

5/26111

$2,680.00

s

09-2-12311-5

6/22111

$3,775.00

s

10-2-02410-4

11/3/11

$11,000.00

s

11-2-02086-7

11/15/1
1

$5,250.00

s

08-2-01287-2

03/29/1
1

$21,245.00

s

11-2-00162-5

1211/11

$1,000.00

s

10-2-08660-7

01/10/1
1

$1,500.00

s

10-2-02835-6

01/1011
1

$1,200.00

s

10-2-05025-1

09/27/1
1

$434.34

P-no fines
awarded, just
costs

09-2-02875

0910711
1

$9,250.00

-

n/a
Superior
Court
Snohomish
Superior
Court
Pierce
Superior
Court
Thurston
Countv
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Snohomish
Superior
Court
Snohomish
Superior
Court
Spokane
Superior
Court
Thurston

s

$121,121.84

2012
Moore,
David
v.
DOC
Forbes,
v.
Susan
DOC
Bronowski,
Steven v.
DOC

Yes

No

Yes

Superior
Court
Spokane
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Thurston

-

11-2-02214-0
11-2-02213-1

5/23/12

$600.00

s

11-2-02379-3

6/4/12

$10,000.00

s

12-2-00151-8

6/5/12

$300.00

s

-

DEFENDANT'S 15TROGS AND RFPS
AND PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS AND
RESPONSES THERETO
NO. 15-2-00672-7

6

A'ITORNEY GENERAL OF WASHINGTON
Corrections Division

POBox40116
Olympia, WA 98504-0116

(360) 586-1445

1

WCOG v.
AG&DOC

No

Chester,
David
DOC
Mitchell,
Kevin
DOC
Ashby,
Michael
DOC
Faulk,
Darren
DOC
Canha
Steven
DOC
Orndorff
Shawn
DOC
Simms
Daniel
DOC
Francis
Shawn
DOC
Faulkner,
Clarence
DOC

Yes

2
3

4
5

6
7

8
9
10
11

12
13

14
15
16

17
18
19
20

21

22
23
24
25

26

v.
.
v.

Yes

Yes
v.
No
v.
Yes
v.
Yes
v.
Yes
v.
Yes
v.
Yes
v.

Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Spokane
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Franklin
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Clallam
Superior
CourtThurston
Superior
CourtSpokane
Superior
Court
Franklin

10-2-00485-5

5/11/12

$32,500.00

s

11-2-00329-3

6/7/12

$1,000.00

P/Contempt
Sanction

08-2-00815-8

6/8/12

$469.90

s

11-2-50491-6

8/8/12

$300.00

s

10-2-02753-7

9/19/12

$173,131.01

p

12-2-00131-3

8/28/12

$18,000.00

s

10-2-01043-5

9/21/12

$5,300.00

s

11-2-00611-2

10/1211
2

$3,000.00

s

12-2-00556-1

11/9/12

$11,650.00

s

12-2-50706-9

12/26/1
2

$2,697.00

s

-

-

-

$258,947.91
2013
Faulkner,
Clarence v.
DOC
Baker,
Shappa v.
DOC
Chester,
David
v.
DOC
McKee,
Jeffrey v.
DOC
McKee,
Jeffrey R.
vs. DOC
McKee,
Jeffrey vs.
DOC

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Superior
Court
Franklin
Superior
Court
Thurston
Superior
Court
Spokane
Superior
Court
Franklin
Superior
Court
Spokane
Superior
Court
Franklin

12-2-51013-2

2/21/13

$600

s

12-2-02491-7

2/22/13

$4000

s

11-2-00329-3

6127113

$100,000

s

13-2-5004 7-0

11/2211
3

s

11-2-02020-1

11/26/1
3

12-2-50391-8

11/27/1
3

$80,000 (part
of a multi-case
settlement)
$80,000 (part
of a multi-case
settlement)
$80,000 (part
of a multi-case
settlement)

·-

-

DEFENDANT'S 1ST ROGS AND RFPS
AND PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS AND
RESPONSES THERETO
NO. 15-2-00672-7

7

s
s

ATTORNEY GENERAL OF WASHINGTON
Corrections Division
POBox401!6
Olympia, WA 98504-0116
(360) 586-1445

1

2

3
4
5
6

7

8
9

10
11

12
13
14
15
16

17
18
19
20

21

22
23
24
25

McKee,
Jeffrey R
Vs. Scilley,
Lee
McKee,
Jeffrey R
vs,
DOC,
et. al.
McKee,
Jeffrey R
vs. DOC,
et. al.
McKee,
Jeffrey R
vs.
DOC,
et.al.
McKee,
Jeffrey vs.
Washington
State
Department
of
Corrections
Baker,
Shappa vs.
DOC
Keefover,
v.
James
DOC

13-2-50726-1

11127/1
3

$80,000 (part
of a multi-case
settlement)

s

08-2-00529-9

11/27/1
3

$80,000 (part
of a multi-case
settlement)

s

08-2-00527-2

12/6/13

$80,000 (part
of a multi-case
settlement)

s

Yes

08-2-00528-1
Superior
Court
Thurston

11127/1
3

$80,000 (part
of a multi-case
settlement)

s

Yes

Superior
Court
Franklin

13-2-50300-2

11127/1
3

$80,000 (part
of a multi-case
settlement)

s

Yes

Superior
12-2-00294-5
Court
Spokane
13-2-51070-0
Superior
Court
Franklin

11/26/1
3

$57,500

s

12/2311
3

$750.00

s

Yes

Superior
Court
Franklin

-

Yes

Superior
Court
Thurston

-

Yes

Superior
Court
Thurston

-

Yes

-

$242,850.00
2014
Faulkner,
Clarence v.
DOC
Faulkner,
c;Iarence v.
DOC
Williams,
Carlos John
vs.
Hinrichsen,
Denise
Williams,
Carlos John
vs. DOC
Ashby,
Michael vs.
DOC

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Superior
13-2-51176-5
Court
Franklin
Superior
13-2-50985-0
Court
Franklin
Superior
13-2-06450-1
Court
Snohomish

14-2-01833-7
Superior
Court
Snohomish
14-2-02686-1
Superior
Court
Snohomish

1124114

1124114

1/16/14

1116/14

3/20/14

$2,500 (part of
a multi-case
settlement)
$2,500 (part of
a multi-case
settlement)
$1,060 (part of
a multi-case
settlement)

$1,060 (part of
a multi-case
settlement)
$600

s
s
s

s
s

26

DEFENDANT'S 1ST ROGS AND RFPS
AND PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS AND .
RESPONSES THERETO
NO. 15-2-00672-7

8

ATTORNEY GENERAL OF WASHINGTON
Corrections Division
PO Box40116

Olympia, WA 98504-0116
(360) 586-1445

1

2
3
4

5
6

7
8

9

Gronquist,
Derek
E.
vs. DOC
Gronquist,
Derek
E.
VS. DOC.
Gronquist,
Derek
E.
vs. DOC.
Francis,
Shawn D.
vs. DOC
Martinez,
Jose
vs.
Department
of
Corrections

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Superior
Court
Franklin
Superior
Court
Snohomish
Superior
Court
Franklin
Superior
Court
Spokane
Superior
Court
Franklin

14-2-50217-9

6116114

13-2-06293-1

6118114

13-2-50749-1

6/16114

12-2-02996-7

7114/14

14-2-50399-0

11119/1
4

s

$20,000 (part
of a multi-case
settlement)
$20,000 (part
of a multi-case
settlement)
$20,000 (part
of a multi-case
settlement)
$22,500

s

$1,778

s

s
s

$48,438.00

10
11

12
13

14
15
16
17
18
19
20

21

22
23
24
25

26

2015
Faulkner,
Clarence J
vs. DOC
Hamilton,
Jimi James
vs.
Washington
State
Department
of
Corrections
Brown,
Eldorado
vs.
Homton, D.
HainesMarchel,
Libby VS.
DOC
Gronquist,
E.
Derek
vs.DOC

Yes

Yes

Yes

Superior
Court
Thurston

$4,615.00

s

3/25/15

$1,756.00

s

15-2-00186-5

5/24115

$1,250.00

s

11-2-02736-5

6/1/15

$9,864.00

p

14-2-51107-1

8/31/15

$529.13

s

-

Yes

Superior
Court
Thurston

-

Yes

Superior
Court
Franklin

Total Pay Out

Year

2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010

3125115

Superior
14-2-04920-8
Court
Snohomish
Superior
15-2-00028-1
Court
Thurston

$5,780.50
$65,331.73
$17,967.82
$26,612.04
$676,795.92
$146,125.00
$239,298.29
$68,865.88

DEFENDANT'S 1STROGS AND RFPS
AND PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS AND
RESPONSES THERETO
NO. 15-2-00672-7

9

ATTORNEY GENERAL OF WASHINGTON
Corrections Division
POBox40116

Olympia, WA 98504-0116
(360) 586-1445

1

2
3

2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
TOTAL

4

$121,121.84
$258,947.91 .
$242,850.00
$48,438.00
$18,014.13
$1,936,149.06

INTERROGATORY 2:

5

Please identify the number of times iri the past seven (7)

6

years that the Department of Corrections has settled a claim of an alleged violation of the

7

Public Records Act by paying money to a requester or his representative.
OBJECTION:

8

This request is vague and ambiguous with respect to the terms

9

"settled" or "alleged." Moreover, this interrogatory is not reasonably calculated to lead to the

10

discovery of admissible evidence as every action in which the Department settled an allegation

11

of the Public Records Act during the specified time period cannot be related to the allegations

12

in Plaintiffs complaint. For similar reasons, this interrogatory is overly broad and unduly

13

burdensome. Plaintiff has equal access to court files if Plaintiff desires additional information.

14

ANSWER:

15

response to Interrogatory 1.

16

Ill

17

Ill

18

Ill

19

Ill

20

Ill

21

Ill

22

Ill

23

Ill

24

Ill

25

Ill

26

Ill

Without waiving the above objections, see the chart provided in

DEFENDANT'S 1STROGS AND RFPS
AND PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS AND
RESPONSES THERETO
NO. 15-2-00672-7

10

AITORNEY GENERAL OF WASHINGTON

Corrections Division
POBox40116
Olympia, WA98504-0!16
(360) 586-1445